4 ms·
I was curious about the legal justification for your claim, so I read your main source (biren.com). It seems like you're taking what is a possible defense again
by mindslight 4y ago
I was curious about the legal justification for your claim, so I read your main source (biren.com). It seems like you're taking what is a possible defense against a product liability claim (CACI 1245), and pulling it out of context. But rather, for that to even apply, there still has to be a fundamental design defect in the product.
So if there is a safety interlock controlled by software, which the end user then disables by replacing the software, and then someone gets hurt - even though the manufacturer could have reasonably foreseen the modification, the manufacturer still isn't liable because their (removed) safety interlock code wasn't defective in the first place.
But regardless of the current state of the law, a new law that prohibited companies from prohibiting modifications to software on devices they sell would obviously affect that. The thing your citing is California jury instructions, that are presumably a distillation of case law. So rather than even needing to be amended by a legislature, they would be implicitly adjusted with the passage of a right to repair law.