3 ms·
They 100% do, because local government regulation has launched the "soft costs" into the stratosphere. A developer has to count on carrying their project for a
by jeffbee 4y ago
They 100% do, because local government regulation has launched the "soft costs" into the stratosphere. A developer has to count on carrying their project for a minimum of 4 years while the city considers their application, their EIR, their design review, their historical resource evaluation, etc etc etc. Even when projects are city-funded, the per-unit costs are generally 600k-1m per unit. See: Berkeley Way/Hope Center, 189 total units on city-donated land for $120 million. See: https://www.latimes.com/homeless-housing/story/2022-06-20/california-affordable-housing-cost-1-million-apartment https://www.latimes.com/homeless-housing/story/2022-06-20/ca...
- dragonwriter 4y ago> They 100% do, because local government regulation has launched the "soft costs" into the stratosphere. Even if that was true, it would be irrelevant in this context, since we are talking about the cost of a hypothetical program that would be enacted through State law, not private action by developers. And State law can (as demonstrated by things like the builders remedy) suspend or otherwise bypass local administrative barriers.
- jeffbee 4y agoThe whole article is about how the bypass is imperfect.
- dragonwriter 4y agoThis subthread, not the article, is about a proposal that the State use its power and funds to directly build housing, and, were it to choose to do so, it could alter the power of subordinate jurisdictions to impede that in any way it chose. So, current local administratively imposed costs are not, legitimately, part of the building cost the state would necessarily face in such a hypothetical, only actual construction costs or federally-imposed administrative costs.
- jeffbee 4y agoHypothetically, the state can dissolve any city with a simple majority vote in the legislature, clearing the decks of any irritating "lead agencies" with bothersome CEQA conclusions. But realistically, the state has only ever dissolved one entity involuntarily. Short of dissolution the state cannot simply ignore local agencies, as we see with UC vs. Berkeley.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Short of dissolution the state cannot simply ignore local agencies No, short of dissolution, it can also adopt any restriction on or state immunity from local authority it wants. (There are some resrictions that might take a ballot measure rather than just the legislature, but since the hypothetical didn’t limit the methods by which the proposed program would be adopted, that is immaterial.) > UC vs. Berkeley. UC, while established by the State, is not coextensive with it and does not independently exercise the full powers of the State.
- jeffbee 4y agoI appreciate both your willingness to follow the replies, and your openness to practical solution that so few seem to consider. This isn't a federal system where the cities have real powers. All the power in our state lies with the state, but the state government so seldom exercises it.