5 ms·
As someone that uses RHEL coz of some of our customers need it, I can get their point. RHEL might be open source but it is structured (obviously) to sell the s
by ilyt 4y ago
As someone that uses RHEL coz of some of our customers need it, I can get their point.
RHEL might be open source but it is structured (obviously) to sell the support license. You can't "just" install DRBD like on every other distro, you need to get the storage whatever the fuck pack, or get the packages from EPEL. In Debian DRBD module just comes with kernel, need to install it on RHEL etc.
It's annoying to manage even as paid customer and wholly worse experience than just installing Debian.
- rbanffy 4y ago> It's annoying to manage even as paid customer and wholly worse experience than just installing Debian. All that is mostly solved with CentOS. I really don't get the people so upset about it.
- bayindirh 4y agoFor some of us, using an older but way more tested and more stable version is equally important. CentOS stream moves the release point to (RHEL+1), which sometimes break things in unexpected ways. This is why we also migrating to Rocky on such systems.
- rbanffy 4y agoYou can always pin your package versions (or image hash) to whatever is in RHEL. So far, all my CentOS stream boxes have been remarkably stable. And that's for my pets. The cattle is blissfully unaware of anything different.
- bayindirh 4y agoLooks like our environments are different. The environment we use is a descendant of Scientific Linux, so we always worked in (RHEL-1) environments. So pinning to RHEL is not helping us, again.
- rbanffy 4y agoYou can have a single RHEL8 reference (not sure how hard is to get the full RHEL BOM) to base your versions from and use the CentOS repos as source for the packages themselves. My CentOS boxes are pulling straight from 9 stream. I had an issue with Grafana today I’m still figuring out.
- mekster 4y agoYour environment is that important but never considered actually using RHEL (or Ubuntu ESM)? > sometimes break things in unexpected ways I have faith on RH to keep CentOS stream to be quite stable now that it runs on its own brand. I can't understand how people had super faith on CentOS when it was run by a community which even had someone lock up the organization's fund/asset at some point.
- vbezhenar 4y agoPeople believe that RHEL is rock stable. People believe that CentOS was the same RHEL for free. Bit to bit. May be with changed logos. So people believed that they’ll get rock stable system for free by using CentOS. They believed it so much that it hurted RHEL sales. None of those beliefs were correct. But lost sales were real.
- touisteur 4y agoOne day I'd like to know whether sales were really hurt or it's like 'we've been downloaded 1 million times our single is 5usd, we could have made 5musd' we'... Well no.
- bayindirh 4y agoPeople think that we use CentOS because we’re cheap. The reality is the software we use is certified against it. We’re a supercomputing center. We’re federated. Everybody is using CentOS. So, we also use CentOS on our pets sometimes because it reduces administration load. We’re using it for years. We can patch it if we need it. We can submit patches if we need it. We use CentOS as a multinational community, which is completely different from “Hey, look! Free RHEL!”. We’ll see where we gonna evolve. Stream? Rocky? Alma? It’s will be a collective decision. For some pets we migrated to Rocky, and we’re happy, for now.
- mekster 4y agoDo you mind sharing how you decided to go with Rocky instead of the others?
- j33zusjuice 4y agoWhy Rocky? Why trust the guy that sold to RHEL once already? Why not Alma that has a stated commitment to never sell to a private corporation? Alma also has a stated turn around time for security patches of 2-3 business days, something I have not seen from Rocky. If we decide we can’t afford 100% RHEL licensing, Alma was my choice, but I see so many choosing Rocky, and I’m genuinely curious why people are doing that.
- ensignavenger 4y agoEither appear to be acceptable choices. Looking at their respective websites, they both make similiar commitments to remaining independent. From what I found, the Rocky website actually makes the commitment in stronger terms than the Alma website.
- iamwpj 4y agoHe sold to RHEL and then RHEL sold to IBM and then CentOS was changed. I don't think selling to RHEL is the condemning move here.
- dralley 4y agoThe change had nothing to do with IBM. I know people view this with skepticism, but it's true. The primary purpose of CentOS Stream is this: to allow a real community to be built around CentOS, where partners and users can contribute. With CentOS if you encountered a bug your only option was to file it against RHEL (not CentOS), wait for someone at Red Hat to get to it, then wait for RHEL to pick it up and release it. You would be very lucky for that whole process to complete within 6 months and if you're not a customer you probably won't be able to test a hotfix on your own systems. Whereas with Stream: partners and downstream developers can file issues directly against Stream, and then contribute fixes directly to Stream, where they get QA'd in public and are added directly to the future release of RHEL. So Oracle Linux, Rocky, Alma and anyone else can actually participate in the process and contribute back instead of having to just take whatever RH throws over the wall. However, the messaging and timelines around all of this were handled... not well, and some of the acrimony around that is reasonable even if the changes make sense.
- tyingq 4y agoAll that was mostly solved with CentOS. Changing from a downstream to an upstream distro changes what it is.
- rbanffy 4y agoOnly if you update everything blindly.
- tyingq 4y agoSaid another way, "only if you don't meticulously map everything to what's stable".
- rbanffy 4y agoI'm sure there is an easy way to automate that.
- tyingq 4y agoThat feature is the essence of why most people used CentOS in the first place though.
- rbanffy 4y agoYou can think of it as RHEL tracks CentOS and has it's point releases spun out of that. There is no reason to think CentOS stream will break more often than RHEL does, because, if that happens, it's Red Hat shooting its own foot.
- vbezhenar 4y agoOpen source does not mean that you can just install it. I understand that for majority of open source projects that’s true, but definitions are definitions. May be we should invent better terms like non-commercial free software and commercial free software and set some expectations for the first category. But still Rocky Linux is possible only because Red Hat provides sources for its distribution. There’s no Rocky Windows.