7 ms·
More than a third of US small businesses couldn’t pay all their rent in October
- jrs235 4y agohttps://archive.ph/1zraL https://archive.ph/1zraL
- Cwizard 4y ago> It’s up seven percentage points from last month and is now at the highest pace this year, the survey showed. > More than half say their rent is at least 10% higher than it was six months ago, and in seven say rents have increased at least 20%.
- fma 4y agoI can't speak for all business owner, but as a business owner I signed a 5 year lease with an option to renew...so I know my rent price 10 years out. My price only changes at the 5 year market and I knew it when signing the lease. Who are these people where their rent changes 6 months? When we looked around these are fairly common terms... I mean technically our rate increased last year so we are part of some, statistics but it's meaningless.
- beckingz 4y ago(chuckles) I'm in danger. Nothing profitable makes it out of the near future I suppose.
- mech422 4y agoObligatory: https://imgur.com/gallery/XS5LK https://imgur.com/gallery/XS5LK
- skyyler 4y agoAs much as I wish it were the opposite, I have a feeling that the near future will venerate Nick Land in a lot of ways.
- mech422 4y agoheh - guess we're the only 2 memer's :-P
- mech422 4y agoNot sure if people don't know the "I'm in danger" meme(1) or just have no sense of humor :-P 1) https://imgur.com/gallery/VQWPsBS https://imgur.com/gallery/VQWPsBS
- mech422 4y agook - yep, its have no sense of humor...
- O__________O 4y agoDirect link to related survey report, which has a lot more data than what is mentioned by the press: https://www.alignable.com/forum/rent-delinquency-jumps-7-to-37-in-u-s-in-october https://www.alignable.com/forum/rent-delinquency-jumps-7-to-...
- bombcar 4y ago> In September, rent delinquency was at a six-month low, as optimism for Q4's earning potential was high and some small business owners reported increased sales. > But now, a month later, 37% of small business owners in the U.S. were unable to pay their rent in full and on time in October, compared to just 30% in September. So 30% was a six-month low, and 7% more is a record surge. This implies that a surprisingly large percentage of small business owners are always behind on rent. Another thing to remember is that the landlord gets paid last - if you miss a wage payment to your staff the local government will crawl right up your arse and explode, if you miss a tax payment the IRS will do something similar (though a bit later). If you start stiffing your suppliers you'll have nothing to sell, and if you fall behind on utilities you'll get them cut off. But if you stiff the landlord he's not going to evict you right away, especially if you make a partial payment (note the "in full") and he has nobody better to rent to, anyway.
- mschuster91 4y ago> But if you stiff the landlord he's not going to evict you right away, especially if you make a partial payment (note the "in full") and he has nobody better to rent to, anyway. I'm not shedding tears for landlords. Most of them charge exorbitant rent while still enjoying absurdly low interest rates of the last decade on their loans and doing the bare minimum (or none at all) of maintenance or investment into improvements (e.g. bring electricity and water grids or insulation up to code). I seriously hope that the current market crash brings down rents massively to affordable prices, but as long as landlords can get tax advantages for un-rented units especially large corporations don't have an incentive to lower rents - it will take a lot of no or partial payments to force their hands. An alternative would be vacancy taxes, but these are hard to pass if half the legislators are bought off by large real estate investors and their banks.
- rednerrus 4y agoIsn't this testing the elasticity of rent prices? Some of what's going on inflation wise is that companies are finding their prices to be more elastic than they previously thought. It seems that we are entering the edge of elasticity with the potential that the whole thing might snap.
- bArray 4y agoJust 3 weeks ago people were mocking me about the incoming recession [1]. These companies that can't pay their bills are going to lay-off staff just to stay afloat. Unemployment is about to skyrocket. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33149381 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33149381
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ROTMetro 4y agoI wouldn't really call that mocking. Black Friday is typically the day when business' get 'into the black' for the year. Things typically get tight in October with having to both prepare for a November increase while being a lean month. This doesn't seem all that different than the position all of the startups and small businesses I have worked at or had insight into from the past. What is different is the Fed, media, and large corporations are trying really really hard to talk down the economy into a fear based recession this time, complaining loudly about the growing cost of labour and how that is the end of the world, yet bragging about record profits taken 'under the guise of inflation' on their earnings calls. Meanwhile, consumer confidence is the highest since Feb. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-09-27/us-consumer-confidence-rises-a-second-month-to-most-since-april#:~:text=A%20measure%20of%20expectations%20%2D%2D,and%20a%20robust%20job%20market https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-09-27/us-consum.... I'll go with consumer sentiment and historical knowledge over an artificial narrative and fake hysteria along with a Fed push intended to increase unemployed to keep down labor costs for companies posting record profits in this horrible (yet record setting) economy.
