10 ms·
I made outlines for KDE Breeze window decoration
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y ago> But what happens if shadows are disabled? > Something cheeky happens! I actually draw the shadows with 0% alpha channel! Does that still pay the performance cost to "draw" them, or does it get optimized away?
- sdwvit 4y agoKDE uses gpu acceleration for its ui. So that should be a negligible impact on performance. I am unsure about if you even have shadows with CPU rendering.
- tmtvl 4y agoUsing software rendering instead of OpenGL disables most if not all effects from what I remember.
- formerly_proven 4y agoiirc software rendering in kwin disables compositing alltogether
- BearOso 4y agoIf you're using a compositor you're paying the cost. The rounded corners are antialiased, so blending happens regardless.
- thesuitonym 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoKDE getting window borders, Gnome getting thumbnails in the file picker, what's going on? Next you're gonna tell me that Wayland will be usable in the next decade.
- sdwvit 4y agoAs stated by one of the core KDE contributors, they (KDE team) want to make KDE appealing for regular users more, thus KDE6 work is focused on bugfixing and polishing the UX. https://pointieststick.com/2022/10/28/this-week-in-kde-next-generation-improvements/ https://pointieststick.com/2022/10/28/this-week-in-kde-next-...
- Arnavion 4y ago>Next you're gonna tell me that Wayland will be usable in the next decade. It's already usable today, so I don't see why you'd need to wait for a decade.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>It's already usable today, so I don't see why you'd need to wait for a decade. No, it's not usable for me. I still can't share my screen in Slack or Teams making calls with Windows and Mac colleagues an embarrassing mess. Firefox in Ubuntu 22.04 has Wayland disabled by default (why though, if Wayland is so usable?) No scroll acceleration settings. Currently, Wayland is one step forward, one step back. Especially that many highly used apps still haven't made the switch and that Wayland has not yet feature parity to what X11 offered.
- Arnavion 4y ago>I still can't share my screen in Slack or Teams making calls with Windows and Mac colleagues an embarrassing mess. Works fine in at least all wlroots compositors (via xdpw) and in GNOME (via xdpgtk). The Electron versions presumably don't use PW so they'll only share Xwayland windows. The browser versions will be able to share everything through xdp since all major browsers support PW. >Firefox in Ubuntu 22.04 has Wayland disabled by default (why though, if Wayland is so usable?) Dunno, works for me. Firefox isn't exactly the poster-child of intelligent decisions. >No scroll acceleration settings. Depends on the compositor. sway supports them. Not a Wayland problem. >Currently, Wayland is one step forward, one step back. Nope. >Especially that many highly used apps still haven't made the switch Yes they have. For starters, every GTK3+ and Qt 5+ program will already use Wayland if it exists. >Wayland has not yet feature parity to what X11 offered. Yes it has.
- Gualdrapo 4y agoThis is not new to KDE (there was QtCurve, Aurora...) and nowhere it says so, but only new to Breeze.
- jstimpfle 4y agoWhile we're at it, Windows 10 suffers the same problem.
- marwis 4y agoBoth Win10 and Win11 will draw outline using accent color if you enable "Show accent color on title bars and windows borders". There are also tools to configure it further.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- BearOso 4y agoIt's not the feature that's interesting, it's the story from an outsider describing an experience of working on it and getting it added to KDE.
- johnthescott 4y agojust a heads up, the links are dead for exploding screen snapshots: https://www.akselmo.dev/2022/10/31/assets/images/kde/outline_dark.jpg https://www.akselmo.dev/2022/10/31/assets/images/kde/outline...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Arnavion 4y agoYes, all the href's are missing leading `/`
- alex3305 4y agoI haven't touched KDE in maybe 15 years. I just always defaulted to Gnome when I'm on Linux desktop. But this looks more macOS like. Just curious, is there any reason I should try KDE today?
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>is there any reason I should try KDE today The DE is a personal preference thing. It's nobody's job to convince you to try anything. It's up to you to decide to try it if you're curious. Since you haven't tried KDE in 15 years, you've probably missed a lot. There are also countless KDE Reviews online and on YouTube.
- sirsinsalot 4y agoI went back to KDE after a lifetime using Gnome (and then Cinnamon when Gnome3 ruined things). KDE has been a joy and is now my DE of choice.
