8 ms·
Is Google getting worse? Why critics say ads, spam sites are killing search
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pcurve 4y ago90 percent of my Google search now has “Reddit” appended. Otherwise the result utterly useless especially on mobile phone where there’s no Adblock
- constantcrying 4y agoBrave supports addblocking on both android and iOS. Firefox does at least on Android.
- cyanydeez 4y agoPerfect, now just create a site like reddit, remove people, insert Wikipedia, and you got something everyone will value, but pay nothing for.
- cr4nberry 4y agoI think you just hit the jackpot
- 2pEXgD0fZ5cF 4y agoDepending on the topic and search query it at least has become harder to find information written by actual human beings, and not some garbage sites 100% created and designed for SEO. These sites typically contain lots of generated (or at least mindlessly typed) filler text. Sometimes they have some information inbetween this gibberish, sometimes they completely look like they came out of a markov chain generator. Because of this it is often necessary to append something like "reddit", "forum", "wiki", or "news" to my search, lest I only encounter SEO trash. I believe I can estimate with confidence that Bing and DuckDuckGo are nowadays better than Google during half of my searches. And that was certainly not the case 2 years ago.
- donmcronald 4y ago> These sites typically contain lots of generated (or at least mindlessly typed) filler text. They’ll also optimize for “high value” keywords even though the content doesn’t match and that’s exacerbated even more by Google doing a terrible job of picking synonyms. A good example is reboot vs reset. I literally can’t even find instructions to force reboot a phone anymore.
- fetus8 4y agoI switched to DDG a few years back, but whenever I accidentally search via Google, every result feels like an ad. Not sure how anyone actually uses it anymore. I've converted most of my coworkers away from Google and they've all mentioned how much different results are on DDG, Bing or even Alta, and how much better the results are. Bye Google!
- Ygg2 4y agoYes. Recent example was searching some old card mechanic wrapped in spooky tale. Resorted to searching a Subreddit.
- mattnewton 4y agoShopping in particular seems iffy for me. I used to use Google shopping to find deals, but increasingly the results are full of scams. I bought a baratta encore grinder new for what looked like MSRP with free shipping off a site highly ranked in Google shopping. It never arrived, I had to dispute the charge with my credit card company, and the site disappeared a couple of months later. Now if I search "nvidia 4090" on shopping, the top organic result is a card at "Orvamini" that claims to still be in stock at MSRP.[0] I don't believe it after clicking around the site, they have all kinds of high end electronics that are sold out everywhere, at or below MSRP and I have never heard of the brand. For example, they could easily sell this card for over $2k, or 50% more than the below-msrp price they have currently listed, on eBay or stockx.[1] [0] https://www.google.com/shopping/product/5873870201295230510?q=4090+nvidia&client=ms-android-google&biw=412&bih=790&tbs=vw:l&prmd=sniv https://www.google.com/shopping/product/5873870201295230510?... [1] https://orvamini.com/product/nvidia-geforce-rtx-4090-founders-edition-graphics-card-24gb-gddr6x-titanium-and-black/ https://orvamini.com/product/nvidia-geforce-rtx-4090-founder...
- cma 4y agoHotel booking results in Google Maps are almost all scams. They don't care because they use it to force the hotel to pay for a sponsored ranking in the booking listings to be up high.
- donmcronald 4y agoI know people who have been scammed by middleman ads. Search to buy flowers in a specific area and there’s a good chance the top ad will be a middleman that will take your order and flip it to a local business. You’ll think you’re buying a fancy (expensive) flower arrangement, but the middleman will order something small (and cheap) on your behalf. You overpay while the recipient of the flowers gets something mediocre at best. The exact thing happened to my mother while trying to send flowers for a relative’s funeral. She paid something close to $200, the local shop got a small order, and some grifter got a bunch of easy money for gaming the system. But hey! As long as Google gets their cut for the ad / referral the collateral damage of grifting seniors is just smart business, right?
- thomassmith65 4y ago"Hey, maybe this is the year Google starts to improve!" /s Web search plays a relatively important role in everyday life today. Personally I'm averse to using products or services, even if they are currently 'okay', once I see they are on the downward trajectory.
