3 ms·
XMPP and SIP are decentralized, federated, and self hostable as well and they had bridges before matrix was a thing. The main draw for matrix for me is it has t
by zamadatix 4y ago
XMPP and SIP are decentralized, federated, and self hostable as well and they had bridges before matrix was a thing. The main draw for matrix for me is it has the most modern bridges. Not because the protocol allows it but because it’s where people have been making them lately. The main downside I’ve noticed is large rooms take an inordinate amount of time to join and sync. I still enjoy matrix I just don’t think it’s as unique as this pitch makes it out to be.
- zaik 4y agoPeople make bridges for XMPP (see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33420784 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33420784 ) but bridges are just band-aids anyways: Most important they don't support e2e encryption. If we want to have messenger interoperability we need standardization. Matrix should focus on compliance with the existing XMPP internet standard instead of inventing yet another set of incompatible primitives.
- mnot 4y agoThe IETF has given up on XMPP for its own chat service.
- MattJ100 4y agoWhat the IETF (or any organization in a similar position) sought for its discussions was an existing off-the-shelf product, not a protocol. They chose Zulip, because it is a product that has various features that are attractive for the IETF's use cases. The protocol it uses internally is pretty irrelevant from the IETF's perspective, as a user. If the IETF had developed its own chat tool and did not use XMPP for that, your comment would have more weight.