3 ms·
This feels like bait and I'm surprised it is at the top. Here's why it feels like bait: - Who is ranting about the free market. Republicans? Really just a sele
by godelski 4y ago
This feels like bait and I'm surprised it is at the top. Here's why it feels like bait:
- Who is ranting about the free market. Republicans? Really just a select few and only in specific contexts. But they haven't ever voted in that interest so I'm not sure this is anything new.
- It feels like it is implying China has the moral upper hand. The same country who takes US invented products and sells them 10x cheaper under a different brand, violating international intellectual property laws. Buy Spot for $75k or Weilan's Alpha Dog or Unitree's Go for $2.5k?
- China complains about US taking their technology and talent while taking US technology and talent. Is this not hypocritical, double-standard protectionism, or even economic warfare?
- The comment implies that one side is morally right and the other isn't. Instead it is quite possible that the two have been engaged in soft economic warfare for decades and that neither is morally "right" (who has the high ground is arguable, but they definitely both are in the mud).
- This comment is boiling the situation down and decades of (complex) context into a singular point of time and singular action. It discourages looking at the events that led to this event and why the choices involved were made. This is bad faith.
So I want to encourage discussion on the topic, but I don't understand how this comment is anything but bait. It is reactionary and promoting reactionary comments. I suggest others don't take the bait.
If I'm wrong in my analysis I'm open to it. But I needed to explain why I don't think this comment is engaging in good faith nor promoting a healthy and fruitful discussion.
- soperj 4y ago> - It feels like it is implying China has the moral upper hand. The same country who takes US invented products and sells them 10x cheaper under a different brand, violating international intellectual property laws. Buy Spot for $75k or Weilan's Alpha Dog or Unitree's Go for $2.5k? This is right out of the USA playbook from the the late 1700s. << Under the Patent Act of 1793, the United States barred foreign inventors from receiving patents at the same time as granting patents to Americans who had pirated technology from other countries. “America thus became, by national policy and legislative act, the world’s premier legal sanctuary for industrial pirates. Any American could bring a foreign innovation to the United States and commercialize the idea, all with total legal immunity.” >> [0] [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_United_States_patent_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_United_States_paten...
- godelski 4y agoI'm not sure what this comment means. The US doing something bad 200 years ago doesn't justify the bad actions of today. Either it is bad in both cases or it is okay/good in both cases. It is unclear which you are saying because I'm interpreting it as whatbaoutism. That's not productive nor in good faith. Especially referencing something that happened 200 years ago. There were a lot of bad stuff that we did 200 years ago and that doesn't matter who "we" is. Thomas Jefferson was still Secretary of State at this time. The nation was less than 20 years old. That applies to literally every country on the planet. We've all progressed. But also, this problem was resolved by 1836, when foreigners could be granted patents. Thomas Jefferson had only been dead for 10 years by this time. This is still decades before the civil war and a century before America became part of the global stage. There were only 25 US states at this time and it wasn't long after the Louisiana Purchase happened. Decades before Texas was annexed. So I'm extra confused. This comment too feels like bait because I can't find any relevance to the conversation at hand. It appears to be pure distraction and not in good faith. No one is saying America didn't do a lot of bad shit in the past (Americans are pretty open about our historical atrocities). But in absolutely no way do historical atrocities justify actions of today. I mean what, are you going to say that the Trail of Tears justifies genocide of Ughygurs or that it justifies Hitler killing the Jews? Clearly it doesn't. All these things are wrong. Now and then. One historical wrong doing in absolutely no way shape or manner justifies modern wrongdoings. Please don't astroturf.
- unity1001 4y ago> The US doing something bad 200 years ago doesn't justify the bad actions of today The US has always done it. It backstabbed the Brits and the French, stealing their nuclear fission research and not giving them access to Manhattan Project. It kept doing corporate spying on everyone including its allies using ECHELON. So much that a few years ago entire US State Dept. diplomat cadre were ordered to do corporate spying by the US State Dept itself.
- unity1001 4y ago> Who is ranting about the free market. Republicans? The US, the UK, all its satellites. It was 40 years of 'free trade and free market for all' cacophony. Everyone were either persuaded to it, or were coup'ed or bombed into doing it. But now that the US is losing the competition, voila, suddenly free market is not cool anymore. But its ok - the US can bring back protectionism and mercantilism under the excuse 'national security'. No one will bat an eye in Angloamerica. > - The comment implies that one side is morally right and the other isn't. The comment does not imply that. It outright says that. The US has been pushing 'free market' down everyone's throats. Now that it is losing the competition, its literally eating its own words. That's morally wrong. > This comment is boiling the situation down and decades of (complex) context There is no complex context in this. The US has always employed double-speak. It was 'free market for me, not for thee'. Even the closest allies were subjected to tariffs and quotas in order to be able to export anything to the US even at the heyday of 'free market'. So it was doublespeak from the start. Today, we just see the dropping of the public facade of something that the US was always doing. Japanese would know - they got the Plaza Accords. China is bad, because it did not even entertain signing any such sociopathic document.
- godelski 4y ago>> Who is ranting about the free market. Republicans? > The US, the UK, all its satellites. It was 40 years of 'free trade and free market for all' cacophony. Everyone were either persuaded to it, or were coup'ed or bombed into doing it. I'm not sure why you are cherry picking my argument. This too feels like bait. You're painting with a really broad brush, putting things into neat aggregated boxes, and ignoring the difference between history and current days. I also don't think one country doing wrong in the past (or even currently) justifies another country doing wrong. Can we just all agree that if something is wrong that it doesn't matter who does it? I've assumed this is such a non-controversial statement that it need not be said, but it appears I am wrong.
- unity1001 4y ago> I'm not sure why you are cherry picking my argument. This too feels like bait It likely feels so because especially the people who live in the US have internalized all the propaganda. You are born into the 'free market' propaganda, and you never notice that it exists. Hence you don't notice any stark difference. But overseas, the 'free market' propaganda was an immutable cacophony that dominated the privately owned press for ~40 years now. All the neoliberal reforms that were pushed on our countries were pushed by being backed and rationalized on that propaganda. And now all the principles that were sold to us are being invalidated, being proven to be lies from the start. > Can we just all agree that if something is wrong that it doesn't matter who does it? Really, we cannot - there is one country that pushed all of this onto ENTIRE world. Forcing them to adopt its false religion and to privatize, literally sell out everything in every country to corporate profit. We got coups, regime changes, invasions, bombins to make it happen. The US did it. This is still going on. It hasnt gone anywhere. Even as the US itself closing its economy to everyone, its still forcing others to open up its economy. Calling this out is long overdue. And that is something everyone including you, should do. Because the establishment that is responsible with this has no qualms in destroying its own for profit like it destroyed everyone else. And it is already doing that. Its amazing how this even needs to be said...