4 ms·
> In truth, pretty much nobody really knows for sure what policies actually will increase GDP... Have they tried securing access to large amounts of cheap ener
by roenxi 4y ago
> In truth, pretty much nobody really knows for sure what policies actually will increase GDP...
Have they tried securing access to large amounts of cheap energy? It is a bit of a win-win because either GDP goes up and case closed or they can sit back and relax in luxury mulling why GDP didn't go up despite massive increases in the general prosperity.
Energy isn't the entire story because there also need to be people around who know how to transform it into whatever you want, but it is a rather important part of the puzzle. After that, freedom and education are probably going to make up the rest. What else is there? I suppose land ownership.
The puzzle isn't that complicated. We all know what comfort looks like. Asking how to make GDP go up is the wrong question, it is just a tool to point out when policies are wasting resources. More waste -> less GDP -> notice that and waste less -> reorient to secure prosperity.
- thewarrior 4y agoYes they created a global reserve currency they can print to get energy as they need and a super large military to force everyone to go along with it. Securing large amounts of cheap energy is non trivial as europe is beginning to find out.
- gadders 4y agoNot trivial, but there are a few foot-guns that can be avoided like not shutting down your nuclear power plants or not giving licenses to actually dig the energy out of the ground.
- defrost 4y ago> What else is there? I suppose land ownership. As in? The % of pop. that owns land? The conversion of common parks to land titles for sale? The spread of skyscrapers to allow the sale of vetically stacked "land"?
- SideQuark 4y agoEvery country tries securing cheap energy; that's what energy markets are for. There is no such thing as a trivial win here. And trying to secure it could end up costing significant GDP, as demonstrated by wars fought over securing energy.
- roenxi 4y agoThey aren't. The EU is in the news right now because they cracked down on nuclear and fossil fuels and - after succeeding - ended up in an energy crisis. You can see what countries trying to secure cheap energy do by looking at China and India - lots of coal, lots of oil, bring on as much capacity in nuclear and renewables as they can. They're playing with effectively 4x as many sources of energy as the EU despite the Europeans having a wealth and tech lead! I say 4x because renewables aren't quite a big enough energy source to break up into components.
- Schroedingersat 4y ago> The EU is in the news right now because they cracked down on nuclear and fossil fuels and - after succeeding - ended up in an energy crisis. They allowed the fossil fuel lobby to severely curtail their renewable installations and had a quarter of their nuclear reactors fail. Then had a massive source of gas disappear. The renewables are working exactly as advertised. Seems like a pretty good argument for more of them. > do by looking at China So at least half of new generation as renewables with a small increase in nuclear whilst keeping thermal plant capacity roughly constant (mostly by moving existing production to more efficient plants)?
- roenxi 4y agoThat would be an improvement over the failure that they have managed. The Europeans have shrinking access to electricity, so they effectively must have negative absolute growth on fossil fuels and I suspect negative or near 0 growth of nuclear (not going to check, so maybe someone is doing the sensible thing and building some nuclear plants and I haven't read about it). They have a long way to go to get towards the sort of success China is managing. They need a lot of renewables to recover from their serious policy screw ups. They don't seem to have been able to build it that quickly! Hopefully they manage before there is a really bad winter.