2 ms·
>What GDP gives us is a way to frame policy. >Policy-makers will say "our research shows lowering taxes will do X and increase GDP", or "our research shows rai
by gruez 4y ago
>What GDP gives us is a way to frame policy.
>Policy-makers will say "our research shows lowering taxes will do X and increase GDP", or "our research shows raising taxes will do Y and increase GDP". That happens now. I don't think we usually actually manage to tie an actual law or policy, as implemented, back to a change in GDP pretty much ever. It's not really the scientific method.
Strong disagree on this. Policies aren't just framed on "GDP goes up, we should do it", they're framed on "GDP goes up by $x at the cost of $y, so we should do it". A policy that claims to increase GDP, but where $x is smaller than $y is going to get shot down even if it sounds good.
With GDP there's at least some way of checking your estimates. You can fudge your estimates up or down by changing your assumptions, but in the end you're still trying to pin down how much economic activity will occur and that can be cross-checked with tax records or government statistics. How are you going to do the same with GNP?