- warning26 4y agoI mean, what do you have to lose? Install it and see how you like it!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- slbtty 4y agoGNOME is being obsoleted by KDE.
- DivineBicycle 4y agoYeah right
- rs_rs_rs_rs_rs 4y agoOne can hope...
- ASalazarMX 4y ago
- anthk 4y agoEven if today I use mostly the CLI, cwm and OpenBSD, I miss Keramik.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoIt’s always nice to read about someone contributing to open source. Looking at the screenshots I have a question for the KDE users here. I am surprised by the incorrect kerning and strange padding on display in the interface. Is that normal or is it a consequence of it being so customisable the author likes settings which leads to this result?
- vhanda 4y agoIn my experience, it's normal. Eventually you get used to it, and start ignoring it. Sadly. I'd switched to Gnome for many years, but in the end - being able to easy tweak the desktop to my liking drove me back to KDE.
- shmerl 4y agoCan you please point out what that means in that sceenshot? Fonts generally got pretty good with fontconfig, but I suppose there are always some edge cases.
- xbar 4y agoPerhaps lowercase o gets excessive space? I'm guessing here. It's the only element that seems even remotely mis-kerned.
- shmerl 4y agoI don't really see anything off about it personally.
- jesperwe 4y agoFor example look at the "New" in the dark screen. N/e too wide compared to e/w.
- shmerl 4y agoHere it's zoomed in: https://i.imgur.com/jFeQJTm.png https://i.imgur.com/jFeQJTm.png Looks like equal distance but there is more blurring between e and w so they can appear closer.
- waltbosz 4y agoI have a visual impairment that make it really hard for me to distinguish objects where the is little contrast. This new UI trend of one pixel borders is a big annoyance for me. I constantly click the wrong window. I actually wrote a Windows app to do something like this. It's sitting in my unfinished folder because I ran into too many issues to fix for a hobby project. The rectangle data for Windows apps seems to vary widely. I needed a bunch of different formulas to correct for the rectangles I was getting back from the WinAPI calls. One of my features was a different border color for each app. I tried various color rules, such as multiple copies of VSCode would each get their own shade of blue, or cycle through colors of the rainbow.
- Jedd 4y agoMicrosoft Windows is abysmal on this front - I have to use Microsoft Windows 10 periodically, while most of my life is spent in KDE, and the disjoint is jarring. In KDE I can precisely control and set window border thickness and colour. In Microsoft Windows 10 (and I assume 11 has continued the trend at making this even worse) I can enable a very thin border, of a themed colour, and that border disappears when the window is no longer in focus. This means a couple of terminal windows (eg gitbash) have near impossible to discern edges when they're overlapping. On top of this, some Microsoft applications seem to break their own styling rules (Office apps, say) which I suspect is the kind of issue that stalled your project.
- Ayesh 4y agoYeah, I recently started to use KDE Plasma with Fedora (after Gnome left a sour taste), and the amount of customizations it allows is mind-blowing. This may be common knowledge, but as a newcomer to KDE, these very precise controls are quite a fresh breath from OSs like Win10/11 and Mac OS. Reminded me of those Windows 98 shell customizations. Windows seems to be going backwards when it comes to customizations; there are only a few customizations allowed in Windows 11 now.
- vladvasiliu 4y agoWindows 11 seems a bit better on this front than 10. I don't use either very often (mostly for gaming and sometimes at work) but I have yet to see the active window having the same color as a background one, or even be unable to tell where one window stops and the other begins.
- bityard 4y agoI don't know if the submitter here is the author of this, but if the author is here, I have just two words for them: THANK YOU! Over the past few years, UI design has been trending towards removing ALL visual cues of how to interact with software and programs. It's intensely weird that we are actually making computers HARDER to use, not easier. Need some examples? Okay! * Menus containing frequently-used program functions are hidden away behind abstract, arbitrary icons. * There is no separation between parts of a UI that do different things. It's all "flat." * Buttons that perform actions are just text now, and usually look like all other text on the screen. * Icons are now all monochrome, except for branding purposes. * Scrollbars, when they even still exist, are thin lines that only appear while you scroll, making them effectively useless for grabbing with the mouse to quickly navigate through a document. * On Windows and GNOME, titlebars are effectively no longer a thing anymore. Each program implements their own, leading to an inconsistent look and behavior between applications. The only explanation that I can come up with is that most developers these days either use tiling window managers or just fullscreen every application. Lack of window borders is another item on this list. My monitor is quite often filled with overlapping windows and lack of border means it's often hard to tell at a glance where one window ends and the other begins. Shadows can help sometimes but aren't as useful for "dark mode" or windows with dark backgrounds. KDE is better than most other desktop environments about retaining useful desktop functionality while all the others are trying their damndest to throw it all away. I hope this makes it into a release!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- xbar 4y agoAgreed. Finding this in a KDE release would be <insert metaphor that makes you joyful>.
