8 ms·
'Planet killer' asteroid found hiding in sun's glare may one day hit Earth
- no_butterscotch 4y agoI'm always surprised we don't take these threats more seriously. "But we have enough problems down here that need fixing!", "The odds of all civilization being destroyed by that asteroid is only .5%!", "It will cost too much and the odds are low" You'd think protecting all the things we hold dear, family, culture, art, friends, the future - would be a priority.
- zasdffaa 4y agoI do think we should be "protecting all the things we hold dear, family, culture, art, friends, the future", which is why I prioritise eg. climate change, it is a far greater threat.
- pif 4y agoApart from the really tiny ones, there's nothing we can do.
- thehappypm 4y agoTens of thousands of hydrogen bombs can deflect something big.
- pif 4y agoNo, they can't. You need momentum, and no explosion can provide any global momentum.
- thehappypm 4y agoSure they can. They blow a thousand tons of surface off.
- pif 4y agoNo explosion can modify the total momentum.
- thehappypm 4y agoImagine an asteroid made of ice. detonate a nuke near its surface. Super heated steam will eject from the surface at high speeds. Momentum conserved, and energy from the nuke absorbed by the water and turned into kinetic energy.
- n4r9 4y agoYou don't need to modify total momentum in order to divert the course of an object. Think about how a combustion engine works.
- more_corn 4y agoYou don’t even need that. A solar panel and an ion drive will work wonders over time. Heck a solar sail would do the trick.
- throwaway4aday 4y agoThis asteroid was detected by a telescope that > scans the sky during twilight hours when these asteroids can be detected within two 10-minute periods each day 20 minutes per day per telescope. Talk about an under investment in something that may save our lives. I hope that we can soon launch more space based telescopes capable of observing the inner orbits 24/7 using some kind of sun shade or occluding device. We need to dedicate a lot more time and resources to this.
- pif 4y agoThere are so many things that may save our lives, in a huge number of theoretically possible scenarios, that we must choose our priorities.
- throwaway4aday 4y agoAn asteroid impact isn't theoretical. It's a statistical certainty like Russian roulette, just because the gun hasn't gone off yet doesn't mean it's safe to put it to your head and pull the trigger.
- pif 4y agoHow many people have ever been killed by an asteroid? And how many by earthquakes? Even considering just astrophysics, we have more pressing problems.
- JPKab 4y agoIt only takes one asteroid to end all life on earth. It's not a possibility, it's an inevitability. It's happened before, it will happen again, unless the hairless, bipedal fire apes that have proliferated on the planet use their newfound technology to redirect the asteroid slightly while it's far enough away.
- pif 4y agoThe rock that hit our planet 65 million years ago had a diameter of around 10 km. What do you think we may do about that?
- aliqot 4y agoMake hay while the sun shines.
- aliqot 4y agoWhat if all the war-mongering of late was to manifest funding and support to engineer the defense systems to prevent this, without causing undue distress of the populace? Someone feed this to an AI thing, I need this book.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoThere are a lot of undiscovered large asteroids. Even near earth asteroids >1km in size are not 100% known.
- _fat_santa 4y agoWe often hear in science fiction that if an asteroid were to come barreling towards earth, we could somehow either change it's trajectory or break it up into multiple pieces by shooting it with a ICBM/nuclear weapon/etc. What truth is there to this? Suppose this asteroid was on a collision course with earth, would we have any recourse other than praying it lands in Siberia and not NYC.
- alex_duf 4y agoAt this sort of scale I don't think it makes a big difference that it hits Siberia, the middle of the Pacific, or wherever you're living. In fact maybe it's better to take it directly on your head.
- gcanyon 4y agoOn the flip side, it's maybe 1/300th the size of the one that killed the dinosaurs. So, definitely not great, but survivable. (obviously with major death, destruction, and setback to humanity)
- shagie 4y ago> What truth is there to this? Suppose this asteroid was on a collision course with earth, would we have any recourse other than praying it lands in Siberia and not NYC. Astrodynamic Fundamentals for Deflecting Hazardous Near-Earth Objects - https://www.adrc.iastate.edu/files/2012/09/IAC-09.C1.3.1.pdf https://www.adrc.iastate.edu/files/2012/09/IAC-09.C1.3.1.pdf That paper goes into the what it would take to divert an asteroid (with emphasis on Apophis).
- jjk166 4y agoDepends on timing. ICBMs can only reach an altitude of about 1300km and are not designed to hit moving targets in space anyways, so if an asteroid is going to hit us in the next few days we're screwed. However implementing a system to defend against asteroids even with short notice is feasible. We can make rockets much larger than ICBMs and put them on standby for planetary defense. You'd presumably put appropriate sensors and maneuvering thrusters for getting to the approrpiate position near or on the target, akin to the interceptors used in missile defense. Interceptors would have a dedicated 3rd stage like the Centaur to launch them on trajectories away from Earth - the further away the interception the smaller the necessary deflection. Ideally you'd catch it early and start the deflection so far away that a kinetic impactor or even just the craft's gravitation would nudge it to a safe course, but for short notice you need to go nuclear. Breaking up an asteroid into smaller pieces with a nuke is possible, especially for the subset of asteroids which are basically loosely held together piles of gravel. Some people think this is a bad idea as instead of 1 big rock to deal with now you have lots of little rocks that are also radioactive, but that actually is a much preferable situation. The ability of objects to pass through the atmosphere is dependent on their diameter, lots of small rocks will burn up harmlessly while a single big one will impact. The radioactivity from the nuke would be spread out extremely dilute, and specific nuclear weapon designs which minimize neutron activation can keep the radioactivity very low. A more serious concern is that you don't know the trajectories of the resulting fragments, some of which might still be dangerous, and thus it would be a very bad idea to destroy it before impact was a certainty, but then waiting until the last minute to stop it is a major risk in itself. More safe would be to detonate the nuclear device near the asteroid. This would vaporize a thin layer of the surface of the asteroid in line of sight of the explosion, sending it flying off into space at extremely high velocity and propelling the asteroid equally in the opposite direction. There are two major advantages to this approach: it will work against targets regardless of their composition and internal structure (very beneficial if we don't have time to study the asteroid ahead of time) and the method can be done repeatedly to the same target - we could launch dozens of independent interceptors and just keep detonating them one by one until we get the desired result. While the goal is to have the asteroid not impact at all, and thus radioactivity is even less of a concern, this option does produce even less radioactivity than blowing up the asteroid. From a strictly technical perspective this option is pretty much a no brainer, but obviously building a battery of dozens of nuclear missiles is politically problematic.
- m3047 4y agoThere was a reference to DART in that article, here are some pictures. https://www.space.com/dart-asteroid-crash-first-photos-liciacube https://www.space.com/dart-asteroid-crash-first-photos-licia...
- gerikson 4y agoClassic WW2 fighter pilot tactic.
- IntrepidWorm 4y agoThey actually just issued a retraction: apparently it was just Tom Cruise.
- progre 4y ago"Beware of the Hun in the sun" WW1 too apparently https://www.rafmuseum.org.uk/research/archive-exhibitions/worth-a-thousand-words-air-diagrams/beware-of-the-hun-in-the-sun/ https://www.rafmuseum.org.uk/research/archive-exhibitions/wo...