3 ms·
Hydralox is worst of both worlds. To get out of gravity well thrust/weight is key, and Raptor is king at that. In deep space ISP is key, and ion thrusters
by bryanlarsen 4y ago
Hydralox is worst of both worlds. To get out of gravity well thrust/weight is key, and Raptor is king at that. In deep space ISP is key, and ion thrusters are way more efficient than hydrolox at that. People don't realize that SpaceX is perhaps the world's largest manufacturer of ion thrusters since they use them on Starlink.
- avmich 4y agoStorage time is also important, and it's likely easier to store long term (Earth-Mars flight time is months) mid-cryogenic LOX and liquid methane rather than deep-cryogenic LH2.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y ago"To get out of gravity well thrust/weight is key" this isn't really true. TWR matters a lot for the first stage, but by the seccond stage, higher ISP and lower TWR is worth it as long as thrust is reasonable. ion thrusters are great for light unmanned probes but anything heavy needs higher thrust and hydralox is key for that. Ion propulsion is also pretty much worthless past jupiter since you can't get enough electricity.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoPast Jupiter hydrolox is unusable because of boil-off issues. The best option past Jupiter is nuclear electric, aka ion propulsion. If you need both thrust & efficiency, a large number of ion thrusters is often a good option.