3 ms·
> Even Gruber can't manage to fake gushing over it Is a non sequitur insult really necessary to this part of your post?
by jacobolus 15y ago
> Even Gruber can't manage to fake gushing over it
Is a non sequitur insult really necessary to this part of your post?
- bane 15y agoI think so. And it wasn't intended as an insult. Gruber's one-sided treatment of Apple is pretty well acknowledged and understood. He's used as the benchmark, somebody who is virtually obliged to like whatever Apple does, and even he can't muster a favorable opinion about it. The problem with the original article is that it assumes that whatever Apple does must be good, which is flawed thinking. To use it as a counterweight to the problems in Android apps is fundamentally flawed. Using Gruber as the far end of the scale was intentional and not insulting. After all, calling a Banana yellow isn't insulting is it? It is what it is and Gruber is who he is. He serves his purpose as the thought leader championing the Apple way. Plus it wasn't non-sequitur, Gruber was specifically talking about the trend towards Skeuomorphism in Apple's design language as a bad thing.
- jamesgeck0 15y agoWhile I appreciate your reasoning, a quote from someone like Jakob Nielsen might have been a stronger choice.
- bane 15y agoHave any suggestions of quotes germane to the discussion?