4 ms·
Please stop being the highlight of zero sum thinking. Let's make up a hypothetical example. The government says you have to install a safety rail and the amort
by pixl97 4y ago
Please stop being the highlight of zero sum thinking.
Let's make up a hypothetical example. The government says you have to install a safety rail and the amortized cost is $1 a year.
You: OMG, this is going to cost $100 over the next century, a huge loss, I am destroyed.
Reality: Johnny doesn't fall of the equipment being coming paralyzed (costing you an immediate $200 in lawsuit and payout fees) and is able to produce economic product over the next few decades bringing in $400 to the economy. Net win for everyone.
That's where the money comes from. Or would you rather be like Russia where you have a giant potential economy that outputs less than Italy and doesn't give a damned about corruption and has terrible quality of living standards/longevity?
- WalterBright 4y agoHere ya go (not a hypothetical example): https://slate.com/business/2022/10/san-francisco-toilet-million-noe-valley-design-review.html https://slate.com/business/2022/10/san-francisco-toilet-mill... They beat out Seattle, that spent $250,000 on a portable toilet a few years ago. On my own street, the city water outfit installed a fire hydrant. It cost $10,000, including architectural drawings of the installation. When the crew came out to install the hydrant (the main water line runs under my property) I asked them if they'd seen the drawings. They said "what drawings?" They'd never seen nor talked to the engineer, nor had any idea there ever was one. I asked them what the hydrant cost. They said $2,000. They had a machine on the back of the truck that was able to dig the hole, drill the main, and clamp on the new hydrant in 15 minutes. This was 20 some years ago, back when $10,000 was real money. The IRS now requires any business that sends out payments to an individual of more than $600 per year now has to file 1099s. The threshold used to be $20,000. A lot of ebay-ers are in for a big surprise. Do you have receipts for what you paid for items you sold on ebay?
- shadowgovt 4y agoAnecdotes about corruption and mismanagement do not address the underlying point that government spending is not zero-sum. That hydrant was probably too expensive (maybe; insufficient data to say for sure). The damage if a fire breaks out and no municipal fire system is available in a modern city is catastrophic.
- WalterBright 4y ago> Anecdotes I gave real examples, not hypotheticals. I never said government spending was zero-sum. > That hydrant was probably too expensive The bill was $10,000 for a $3,000 job. > The damage if a fire breaks out and no municipal fire system is available in a modern city is catastrophic. At $10,000 a pop there'll be a lot fewer hydrants installed, and hence greater risk of catastrophic fire.
- shadowgovt 4y agoAnecdotes aren't hypotheticals; they're single data points with insufficient signal to predict a trend or pattern.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 4y agoYou can believe the government is efficient if you like. The fact remains that there's been massive growth in government, and that is going to be paid for out of the economy.
- shadowgovt 4y agoMaybe I've just spent too many years in government contracting, but when I hear that a government program is growing, I hear economic stimulus, not pulling something out of the economy.
- WalterBright 4y agoI wonder why those countries that "stimulate" their economies tend to do poorly.
- shadowgovt 4y ago
- pixl97 4y agoThe guy installing the meter was told where to install it, they are not the architect that make sure it actually works if they install top many so it's not a surprise. It's no different than me 20 years ago installing a server for a client. I would go out slap it in and turn it on. I did not architect the applications on it, nor configure the firewall rules on the router for it to work. News articles are written about exceptional things, not the mundane.
- WalterBright 4y agoI saw the drawings. As an engineer, I can assert they were completely custom made and completely unnecessary. You don't need architectural drawings to determine if the flow is sufficient. Besides, everyone knew the flow was sufficient because it would be the only hydrant upstream of a flow reducer in the main line. I.e. there was plenty of pressure in the line. The drawings were completely superfluous to a bog-standard install. > News articles are written about exceptional things That's true. The hydrant wasn't in the news. Want another one that wasn't exceptional enough to make the news? A nearby one mile stretch of road has been undergoing repaving for THREE YEARS now. BTW, did you read the article about SF? It blames the permitting process which takes forever and $$$$. That affects everything in SF.