5 ms·
"Apple set the bar for realistic textured apps. Developers followed." IMHO, this was to be avoided. I think this move on Apple's part to move towards such lite
by bane 15y ago
"Apple set the bar for realistic textured apps. Developers followed."
IMHO, this was to be avoided. I think this move on Apple's part to move towards such literal skeuomorphism was a major step back. After decades of learning that literal analogies on computing devices simply doesn't work all that well, Apple decided to forget about all of that lesson learned stuff and just throw it all away.
Even Gruber can't manage to fake gushing over it
http://daringfireball.net/linked/2011/10/26/against-skeuomorphism http://daringfireball.net/linked/2011/10/26/against-skeuomor...
These themes aren’t lies. They’re not designed to help users understand how these apps work. They’re just decoration. They’re per-app branding. Apple no longer endorses system-wide visual uniformity. Special apps are supposed to look special. Why is Find My Friends wrapped in rich Corinthian leather? Because someone at Apple likes (and, sadly, if my guess is right, better said liked, past tense) how it looks.
I'd say in general the design gods are not happy with this move
http://www.andymangold.com/skeuomorphism-the-opiate-of-the-people/ http://www.andymangold.com/skeuomorphism-the-opiate-of-the-p...
http://madebymany.com/blog/apples-aesthetic-dichotomy http://madebymany.com/blog/apples-aesthetic-dichotomy
http://kensegall.com/blog/tag/ical-address-book/ http://kensegall.com/blog/tag/ical-address-book/
http://cushley.net/2011/07/in-depth-os-x-lion-review-part-3-new-visual-changes/ http://cushley.net/2011/07/in-depth-os-x-lion-review-part-3-...
So in less than half a dozen links this design trend is called cheap "kitsch", "infantile", patronizing lies, "hideous" etc. These are not slight disagreements, these are fighting words.
I agree that Google's Android apps suffer from terrible UI consistency problems, but using Apple's trend towards textured apps as an example of consistency cum success doesn't work here.
A better example might be the pre-OS X guidelines that Apple used to publish. You couldn't tell one company's application from another!
In the end though, I'm not entirely sure that it really matters all that much. Users will learn how to use the apps they want, and they'll think about those apps as tasks, each with discrete ways of doing things. e.g. opening a car door is different than opening a fridge door is different from opening a closet door is different from opening the screen door is different from opening the shower door etc. UI consistency just isn't that important, it's just annoying when you notice it.
- lominming 15y agoYes. I agreed with you. I am not a big fan of those textured apps myself and I really like how WP7 look. That is a post for another time.
- michaelwenton 15y agoTwo things. First, I think it's pretty universally agreed that Apple's trend toward skeuomporphism is bad. But that doesn't mean that Apple hasn't created a consistent set of UI standards for iOS. Both because of culture and because of the built-in toolkit, UI elements among apps on iOS are very standard. This is especially true of Apple-built apps, which is why the blog post detailing Google's inconsistencies is so strange to me. Secondly, Apple does in fact still publish Human Interface Guidelines, and while they're not followed to the degree that they were pre-OS X, they are still taken seriously by most developers and designers of Mac software. http://developer.apple.com/library/mac/#documentation/UserExperience/Conceptual/AppleHIGuidelines/Intro/Intro.html http://developer.apple.com/library/mac/#documentation/UserEx...
- bane 15y ago* Apple does in fact still publish Human Interface Guidelines, and while they're not followed to the degree that they were pre-OS X* Right, which is the problem IMHO. Even Apple can't muster up enough will to follow them these days with their own apps. Are the apps generally good looking on their own? Most of them are, there's a few "what were they thinking" moments. The problem though is that even Apple isn't following the HIG these days and that spells doom and gloom for anybody who wishes to hold them up as the high water mark for design houses to follow. Pre-OS X it was a very solid design language. Pretty much everything looked like everything else, and it all looked pretty good. You really had to work hard to make an ugly piece of software. Both because of culture and because of the built-in toolkit And you are also right with this, having a built-in toolkit, with all sorts of good looking, consistent, well-behaved interface elements is the key here. Android gives you layout control (great for different screen sizes/resolution) but doesn't seem to provide anywhere near the level of toolkitting needed, while iOS takes up the lessons learned in the pre-OS X days and provides an awesome toolkit. Then Apple manages to ignore the whole thing and try to make everything look like something I threw away 15 years ago because computing devices were better.
- jacobolus 15y ago> Even Gruber can't manage to fake gushing over it Is a non sequitur insult really necessary to this part of your post?
- bane 15y agoI think so. And it wasn't intended as an insult. Gruber's one-sided treatment of Apple is pretty well acknowledged and understood. He's used as the benchmark, somebody who is virtually obliged to like whatever Apple does, and even he can't muster a favorable opinion about it. The problem with the original article is that it assumes that whatever Apple does must be good, which is flawed thinking. To use it as a counterweight to the problems in Android apps is fundamentally flawed. Using Gruber as the far end of the scale was intentional and not insulting. After all, calling a Banana yellow isn't insulting is it? It is what it is and Gruber is who he is. He serves his purpose as the thought leader championing the Apple way. Plus it wasn't non-sequitur, Gruber was specifically talking about the trend towards Skeuomorphism in Apple's design language as a bad thing.
- jamesgeck0 15y agoWhile I appreciate your reasoning, a quote from someone like Jakob Nielsen might have been a stronger choice.
- bane 15y agoHave any suggestions of quotes germane to the discussion?
- danssig 15y ago>Users will learn how to use the apps they want, and they'll think about those apps as tasks, each with discrete ways of doing things. e.g. opening a car door is different than opening a fridge door is different from opening a closet door is different from opening the screen door is different from opening the shower door etc. I thought that was the whole point of what they were doing.