6 ms·
Admin assistants (like actual admin assistants) usually have access to full customer contact lists, and exposure to rather intimate details of the business and
by lazide 4y ago
Admin assistants (like actual admin assistants) usually have access to full customer contact lists, and exposure to rather intimate details of the business and executives lives.
They’re definitely not comparable to security guards in that sense.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoThis is not enough of an excuse to encumber someone from earning a living elsewhere. > “Employers need to get creative about how to impose restrictions to protect themselves against individuals” in whom they have made significant investments, or who have been allowed access to trade secrets, to protect themselves against such employees leaving, said Maxwell N. Shaffer, a partner with Holland & Knight LLP in Denver. The sort of healthy employee-employer relationship that retains talent.
- lazide 4y agoWhat is being banned are non-competes that don’t pay someone to not compete. There are legitimate reasons for actual non-competes in many of these cases, and CAlifornia for instance just requires you pay them for it. Which in such a situation seems justified.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoI agree. If you want to pay someone to sit on the bench because that has value to you ("Garden Leave"), I support that. If you want to twist their arm because you have power as an employer, nope. That's what labor law and regulation are for. Lots of examples of malicious employers doing the latter, as you'll note the sentiment throughout the thread comments and laws intending to patch this bug in statute.
- michaelmrose 4y agoWhy let them have that at all. The honest true is instead of worrying what strategy most balances the interests of 99.9% of people and a few whiny rich people we could spend that time creating actual value. Whereas if you want to continue on with the Rube Goldberg device we ought to force them to pay not employers present rate but market rate and cost of foregone opportunity. You might say that's incredibly unaffordable but that is the point. Otherwise the employer is robbing society of the value created in addition to stealing the difference between present rate and market rate + foregone opportunities.
- lazide 4y agoBecause employees can be shitty people too. See my comment upthread about an up close and personal view I had to one such shitty employee. What you seem to be advocating is to never allow a company<-> employee to have a non compete clause, even if the company is happy to pay for it. Which yikes. Do you think what Levandowski did with Waymo/Uber helped anyone? Including ‘society’ overall?
- michaelmrose 4y agoI don't care what they are happy to pay for. There are plenty of other tools available to protect the interests of companies. For example Levandowski stole trade secrets and is being sued for 9 figures and indicted. You couldn't have picked a worse example of the need for post employment non-competes if you tried. Likewise your other example is an employee taking an employees money and their customers at the same time. It would have been sufficient to bar him from competing and working against the employers interests WHILE he was there. If he had quit and called prior customers and said I know you do business with blank but I can do better would that really have been wrong?
- prirun 4y ago> What is being banned are non-competes that don’t pay someone to not compete. Employers will just say "the no-compete compensations is built in to your pay".
- lovich 4y agoThey can say anything, but the behavior has gotten enough voter anger to make politicians view this as something to regulate, so their opinion on the matter is quickly going to lose any weight
- lazide 4y agoWhich is what is banned in California. If someone wants an enforceable non-compete, they need to pay them (fairly and explicitly) for the time they’re not allowed to compete.
- PeterisP 4y agoSure, and in this case as soon as the pay stops, the non-compete obligations stop as well.
- ec109685 4y agoThere are already laws against Admin assistants from taking full customer contact lists from one job to another. You don't need non-competes to enforce that.
- lazide 4y agoReally, which laws are those? The only ones I’m aware of would be trade secret laws, but they’re dubiously applicable to bare customer contact lists. You can make contractual restrictions of course (company property), but good luck being able to prove they actually took it unless they’re really dumb. Merely contacting all, or many, customers for instance wouldn’t prove it. Being able to show they work for competitor x is easy, however, as is showing they’re pursuing customers in the same space.
- jahewson 4y agolol, no. Confidential business information is an area heavily protected by law. Customer lists are the canonical example. It’s much easier to win this kind of civil suit than a criminal case. The court can absolutely crush a business that is founded in this manner to compensate the former employer.
- JackFr 4y agoThen why didn't Dunder Mifflin sue the Michael Scott Paper Company?
- dpkirchner 4y agoBecause they didn't reach out to the very real lawyers at Boston Legal.
- lovich 4y agoAssuming you were asking seriously, its a comedy show that was not trying to accurately portray how businesses run.
- jaxn 4y agoEvery admin assistant should be under an NDA / Confidentiality agreement. Same for personal security. But those are not non-competes.
- noasaservice 4y agoIf they're that important, then the company should pay a significant percentage of their pay to keep them from doing their profession, or GTFO.
- jaxn 4y agoI am saying that they do NOT have non-competes.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoThere are already laws against taking trade secrets/proprietary information, and using it elsewhere. You go to jail for that. It's called "theft." My company had us sign a ridiculous NCA. It pretty much made it impossible to get a job anywhere, after leaving the company; even if they fired you, or laid you off. Their description of a "competitor" was so vague, that it could, literally, be applied to a 7-11, as they potentially sold peripherals that could be plugged into our devices.