3 ms·
> My pet theory is that this is the reason why Siri, Alexa and co. still are shit and haven't moved an inch forward since their inception. I can't comment much
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
> My pet theory is that this is the reason why Siri, Alexa and co. still are shit and haven't moved an inch forward since their inception.
I can't comment much on Siri or Alexa, but Google Assistant has gotten heaps better at understanding my voice and intent since it was first released about 6 years ago. It used to pretty reliably misunderstand at least 1 word per sentence (which made for an extremely frustrating experience originally); now, at least for me, it's extremely rare that it misunderstands me.
This would point to the problem being company-specific, and not a fundamental issue with the "black box" aspect of the technology.
- o_____________o 4y agoSiri's total impotence was one of the most surprising issues when I switched from stock Android to iPhone a couple years ago. I'm curious what's going on inside Apple to produce something this poor in their core product.
- outworlder 4y agoInteresting. Alexa misunderstands me _a lot_. There are a few commands I use very often, but somehow they don't rank high enough. I have one Google Assistant I got for free. I'll try it. Most of what I want Alexa to do is interfacing with Home Assistant anyway.
- tuatoru 4y agoWhen asked, Google assistant claims it's sticking around for good. But we know better.
- drekipus 4y agoI have precisely the opposite with my Google home speaker. Also a reduction of functionality, as I used to be able to read some messages and set a reminder, but now it just gives me the time and plays Spotify music. I like voice commands, but I like them working reliably. I can't believe there was like an open-source zapier-like voice command API that could be used for everything and maintained properly.