3 ms·
I don't know this specific artist, but the fact that someone dedicated their profession and life to art doesn't mean they're necessarily good.
by stavros 4y ago
I don't know this specific artist, but the fact that someone dedicated their profession and life to art doesn't mean they're necessarily good.
- bombcar 4y agoOr they could dedicate years and be good (or great!) and still not unique. In fact, the better they get the less likely they are to be unique as more people will imitate their style.
- jfk13 4y agoDoes whether they're good or not actually have any bearing on the legality or morality of copying their work?
- rosywoozlechan 4y agoI didn't make this claim that someone would be good just because of the amount of time spent, the claim I made that is harsh criticism to make when they have. For example if you just started strength training, have been at it for just a few weeks and someone said "you're not very strong" that's not harsh criticism because you just started, but if you've been strength training for 10-20 years and someone said "you're not very strong" that criticism hits different right? Does it make sense what I am saying now? This artist will probably read these HN comments, and I'm struck by how cruel the comments are to someone who's just out there creating wonderful content, didn't ask for any of this, so many of you here do not care about how she feels. I also call into question the ability of these HN commenter's competence at critiquing art.
- stavros 4y agoAh, yes, that clarifies it, thank you. I agree.
- i_like_apis 4y agoIt’s not an art critique. If she reads it, hopefully she understands the lens of the language. Her style is good, and evidently assiduous. Everything said remains relevant.