3 ms·
Since somebody chose to downvote the above comment, I think it bears elaboration for those who might not understand. A contemporary example is domain names. The
by somenameforme 4y ago
Since somebody chose to downvote the above comment, I think it bears elaboration for those who might not understand. A contemporary example is domain names. The current domain system is a monopoly, and it sucks. You pay companies a never-ending and ever-increasing rent to do literally less than nothing. A domain isn't much more than a key/value pair in a small database. You're paying never-ending rent to them for them to not go out of their way to delete your entry.
Relying on a centralized competitor to offer something better would be dubious. If they gain substantial marketshare there's nothing stopping them from deciding to simply swap back to our current system. It could even be done retroactively since everybody has those lines in their terms and conditions that amount to 'We can do anything, and you can't do anything about it.'
But with a decentralized system you have the possibility of a new type of domain where while one operator may be able to be the only one that can create them, once they transfer that domain to you it becomes literally impossible for them to access, change, or affect it in any way, shape, or form. Decentralization is able to turn various digital goods into something much closer to their physical counterpart where you are buying something that is no longer connected to the seller after checkout. And this can really help ensure the integrity of services that otherwise might be susceptible to bait and switch business models.
- PontifexMinimus 4y ago> A contemporary example is domain names. The current domain system is a monopoly, and it sucks. You pay companies a never-ending and ever-increasing rent to do literally less than nothing. A domain isn't much more than a key/value pair in a small database. Is there any legal or technical reason why someone can't set up a DNS server that resolves domain names to different IP addresses than those traditionally used?
- somenameforme 4y agoBeyond network effect, nope. This is one of the more convenient ways to block in-app ads on mobile. Set your DNS to something like AdGuard's servers, and they'll resolve ad delivering domains to a no-op. And suddenly all major third party ads in apps or the web alike are gone.
- PontifexMinimus 4y ago> Beyond network effect, nope. So why does no-one do this/ Obviously people do do it for ad-blocking, so why not for other purposes? Too difficult to get traction, perhaps?
- bombcar 4y agoThere are a very few alternate roots that have actually gotten traction - the most famous of which is .onion
- dinosaurdynasty 4y ago.onion is weird in that it isn't actually DNS; it doesn't support DNS records (like A, SRV, TXT, etc) and applications that use it don't use DNS to connect to things behind onion services.
- cestith 4y agoThere are DNS blocklists for mail servers. It's a slightly different thing, but basically there's if there's an entry it means there's a reputation for the mail sender. Some of them are present/not present and some have a score. Some are against the IP of the sender only, while others are against the domain name or full hostname of the sender. You just set your mail server to do the right lookup against the right DNS server, and incoming mail can be filtered based on the results of the DB someone else is maintaining.
- autoexec 4y agoYou can do it on your own systems all you like, but the thing people love about domain names is that anyone who types in a domain can get to that particular site. The fact that we all generally agree where a domain points to is part of what makes them useful. If I decide I want to have my personal website be called google.com I can edit my hosts file to point google.com to my webserver and everything works for me, but anybody else going to google.com is going to get Google's page instead unless I somehow convince them to edit their files or use my weird DNS server. Even if I come up with some great reason that makes people want to accept that google.com is better when it goes to my website instead, what happens when someone else decides they should be able to use google.com for something else and they convince a bunch of people to use their weird DNS server? We could fragment the DNS all over the place and have several conflicting entries for every popular domain name depending on what DNS server you're using but is that really better?
- teddyh 4y agoPeople have tried: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_DNS_root https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_DNS_root
- aidenn0 4y agoThere are no legal nor technical reason why someone can't do that. There's also no reason why the TLD can't be a number[1] 1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2179216 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2179216
- efsavage 4y agoI'm not defending registrars/registries per se, but... > A domain isn't much more than a key/value pair in a small database. No, it's often a huge investment and important part of security approaches (certificates, validation, email, etc.) > You're paying never-ending rent to them for them to not go out of their way to delete your entry. Yes, you're paying them to not update that value to point to someone else's server. Just like you pay your landlord to not only keep your apartment in working order, but to not let someone else live there. > becomes literally impossible for them to access, change, or affect it in any way, shape, or form How is this a good thing? Someone takes over your domain and nobody is able to get it back? You just spent millions of dollars on marketing to get people to visit your somenameforme.tld and now it points to another site because your key leaked. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯?
- lob_it 4y agoSIM swap attacks happening at every level of the mobile industry would probably invoke cool rebuttals as well. https://consumer.ftc.gov/consumer-alerts/2019/10/sim-swap-scams-how-protect-yourself https://consumer.ftc.gov/consumer-alerts/2019/10/sim-swap-sc... You are not going to be able to pay extra to make rotten to the core pretty.
- somenameforme 4y agoKeys don't "leak" but of course they can be stolen - like any real product. If you spend $40 million on your Van Gogh, and it's stolen - that's not going to be a happy moment. Fortunately keeping a key safe is much easier than keeping a physical asset safe. And you'd only need to access your archive the times when you need to change the IP for your domain or are otherwise transferring/selling it.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoKeys can easily leak; there was a high-profile example not so long ago where a bunch of GPG public keys shared factors due to a bug in generation.