4 ms·
One of the things I admire about Elon (which is saying a lot...) is that for whatever reason, he's ready to bet the farm over and over. Whether he's some geniu
by Waterluvian 4y ago
One of the things I admire about Elon (which is saying a lot...) is that for whatever reason, he's ready to bet the farm over and over. Whether he's some genius tactician or an impulsive moron, he just bought Twitter and is poised to drastically alter it.
"flies in the face of everything I understand about complex systems" indeed!
Forgive me for this analogy but it's in the news: Imagine if NATO just said one day, "you know what, !@#$ it. We're done managing this complex system. Let's assume Russia doesn't have or won't use nukes and change our entire doctrine overnight. Get ready to deploy everything."
There's a real possibility Elon buys Twitter for billions and runs it straight into the ground because he does not understand complex systems. Or maybe he gambles and is lucky. Or maybe he really does _get it_ and this is all in some absolutely bizarre way, calculated.
- dieortin 4y agoI really don’t want to live in a world in which so much depends on impulsive individuals. Your example sounds like a nightmare. That’s no way to make decisions.
- Waterluvian 4y agoYeah. It does sound like a nightmare. And I'm glad that, for now at least, those who get to make the decisions are not as impulsive as countless people are online about the matter. And when it comes to a $44 billon purchase, it sounds like a nightmare to affect it so impulsively. At least, unlike the nuclear fallout, it's not my money, I guess.
- dboreham 4y agoBut that's the world we all live in, and have for thousands of years.
- bombcar 4y agoIf you read the stories of many "successful" CEOs (I'm thinking Jobs here, but there are others) the decisions they'd make often would come out as quite impulsive. If you dig significantly you might find that they're not as impulsive as they seem, that the person was actually considering many aspects but playing their cards close until cut-off time.
- mikkergp 4y agoThis is true, and so far Elon is doing exactly the thing everyone says you can’t do with a social network. If he succeeds, it will completely change the space. Also interesting change of strategy during an economic downturn. But I do think one difference at least from where I’m sitting, is usually the response is, that’s crazy, but if it works you’ll be rich! I’m not even really clear on what the “if it works” is in this situation, I guess if he proves that people are willing to pay $8 per month for a social network?
- BurningFrog 4y agoSure, but impulses among individuals like Putin, Biden and Xi Jinping have much bigger impact.
- reverius42 4y agoAnd that's why it's so important for world leaders to not act (or appear to act) impulsively! You might say the same is true for business leaders.
- Waterluvian 4y agoIt’s also why governments that don’t give Kingly powers to the executive like America’s does might be a good idea.
- BurningFrog 4y agoI don't understand Elon either, but I'm certain that he's not an impulsive moron who doesn't understand complex system, or that he's financing all this with his dad's emerald mine money. For me, there is enough track record to prove he has some very unique business skills, and often succeeds by doing things that conventionally looks crazy. That said, Elon's Twitter may well be a failure regardless. Pretty sure it won't be boring though :)
- mikkergp 4y agoDef. won't be boring. Really we only get to see probably less than half of what he's planning. If the other half is more strategic, then he'll do fine, if the other half mirrors his public image, then I can't see it working.
- simondotau 4y agoThe emerald mine claim comes from statements made by Errol Musk (Elon's father) who described it as a part share in an Zambian mine which resulted in a total lifetime revenues in the order of a few hundred thousand dollars. None of what Errol has said has been corroborated by anyone. No independent sources exist. It's also worth noting that Zambia is not a conflict gem country and an emerald mine in Zambia would not be morally problematic absent any specific evidence. (And regardless of any of the above, I've never been particularly enamoured of criticism of a person because of who their parents are or what their parents did. Blaming Elon for being the son of white people in South Africa is kinda gross, actually.)
- panick21_ 4y agoI saw a recent Twitter take that was like: "Who payed for those computers in the 90s that Musk had access to?" Its like yeah ok, he wasn't found in a dumbster during a civil war. Is that the level now, where nobody can get any credit because they were not born into abject poverty? That just basically means that 99% of people who achieve anything don't deserve credit for anything. Its basically materialist logic taken to an absurd degree.
