7 ms·
All new cars sold in Europe must be emission-free from 2035
- PeterStuer 4y agoHere's me wondering how the full scale smart grid that is required to make this work will be created in this timeframe.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoGiven how long took Sued Link to get operational (Not yet? but already 10 years going), I would say that smart gird will be here around a year 2200-2300
- recuter 4y agoYou're not the only one, but over in the US you can rest easy as Pete Buttigieg is on the case: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=avi9iBC8opU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=avi9iBC8opU I for one am sure politicians have got a great handle on all of this.
- eis 4y agoWhat major changes to the grid are required to make EVs work and why do they have to be "smart"? Electricity consumption will increase but it will be quite uniform if everyone is switching to EVs. A few upgrades for added capacity will be needed but I don't see any major issues with that. And while all new cars have to be emission-free by 2035 that does not mean all cars in use will be. It'll take probably till 2040 to 2045 for the vast majority to be EVs and that's plenty of time to do the necessary upgrades.
- kkfx 4y agoIt's not much a matter of "load" alone but of peak. Keeping AC frequency stable it's hard. We can ramp up or lower the production at a certain speed, not instantaneously and fast charging with instantaneous 100-300kW peaks are a very hard issue to tackle.
- LatteLazy 4y ago40 years or not doing anything, and we're only another 10+ from not doing anything; such progress!
- jryhjythtr 4y ago"The market has decided it wants EVs!" "Legacy auto will be caught short by the EV revolution!" B*llox. EVs will be mandated, we will like them, and some will profit hugely.
- alias_neo 4y agoI have to agree; as a complete nerd, that would _love_ an electric vehicle for all of the good things about them, battery tech and all-touch interiors will keep putting me off getting one, probably until I'm forced to.
- actionfromafar 4y agoI think there will be simpler offers once cheaper models are also EVs. https://www.renaultgroup.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/dacia-spring-6-1024x682.jpg https://www.renaultgroup.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/daci...
- alias_neo 4y agoNice, the pictured vehicle looks nothing like an EV interior, which is great! I suppose the part I'm missing is that for now, all of the EVs we see are trying to be futuristic, once it's the norm, we should see more "normal" vehicles. Don't get me wrong, I'm not some old-git who's anti-change, I'm a millenial, and a tech-nerd, but I also like to keep my eyes on the road when I'm driving.
- kkfx 4y agoAs a driver I love much more: - traffic jam ADAS where with a command my car follow the car in front of it or run at a steady speed alone without me keep driving; - auto-hold that allow to simply ignore current road steepness Instead as an IT guy I HATE the pile of crapware outside my control that "my" connected cars have. And that's a far bigger issue than a crappy or not UI and big or not touch panel aside...
- helsinkiandrew 4y agoDepending on the survey and the country (and they vary a lot) about 20-40% want to buy an electric car now (more so if you include hybrid) and the percent who are dead set against them at any cost is dropping. Those trends are growing at faster rates, before they are mandated EVs will be the main preference by ~80% of the public. https://assets.ey.com/content/dam/ey-sites/ey-com/cs_cz/topics/automotive-and-transportation/ey-mobility-consumer-index-2022-summary.pdf https://assets.ey.com/content/dam/ey-sites/ey-com/cs_cz/topi... https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/business/energy-green/story/2022-07-07/electric-cars-growing-number-of-consumers-now-interested-in-buying-them-survey-says https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/business/energy-green/s...
- erik_seaberg 4y agoThe article depicts a charger for street parking, and this is the first time I’ve seen one. That’s a good step, now you need to install millions of those everywhere before you can expect the cars to be bought.
- mritzmann 4y agoI'm not sure I'm a fan of that. I would like to see more cars parked in garages or underground garages and not "polluting" the streetscape. Before we had so many cars, the streets were so much emptier and nicer. Here in the neighbourhoods the cars cover the pavements and in other places the shop windows. A large part of the quality of life in cities is lost due to parked cars.