- musicale 4y ago> "Hey, maybe this is the year Google starts to improve!" /s Sure, may have been wrong in the past, but 2023 will definitely be the year of: - improved google search - linux on the desktop - mac gaming - ps5 availability at msrp - post-pandemic recovery - fiber to the home - quantum computing - explainable ML/AI systems - non-scammy crypto - distributed internet - a web that doesn't suck - secure and reliable computing - better netflix programs and selection - ???
- miohtama 4y agoDid they launch Duke Nukem Forever yet?
- sebastien_b 4y ago> fiber to the home This one is becoming real for me this year.
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 4y agoI've had fiber at home since 2007.
- musicale 4y agoA rare exception to Betteridge's law of headlines. Google (google.com) provides a very poor experience for anyone looking for web search results that aren't 1) ads or Google properties (above the fold) or 2) spammy SEO garbage (below the fold.)
- footlose_3815 4y ago[dead]
- ranUltra 4y agoGoogle Search has become so bad that I have even changed my search habits: If it is a topic, I use the Wikipedia app to search for it, if I want opinions, then I go on Reddit. But I have to say Google Lens has gotten superb at searching in real life.
- andrei_says_ 4y agoWhat used to be useful intelligent search results with some ads sprinkled around has been transformed into ads with a few poisoned search results sprinkled around. Yes I do believe that’s worse.
- MichaelZuo 4y ago100% There's so much junk nowadays that verbatim search with key phrases is the only way to get a decent signal to noise ratio.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- oldgradstudent 4y agoAny query that is even somewhat related to legal matters gives me pages and pages of law offices with very low quality almost identical content. I was looking for traffic fatality statistics trying to compare taxis vs Uber vs average drivers and all I get are lawyers offering their services. Great SEO work, terrible search experience.
- janesvilleseo 4y agoLegal content is highly monetized. I have had trouble finding similar content. Often these are buried in PDF reports by state agencies. There are some federal resources out there depending on what you need. But those are often hard to navigate too. For something like what you want you may have to compile the date separately to compare it. But yes, attorney SEO is a huge business
- freediver 4y agoCan you share the actual query you used?
- nicbou 4y agoYes. Most of my searches fail. No matter how I formulate my queries, Google shows me mostly unrelated results, and seems to ignore a big part of the internet. For "is it just me?" searches, I manually search Twitter and Reddit. For best product or service searches, I have simply given up. I only get Nepali restaurant recommendations from a Brit with a blog who spent 3 days there. Product recommendations are pure affiliate spam. Good luck finding critical reviews of anything. For programming searches, I click the same few websites, and heavily filter the results with uBlacklist. In the end, it's usually stackoverflow and a few self-hosted programming blogs. For some reason w3schools keeps outranking MDN. Software problem searches ("how to do X in Android") just lead to generic troubleshooting websites that sell software or malware. I have an ad blocker of course. I was shocked to see what Google results look like without one. My website isn't the first result like I thought, but hidden below half a dozen ads. I'm just tired of modern tech. It's just broken recommendation engines and coercive UIs.
- freediver 4y agoHave you considered using a paid search engine? It is a miracle what alignment of incentives can do for search quality.
- forgotmypw17 4y agoI always choose w3schools over MDN because: * w3school's examples are no-nonsense and much easier to understand, with simple working examples. MDN's pages typically read more like academic references. * w3schools typically choose compatibility over the most "modern" way to write something, and compatibility matters a lot to me. MDN basically ignores most browsers that are not in the dominant majority. * w3schools pages are simple and load faster and are less gimmicky. MDN has weird markup with multiple scrollable areas on the same page, which is completely inaccessible to me.
- jemmyw 4y agoI've switched to kagi.com, a paid search service. It started out kind of slow but ok results, but it has only improved over time. I like the programming specific filter. It's location based results are better than Google or DDG, which is great when I'm shopping for stuff as what is available here is pretty limited. No ads, user friendly features, able to talk to support - we want these things then we have to pay for them, and I'm happy to do so.
