4 ms·
When you are watching SpaceX launch videos, pay attention to the velocities at which the various engine burns begin and end. Reaching higher velocities (for co
by bell-cot 4y ago
When you are watching SpaceX launch videos, pay attention to the velocities at which the various engine burns begin and end. Reaching higher velocities (for comparable payloads, etc.) requires burning more fuel - so there is less fuel left in the tank to perform boost-back burns, entry burns, and landing burns. Not enough fuel for a boost-back burn (the typical situation) means "barge landing". Not enough fuel for an entry (& landing) burn means "expended first stage" - which also means "remove the weight of the useless landing legs before launch".
And if the customer is paying SpaceX to take a heavy payload to a high velocity / orbit...well, they are paying for it. Today's launch was actually the third-most-performant (and -expensive) Falcon Heavy launch mode. #2 has both side boosters landing on barges (so the boosters don't need fuel for boost-back burns). #1 expends everything - just like all of SpaceX's competition does.
- pfdietz 4y agoIf you watched the liftoff, after the vehicle was above the fog, the plume from the core looked much weaker than from the boosters. I think they throttle that stage down so it's using less fuel, leaving fuel to be burned after the boosters are done. This will also reduce the velocity at which the boosters are staged so they have an easier time getting back. After the boosters stage the core will be throttled back up (if it hadn't been already).
- bell-cot 4y agoCorrect, and that throttle-fiddling is required to get a good performance boost from using side boosters.
- pleo__ 4y agoAdditionally, the center core is throttled to make sure the vehicle safely gets through the dangerous "max-Q" part of the launch where stress from the atmospheric drag is highest.
- pfdietz 4y agoMakes sense. They throttle even on the F9 for that reason, and the FH is essentially three F9s with an upper stage that is not the mass of 3 F9 upper stages.
- pfdietz 4y agoAn earlier design has propellant transfer from the boosters to the core stage while they were still attached, but I guess that was decided to not be worth it (if the engine thrust growth was high enough simple throttling would be enough.)
- bell-cot 4y agoPropellant (and oxidizer) cross-feed systems would have added a notable amount of weight, a lot of design complexity and cost, and a metric sh*t ton of critical failure scenarios.
- ape4 4y agoAnd this customer asked for no filming later in the launch. So they are rich and secretive - I wonder who that could be?
- ErneX 4y agoIt was a launch for the US Space Force.
- bombcar 4y ago> Not enough fuel for an entry (& landing) burn means "expended first stage" - which also means "remove the weight of the useless landing legs before launch". Landing gear? Where we're going we won't need landing gear!