- alias_neo 4y agoI think this and multi-story car parks are going to be the best solution; what's worse than streets lined with cars parked everywhere? Streets lined with parked cars with wires snaking to and from them. The place I just moved to is already pedestrian-hostile, who needs it getting worse because we shoehorned electricity into our transport? Don't get my wrong, I'm a big nerd, I want an electric car, but the way we're doing it doesn't seem right.
- alias_neo 4y agoI've seen a bunch of them around the UK (Side note: should the title be "EU", presumably it doesn't include the UK, which IS in Europe); I do wonder how we're ever going to get enough charging points to make all-electric a reality; From houses with no parking, to flats with no parking, car parks with no space to put the electric charge point, all this before we get to the problem that battery tech is a huge money sink. I really want an electric vehicle, it ticks lots of boxes for me, but unlike an ICE vehicle that I can top up in seconds, and which are usually engineered with a decent amount of longevity, the battery in an electric vehicle is likely to be next to useless within 5 or so years of buying it; even if it's good enough for me, who would want to buy it when the advertised second-hand range is down to 50 miles per charge? They seems like an utterly terrible investment to me, and at £50k+ (luxury car price bracket according to UK gov), it is an investment to me if I'm spending that much.
- seydor 4y agoCan be rephrased as, all cars will require a heavy, difficult-to-produce, difficult-to-recycle battery that needs a huge reliable supply chain to make it happen, and cities that can withstand the load of charging hundreds of thousands of cars in the evening. Europe doesn't even have the money to do those things so i will dismiss this as the same kind of populism that brought germany to the brink of recession.
- raydiatian 4y agoSo, fatalistically accept that climate change is happening and we don’t have a choice? Or stop driving cars altogether? (I like this plan most)
- thdespou 4y agoStop PCP payments first and then we will see how many can afford a car.
- djbebs 4y agoClimate change isn't nearly as big of an issue as the proposed solutions
- flockonus 4y agoimho, too little too late. At this point we need carbon negative solutions, not only incremental improvements (combustion car -> electric car), this is the same lack of ambition as banning plastic bags on grocery stores in 2022, might have been a timeline solution in 2000.
- DocTomoe 4y agoSo, what is your living situation? Inner city? If so: Do you expect everyone to move in with you? How do you get your food (and - you'll likely buy it from somewhere - how does it get there)? Stopping individual traffic is a pipe dream. Climate change is happening, and we don't have a choice, nor will we be able to stop it - so we do what has always been the major advantage of our species: quick and rapid adaption. Accept that some land is lost, and move to places that are more habitable. Install air conditioning / heating where necessary. Change agriculture to focus on new produce that is more adapted to the climatical circumstances. And start working on a Plan(et) B, because we have only a few more hundred years.
- karol 4y agoExpect people to ride tractors to town.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoIt would be ironic if people would start using same loophole like in USA - Riding big ass SUVs, which has more lenient emission controls because they are not personal cars, but trucks (light-duty vehicles). In EU only every car will be a tractor. Here we go.
- rich_sasha 4y agoIronically, in the UK, Range Rovers (snazzy, very big 4x4s) are called Chelsea Tractors.
- belter 4y agoIn other countries they are also called an appendix extension.
- strken 4y agoIt'll be interesting to see the list of exemptions. Will anyone in a remote area be allowed a petrol car? Or will hydrogen be long enough range and feasible to store?
- RamblingCTO 4y agoWe don't have areas that are that remote. And Germany is small.
- strken 4y agoI thought some of the Nordic countries (and Turkey, if it becomes a member) had quite remote areas.
- RamblingCTO 4y agoOh yeah they do, sorry, I read it as you were also talking about Germany as the parent ;) Eastern Europe as well. Spain etc. probably also, but central Europe not at all. Maybe the alps but that's not "remote" as the US has.
- krmboya 4y agoI'll only let go of my petrol powered car if you give me a solar powered one
- lnsru 4y agoYesterday I just sent my buddy picture with energy generation in Germany. 32,8% coal!!! So the future will be burning coal to power emission-fee cars. It’s just shocking nonsense as I see it as an engineer.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoGet rid of nukes because Germans are scared of nuclear waste Start burning coal Pretend that nuclear waste from coal released uncontrollably from chimneys and ash dumps does not exists.