- blakewatson 4y agoAs someone who has to use scrollbars for accessibility reasons, I too hate the war on scrollbars. It is such a useful, battle-tested UI component.
- continuational 4y ago
- shmerl 4y agoSo this is essentially an enhancement of shadows?
- unknownaccount 4y agoThis can be accomplished on Windows11 with a custom Visual Style. Ive seen it done before on some deviantart themes. Would be cool if someone could release a stock Windows11 Visual Style with only this modified.
- ComputerGuru 4y agoJust turn on accent color window borders. No third party software required.
- unknownaccount 4y agoIf you want to increase the thickness I mean.
- tecoholic 4y agoThis is nice. One of the reasons I still stick to the "Plastik" style and haven't moved to Breeze is the "smoothness" of the interface. This seems to bring in some definition to the interface. I know plastik feels so old and out of date. But it feels more tactile to me because of the higher gradients.
- TillE 4y agoPlastik was the height of KDE style and usability for me. It looked similar to but way better than Windows XP, and KDE could do so much more. Then KDE4 got lost in an ugly, buggy mess of transparency.
- jraph 4y agoAnd Oxygen (the default theme), used a depressing gray. On KDE 4, I used Fusion or Cleanlooks (a port of the Clearlooks GTK theme). KDE 5 went the other way and Breeze looks great. I sometimes try other theme but always come back to Breeze. I even used Breeze on GNOME and found it better-looking than Adwaita.
- nyanpasu64 4y agoI'm glad that windows have outlines, but I'm still disappointed KDE has switched both foreground and background windows to light titlebars by default. This is something I change out of the box on both Windows 10 (dark gray accent color for title bar) and KDE (Breeze Classic color scheme).
- Timja 4y agoThis is something I have been missing in KDE for a long time! How does one use it? Is it a script I can put somewhere on my laptop and then the borders will have outlines?
- diffeomorphism 4y agoYou wait a bit until it is merged and you get it with updates. Then you click on it in settings.
- Timja 4y agoThat would take years. I use Debian Stable. I think Plasma has something like "Decorations" - can a custom decoration be used? Can one use scripts in the "Decorations"?
- michaelmrose 4y agoThat would sound like a self inflicted wound. Personally I really loved emerald the window decorator along with compiz.
- Timja 4y agoCan you elaborate? What sounds like a wound? What is emerald, what is compiz and how does this all related to window borders?
- diffeomorphism 4y agoTranslation: That sounds like you caused this problem for yourself by choosing debian stable. emerald, compiz: fairly famous window managers/compositors everyone used to use, e.g. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4QokOwvPxrE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4QokOwvPxrE > how is this related to window borders compiz is famous for including all sorts of fancy/over the top effects like windows going up in flames, so stuff like glowing window borders should be no problem at all. By now compiz seems mostly unused, but many effects are also available in kwin. For instance system settings -> desktop behavior -> desktop effects -> dim inactive Kinda the opposite of outlines, where it just dims everything else instead of highlighting one, but maybe it works for you?
- WhyNotHugo 4y agoA common trick on css is two add two shadows. The first one is more intense, but has a very small radius. The second one has a larger radius, but a less intense colour. This is a play on how shadows work on real life; where objects may have a strong shadow from an overhead lamp, and a softer shadow via lighting bleeding in from windows or other rooms. The results of this are very subtle -- an untrained eye sees just "a shadow" and not two (I can only recognise this because a designer friend taught me this trick). I wonder if applying a similar technique on window borders could work. But instead of the inner shadow being less intense, it would be a higher contrast one. It's definitely worth exploring. Personally, I'm prefer simple borders instead of shadows. They take up just 1 or 2px (e.g.: maximise space efficiency), and are super clear.