3 ms·
"In studies where they offer one group of undergrads money to complete some random task and another group does it for free?" The studies are pretty wide rangin
by Alex3917 18y ago
"In studies where they offer one group of undergrads money to complete some random task and another group does it for free?"
The studies are pretty wide ranging. For example, people paid to wear their seatbelts are less likely to do so. People who are offered money if they lose weight are less successful, and are more likely to gain even more weight. If teachers are offered money if their students improve on a test, the students will do worse on the test. Students who study something in an attempt to get a good grade will have a more superficial understanding of the material than they would otherwise.
"Things work differently at the other end of the expertise spectrum."
Maybe that's true once your work is at the genius level and you don't need any more external validation, but even if so how do you get there? If you've been mastering your craft for twenty years and then you're offered money it might not be damaging, if done right, but being offered money too soon may well harm the average person.
"The great artists couldn't bring themselves to produce shit, any more than great people in any field ever can."
George Lucas.
- erik 18y agoThere is debate about the impact of reward on motivation. Motivation is a complex thing. http://www.physorg.com/news4126.html http://www.physorg.com/news4126.html "George Lucas" I think that George Lucas has very aptly demonstrated that he is not a great artist. He got lucky with Star Wars. With his next two movies he had the sense to let someone else direct. Then he let the success go to his head.
- Alex3917 18y ago“There are many children for whom the important reward to them is the grades they get, the competition among classmates,” Reiss said. “This goes against what some psychologists say, who think competition is bad and a non-competitive attitude is good, and that learning and curiosity are intrinsic values that everyone shares. They are pushing their own value system on to everybody.” That last sentence is extremely disingenuous. I would be like to read the his original argument though.