- marcyb5st 4y agoI think you are not considering the difference in efficiency between a power plant and a car with an internal combustion engine. Switching to electric just because of that is worth in the long term and additionally, some of the power comes from clean sources so even more so. I saw a video in YT where in a state like Utah in the US an ev becomes greener after the equivalent of few tens of gas tanks (don't remember the number). Will try to find out the sources.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoHowever Germany tries to spin it they are doing very badly on emissions. > Switching to electric just because of that is worth in the long term Is it, though? Batteries are not exactly environment-friendly and hydrogen seems too often ignored.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoPriorities. Materials used in batteries are something that can be managed, like any other toxic industrial chemicals. Emissions go up in the air, and are creating an extinction-level threat. It's important to think of the former, but trying to turn it into a deal-breaker is just suicidal.
- mytailorisrich 4y ago
- Markoff 4y agowell you don't need to sell me the new car, you can sell me the key and give me car as a gift for free
- ghusto 4y agoCan also be read: "Used Cars to be Sold at Insane Premiums After 2035". I was recently in the market for a mini-camper, DIY or ready-made. What became clear early in my search, was that I would be buying what they call a "classic", or "old-timer" diesel. These things spew more pollution than newer vans, but are the most practical option for people who aren't rich. Their baffling classification entitles them to go to more places (many cities are "green zones" in Europe, where I live) than less polluting newer cars, and they cost less to run. Once you take the reliability and serviceability of these simpler vans into account, it becomes an obvious choice. I'm for clean air, so I hope that along with mandating emission-free cars, they also: 1. Ensure electric charging is as widespread as fuelling up 2. Make EVs as reliable and serviceable as normal cars 3. (This one's just wishful thinking) Pass some kind of law banning all-singing-dancing-touchscreen interfaces Otherwise it's the same as taking away something without providing a proper alternative. People will at best maliciously comply, but more likely just find ways around your laws. Laws don't solve issues by themselves.
- kkfx 4y agoMy personal set of issue is (owning now an BEV and a classic EU diesel): - EV batteries, so EVs, are damn expensive and degrade around 3% per year for LiFeP witch are far more robust than ncd, I can't estimate how likely a battery total fault is but it's still a damn big issue. BEVs by themselves nowadays being far more efficient than ICEs are almost on-par in opex terms, at least in EU where the charging infra is not optimal but already spread enough they are just a bit sub-par in CASUAL long-range usage as long as we can charge at home at night or are secondary vehicles and/or we do not live too much at north. So IF they'll reach a price parity with actual ICEs they might be ok for most but still not all private car's usages. - EV charging infra economics, at least the one in EU, must be annihilated. We have tons of different chargers and we do not pay them directly, instead we need some third party service, often just a website who sell rfid cars/badges, with obscure tariffs that vary MUCH for a single unique station from ZERO to $many€. Such kind of "free market" must be erased. - EV AND modern ICE crapware is so DANGEROUS for all that we must banish by laws any black-box. We must mandate open hardware and free software punishing so hard any anti-user feature that no OEM would be so suicidal to try. We must NOT allow connected cars who are de-facto in the hand of their OEM, instead of those of their formal owner. We must forbid tie cars to mobile crap devices through any NON-local network except for single users PERSONAL VPNs/services hosted individually. A day with such modern cars, for instance because of a annoyed lamer or a political move or something else all cars of a certain set of OEMs will go to some important road interception and remain bricked there paralyzing even an entire nation or start to suck power straining the grid etc. Such kind of attacks are already described, far from being theory and so dangerous that the tech allowing them must not be allowed to exists on sale. Beside that. WFH and having a p.v. system in a sunny-enough place, I feel a bit of economy even if not enough to pay back the car price before it will go to the trash. I see NO other real ecological reason behind them. It's just a needed evolution because we can't improve ICEs anymore and so it's time to change the tech. In pollution terms shifting it to exotic places is not being eco-friendly.