3 ms·
Can Mastodon ever reach the scale of Twitter? Does their architecture answer the question of what happens when Obama tweets an image to 150 million followers? H
by jeffbee 4y ago
Can Mastodon ever reach the scale of Twitter? Does their architecture answer the question of what happens when Obama tweets an image to 150 million followers? Hopefully the answer is not "the local Mastodon instance owner gets a $100k AWS bill next month."
Currently Mastodon.social, which I understand to be the largest instance, has tragic performance with only ~125k users. Every page load takes multiple minutes. It leaves me wondering how Mastodon can replace Twitter in practice.
Edit: and when I say "multiple minutes" that's an estimate ... it's been several minutes and there's no sign that it will ever render.
- kornhole 4y agoMany servers/communities exist in which you might find a good home, but you will need to live with their rules and moderation policies. If you are a politician, journalist, or other high profile person who wants full control to avoid censorship, trolling, and cancellation, get your own domain name. I recommend gandi.net, but other registrars are available. If you already have a domain name, we use a subdomain such as social.yourdomain.com. 1. Setup your own Mastodon instance that you fully control. You have several options here: a. If you already have your site hosted on a server, you can co-host it there. b. If you want someone to take care of all the install and maintenance, contact someone such as https://masto.host/ https://masto.host/. c. If you want to run it from hardware sitting in your office or home, you have many options to do that too. 2. Setup your server rules, logo, and users such as your staffers. 3. Go to https://twitodon.com/ https://twitodon.com/ and register your new account connected to your Twitter account. Also update your home page with this account if you have one. 4. Setup RSS for all the people still tweeting instead of tooting using https://rss-bridge.org/ https://rss-bridge.org/ or https://nitter.net/about https://nitter.net/about to get their RSS feeds.
- jeffbee 4y agoThat did not really answer the question. Twitter allows me to disseminate a photo or video to the entire world, at no risk to myself, for free. How does mastodon address the use case?
- kornhole 4y agoAnybody following your account will receive that toot and photo unless the server they are on has blocked your server or your account. I don't believe there are any limitations to how far your toots can fly other than that.
- jeffbee 4y agoNothing about the current performance of prominent mastodon instances suggests their ability to disseminate messages is unlimited.
- kornhole 4y agoThat is due to too many users jumping on when the servers were not sized for the amount of activity. My server is doing just fine, but I have a relatively small number of users and activity.
- kornhole 4y agoAnd to answer the question about bandwidth: If Obama with 150K followers spread across 1500 servers posts a 200KB image: Obama's server will: - have an outbound bandwidth of 300MB - storage increased by 200KB. The 1500 subscribing servers will: - each have inbound bandwidth of 200KB - have outbound bandwidth to devices of 20MB if they have 100 users each - increase storage by 200KB Those subscribers can boost(retweet) the toot, and then their subscribers will see it too. If they are on the same servers, the increase in bandwidth is only getting it to their devices. - increase in storage of 200KB
- yborg 4y agoMastodon is Ruby on the backend ... as was Twitter in the beginning, and Twitter also fell over when it reached a certain size and had to be reimplemented. So present Mastodon won't scale to Twitter size, no. It's also not the goal, people seem to assume that Mastodon is a Twitter clone that has exactly the same experience and feel the need to post how shocked and disappointed they are when they discover this is not in fact true. Fediverse is a different model for social media which prioritizes decentralization over ease of use, where "ease of use" means being able to easily be spoonfed entertainment in bite-sized pieces. I personally don't feel it will ever be a majoritarian platform and that's perfectly fine. There are plenty of ways for people to find out what BTS is doing and not every platform needs to optimize for this purpose.
- jeffbee 4y agoThis dismissive attitude of "my nerds are better than your sheep" is why this federated nerd b.s. never really takes off.