- 4y ago
- mikkergp 4y agoSpeaking of impulsive, I didn't realize he fired the top exists for-cause blowing up their golden parachutes: https://www.businessinsider.in/tech/news/elon-musk-fired-twitter-execs-including-ceo-parag-agrawal-for-cause-in-a-bid-to-avoid-paying-out-tens-of-millions-in-severance-report-says/articleshow/95182325.cms https://www.businessinsider.in/tech/news/elon-musk-fired-twi...
- Waterluvian 4y agoThat'll be a fun half-decade of lawsuits...
- mikkergp 4y agoOne thing he seems to have estimated is the motivations of other wealthy folk he tries to take (or deny) money from.
- thombat 4y agoMatt Levine has an interesting take on this [0], basically that nothing in that Musk claims of their behaviour meets the specification of "cause" in their employment contracts, and further that the golden parachutes are a good thing in that they prevent the C-suite from being focused on their continuing salary: "The basic problem with Musk’s efforts to walk away from these severance agreements — beyond the lack of actual arguments — is that if he can stiff these executives then no golden parachute is binding. The point of a golden parachute is that a CEO with a golden parachute will sell his company to a buyer whom he doesn’t like, if that’s what is best for shareholders. If the buyer can stiff the CEO on the parachute payments because they don’t like each other, then no buyer will ever pay severance, and no CEO will ever trust it." [0] https://web.archive.org/web/20221031165639/https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-10-31/elon-musk-is-busy-with-twitter?leadSource=uverify%20wall https://web.archive.org/web/20221031165639/https://www.bloom...
- mikkergp 4y ago"And then Elon Musk showed up for his first day of work as Twitter’s chief executive officer — technically its Chief Twit — and said “hey, do you have any other contracts I could violate?” Oh, this is going to be a fun read. In response to your quote, I guess he did it as revenge for making him go through with it.
- UncleMeat 4y agoI don't quite think it is luck - but a weird second thing. Musk has a reality distortion field. I think he is a bloviating jerk but I know a lot of really really smart and dedicated engineers in software and in more traditional fields like mech-e and aerospace who would rather work for Musk than any other person and are willing to take pay cuts to work for him. This means he really can surround himself with very skilled people who can distill his "fuck it, we are doing FOO" commands into real plans. What this tells me is not that Musk is a visionary but that a lot of shitty visions are nevertheless achievable if you've got enough smart people around you.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pkaye 4y agoSo why is he able to get smart people around him? Its not like he pays them a lot or offer a good work/life balance in their job.
- renewiltord 4y agoElon offers people a chance to operate at a true 100% on a thing that matters. Next to that, work-life balance pales. And comp? Comp follows company glory. Tesla engineers are rich, man.
- robryan 4y agoSells them on the mission. Things like a colony on Mars and full self driving are pretty compelling goals for some people.
- mecha_ghidorah 4y agoYeah but I feel like "work on twitter" is way less of a .... shall we say noble/socially fulfilling job. I'd value working on sending people to mars (not to live, just to do a walk on it), it'd make me part of something historic. One day people would write books and make documentaries about the work done to make it happen, and even if I weren't featured for the entire rest of my life if I could tell people "I worked on the software for the Mars shuttle" or whatever and have them go "Oh cool!". Hell, even before it succeeds I think it'd have social capital with the right crowd: pushing boundaries to put someone on mars is a cool job.... Twitter on the other hand... "Oh I work at twitter doing software". That's.... nowhere near as exciting or epic a thing to tell people that you do. So he might have a harder time finding smart people willing to work for less than market rates at twitter compared to finding them for SpaceX and Tesla
- oska 4y ago> Forgive me for this analogy but it's in the news: Imagine if NATO just said one day No, I definitely won't forgive you your 'analogy', because it's sneaking in a highly irresponsible argument for military escalation into a completely unrelated discussion.
- Waterluvian 4y agoLet me help you out: the point of the analogy _is_ to underline how highly irresponsible Elon’s approach is. I think one could criticize that the analogy hyperbole, but I’m quite amused at the pearl clutching that somehow I’m trying to push for nuclear annihilation. Saying the words three times in a mirror doesn’t make it happen.
- teovall 4y agoIt's easy to be impulsive and make risky decisions when those decisions aren't actually risky for you. He's the richest person in the world. Even if he made a terrible decision to "bet the farm" and lost 99.5% of his wealth, he'd still be a billionaire and in the top 0.00005% of net worth in the world.