- Rury 4y agoYes Google is getting worse, but I'd argue it's not entirely due to ads, and not entirely Google's fault. I think people need to understand that Google was invented to solve a problem, and that particular problem, is the problem of finding information you need. In the early days of the internet, there was fewer information stored on the internet, so this problem was simpler back then. However, information has grown dramatically over the years, and is still increasing every day. Basically, now Google's search engine model doesn't really work all that great anymore when compared to its early days, simply because the problem has outgrown Google in scale. Think about it... as more and more information gets generated and stored on the internet, finding the information you exactly are looking for using 3-5 words typed into a search engine at some point just ceases to become probable or even possible. So search engines have to predict what you want based upon the limited information you give it (and does this using others things such as how often something is visited, search patterns, trends, and/or related ads + promotions), and users end up perceiving it as a crummy search. Sadly giving a search engine too many words can stop it from even searching, probably because (if you're a developer) you'd understand that could cause a scan or result in a very time and computer/resource intensive search. So it doesn't even bother searching and tells you it couldn't find any information.
- P5fRxh5kUvp2th 4y agoYou know what would make the problem easier? Not indexing obvious shit. Their problem is trying to automate everything. If I have to deal with obvious shit leaning on X vs Y style queries, and I have to deal with it for a year or more, it's because they're bad, not because the scale has outgrown them.
- unity1001 4y ago"Brands" are killing the search for me. All I get is tangentially relevant, numerous results from the same big sites or brands, whatever I search.
- rysertio 4y agoWhat's even worse is this problem is not bound to Google. Almost all search engines delivering more and more unrelated results as time passes by.
- beezlewax 4y agoSearching for answers to basic programming problems has started to yield a bunch of autogenerated sites that are literally the content ripped directly from stackoverflow.. except with a load of ads injected.
- Piisamirotta 4y agoThat is super annoying. When trying to find answers for programming stuff, the first one is usually stackoverflow and next 5 pages this autogenerated bullshit.
- DeathArrow 4y agoGoogle is a mess. But do we have an alternative? Microsoft is letting Bing die slowly, Yandex is pushing lots of results in Russian, Baidu is of no use if you don't know Mandarin, DuckDuckGo and Startpage are using Google and Bing under the hood. I remember pre Google times when both Yahoo and Altavista yielded decent results.
- ColinHayhurst 4y agoExcuse the self-promotion but we have an independent crawler-index and so are one of very few genuine alternatives: https://www.mojeek.com/ https://www.mojeek.com/
- pjmlp 4y agoGetting? It is already there, I think I would have better luck in Ask Jeaves and Altavista than what Google gives me.
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoNot to make this personal but too me this deterioration started when Giannandrea (circa 2016?) was put in charge of Search at Google and they let the AI/ML engineers run loose on what was a technically sound product. The disappointing thing is that the current product is probably a better fit for 90% of non technical users and will likely make google more money, it just has become useless as a technical query crawler. Personally I use ddg at home and Kagi for technical work. The only Google search product I still use is 'Google Shopping' as a great proxy to find local shops with online delivery.
- cr4nberry 4y ago> Personally I use ddg at home and Kagi for technical work Why Kagi? What does it do better
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoSure, here is my short list: - It's the right business model, I am paying! Which means _I_ am the customer, both in terms of support and feature requests. I mean good luck getting answers in goog 'Groups'. Also it means I support Kagi's operational costs so no ads. - It actually respects bolean operators which is something Google had perfected and has been silently ignoring for the past 6 years or so. The 'Lenses' and 'Filters' are also a good addition in Kagi to narrow results further - For my technical queries it does not overvalue 'freshness' which has become a google search obsession. I am not looking for the latest news about Taylor Swift I am looking for a deep crawl on anything related to my very specific technical query. I don't care if it's 15 years old or 2 weeks old. - Pretty much anything UX related is configurable, so any annoyance is easily removed. It pains me to say it but in 2022 I now have to explicitly opt-in, in order for apps to show me a full URL. (But then again perhaps I am just showing my age).
- cr4nberry 4y agoI still think google has the best results, but I'm not surprised that the new york post is trying to sow distrust in google as a company. IMO google results are still better than bing results But also: I use an alternative frontend[1] that I host locally. Very fast, you get google-tier latency and google-tier results without google-tier bloat. Would highly recommend it to anyone who likes the results but doesn't like the company. [1] https://github.com/benbusby/whoogle-search https://github.com/benbusby/whoogle-search
- donmcronald 4y ago> better than bing results What a ringing endorsement. Lol. Jokes aside, that linked project looks very cool. Thanks!
- okokwhatever 4y agoWeb is broken because search should be considered an infrastructure layer feature. P.D.: Let's see how much time takes Google to offer a non-free search option using the economic recession excuse.