4 ms·
People return to offices, productivity plunges
- lsy 4y agoThe article attributes the productivity loss to employee dissatisfaction, but I suspect working from an office is for many people just less productive overall. - Written communication and documentation falls off as people rely on (and forget) face-to-face discussions - Quality of sleep declines - Workers leave the office promptly to beat (or spend time in) traffic instead of working an extra hour - The workplace itself is full of distractions and other time-sinks like hustling to the meeting room, waiting for the restroom, or taking a long team lunch - The mental load of deferring all minor personal tasks to the end of the workday or the weekend rather than accomplishing them on short breaks during off-peak hours Put otherwise, of course productivity is declining, as we are now spending more of our possibly-productive time expending energy to move and host our bodies away from home, and it seems the productivity gained by doing so doesn't outstrip the productivity wasted.
- __derek__ 4y ago> Economists are trying to come up with explanations for the decline, and to understand what this means for post-pandemic changes to the workplace, including hybrid schedules that allow more time out of the office. > My hunch is that many workers are letting their employers know that things are different now. This "article" is silly. My hunch? There are a ton of new hires, which also hurts productivity for the folks training them. Let's give it some time to simmer before freaking out about productivity.
- quantified 4y agoIf wfh lowered productivity, and return to office lowers productivity, then perhaps the transitions and irregular patterns of half-in-office and half-wfh is the issue. Stabilize around any pattern before fully assessing it.
- redavni 4y agoStability is key to pretty much everything. The lack of it since Covid started is going to have ripple effects for decades.
- quantified 4y agoMakes sense. Look at how society and governments behave when other pictures are unstable.
- bediger4000 4y agoI believe that returning to the office is inevitable, because almost all managers prefer it. This is a good thing because we will have documented proof that businesses make decisions on other than a hard "this makes more money" basis.
- TimTheTinker 4y agoWhat will that proof be helpful for? Honest question. I agree that having proof for true propositions is generally a good thing, but I don't see any specific ways that proof would be helpful in this case. Maybe another consideration for macro-economic theory?
- bediger4000 4y agoI was thinking of the latter. Also, should such facts become "common knowledge" they'll be useful in clarifying policy debates.
- mbrodersen 4y agoNot at all. Smart companies knows that offering WFH will attract more and better developers. It is a massive competitive advantage. I will personally never work for a company that doesn’t offer WFH. I am not the only one.
- mbrodersen 4y agoOf course productivity plunges when people return to offices. The #1 reason are incompetent middle managers who doesn’t know how to manage people without constantly interrupting them with endless BS meetings and unnecessary status reporting. There are companies where 80% of developer time is spent in meetings. Another reason is that people are now exposed to arrogant and toxic co-workers who will drain your soul by their mere presence. A toxic manager/co-worker can easily destroy your motivation.
- janalsncm 4y agoI have to say this article is a bit light on facts. For the curious, here is the actual press release from the Bureau of Labor Stats: https://www.bls.gov/news.release/prod2.nr0.htm https://www.bls.gov/news.release/prod2.nr0.htm On the face of it, this isn’t because of a decrease in hours worked because the productivity rate uses that in the denominator. Plus, hours worked actually increased. This is of course assuming that hours worked is accurate. If this number is actually higher than expected (for example, if workers are spending time commuting rather than working) then it will incorrectly underestimate productivity rates. I looked into how this is calculated: https://www.bls.gov/productivity/technical-notes/labor-productivity-hours-worked-method-using-ces-all-employee-hours-nov-2022.htm https://www.bls.gov/productivity/technical-notes/labor-produ... Importantly, see footnote 6 about salaried employees: > In the nonproduction-worker-to-production-worker hours ratio used in the current methodology, both the numerator and denominator are actual hours worked. However, to be conceptually consistent with the CES data, the denominator should be hours paid, which excludes off-the-clock hours worked by salaried production employees. That is, this ratio implicitly assumes that production workers are paid for all of the hours they work. However, according to the CPS, about 30 percent of production workers are paid a salary. Thus, the nonproduction-worker-to-production-worker hours ratio is biased downward and therefore does not capture all of the OTC hours worked by salaried nonproduction workers. Here, the BLS is explicitly saying they can’t capture all of the hours you work. Intuitively this is true. How could they? This is just my hypothesis. It would be great if there was some survey data to back it up regarding hours actually worked by salaried employees.