2 ms·
IP law is fundamentally different from product distribution law, and antitrust doesn’t really apply to IP (FRAND being a good counter-example, but that is roote
by brookst 4y ago
IP law is fundamentally different from product distribution law, and antitrust doesn’t really apply to IP (FRAND being a good counter-example, but that is rooted in contracts).
All IP is monopolistic, and there is no first sale doctrine. If I buy a physical book from you, it is mine to do with as I see fit. If I license the right to publish your book as part of a set, I am not necessarily allowed to sell that set into your channels and undercut your pricing. The terms of the contract dictate that, and it is not at all an antitrust violation of our contract says I am only to sell the set to schools or whatever.
- kergonath 4y ago> IP law is fundamentally different from product distribution law, and antitrust doesn’t really apply to IP It is relevant when IP is used in an anticompetitive way, like Microsoft’s licensing terms back in the day. I can see a company making the argument that ARM is dominant enough that onerous terms with one company and not the others is anticompetitive (not saying that it is the case, but I have seen worse points seeing some successes recently). Otherwise yes, I agree with everything you said.