- autoexec 4y ago
- kelseyfrog 4y agoI don't get it. If they are struggling to pay rent, can't they just get a second business?
- paxys 4y agoBut I'm sure the new luxury car the owner bought using their taxpayer-funded PPP "loan" is working great.
- barbazoo 4y agoIt would be funny if it weren't true to a large extend apparently :/
- mschuster91 4y agoThat's a matter of enforcement and audits. The problem is IRS [1] (and their equivalents in other Western countries, e.g. Germany [2]) are horribly understaffed which means that small businesses get hit the hardest by audits, while large-scale tax fraud gets ignored routinely - simply because fighting a large corporation is more expensive for the IRS as the effort required to sift through the data is way higher and the corporations have a ton of very expensive lawyers on retainer that can drag out cases for years. [1] https://www.businessinsider.com/tax-season-outlook-analysis-difficult-refunds-delayed-irs-understaffed-2022-1 https://www.businessinsider.com/tax-season-outlook-analysis-... [2] https://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/soziales/unterbesetzte-behoerden-finanzbeamten-mangel-kostet-deutschland-milliarden-euro-a-687156.html https://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/soziales/unterbesetzte-beh...
- aaomidi 4y agoYep. And right now we have the right thinking we’re setting up a gestapo because we want to fund the IRS. To be honest though the IRS has an awful track record of focusing on lower income people :(
- mschuster91 4y agoAt least to me, a partial cause for that is the Scientology "church" in the 1970s and later [1]. When the IRS backed down due to their threats instead of hitting them with fines, that sent a very bad signal: if you're big and aggressive enough, we'll let you continue making a joke out of the tax code and focus on smaller fishes instead. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_status_of_Scientology_in_the_United_States#Obstruction_of_the_IRS_and_conspiracy_to_defraud https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_status_of_Scientology_in_t...
- wwweston 4y agoEither this means commercial-use space isn't as overbuilt as people have been claiming, or vacancy taxes are really needed.
- bombcar 4y agoThe commercial real estate market is basically nothing like what anyone not in the commercial real estate market thinks it is. Everything that applies to single family home rentals and even much that applies to apartment/multi family rentals is out the window. (Though arguably triple net leases would make sense in many cases vis-a-vis home rentals.) Vacancy taxes would also be the easiest thing in the world to get around, you'd just blanket the world with Spirit Halloween stores.
- wwweston 4y ago"Just" seems to be doing a lot of work in that last sentence. I'm sure you know the idea behind vacancy taxes is to incentivize owners to offer rents that not only serve nominal purposes in making finance/accounting work but actually get takers so the space is productively used and mitigate any weird dynamics where there's simultaneously empty space there's no takers on and would-be renters who can't find anything they can afford, a situation which presents an apparent market failure. If Spirit Halloween or whatever equivalent you're imagining is offered a rent they're willing to pay, then there is no market failure and policy is working. How does that represent "getting around" the vacancy tax? Are we imagining that owners are creating Shell Game Seasonal Retail Inc™ and renting to themselves?
- bombcar 4y agoSpirit Halloween, small churches, etc all rent at far below market rates for various reasons, one of which would be "avoiding vacancy taxes". The key is they're always month-to-month and can be booted quickly if a "real" client shows up. I was with a smallish business that rented the other half of our building this way as temporary warehouse space, for something like 10% what we were paying for the warehouse space on "our side of the fence". I think they could be structured in such a way as to at least help the situation, but they'd for certain be gamed.
- 3qz 4y ago
- GamerUncle 4y agowhy ? I think people have the right to start a small venture, like out of all the things to hate, why would you hate people not serving megacorporations ? I am genuinely baffled and would like to know where this opinion comes from.
- bombcar 4y agoI'll try to steelman a few arguments: 1. Small businesses under a certain size avoid many labor/work related laws - for example, the requirement to buy healthcare doesn't apply below 20(?) employees. 2. Small businesses almost always have actually worse support overall, but they get away with it because they can "fire" customers. Walmart has a better return policy than almost anything else in the retail world, for example, because they can eat the costs related to idiots scamming them. 3. Small businesses often get away with treating their employees worse than larger ones, because nobody is going to care of Jane's Coffee Shop stiffed a waitress on tips on Wednesday, but if it happened at a Starbucks it'd be on the national news that night. 4. Small businesses enable people and families to be relatively independent of "large control" which is absolutely not desired by certain groups.
- duxup 4y agoThe article talks about rents going up 10 to 20%. Have we seen situations like this where we then see rents drop as far as historical patterns go?
- jupp0r 4y agoNot even in the completely insane property market downturn in 2008 did rents go down, so no, this basically never happens.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Splizard 4y agoThese businesses should be paid by the landlord to occupy (and therefore maintain) the property for them. This notion that you can own land without occupying it (or paying somebody to occupy it) is an absurdly backwards idea that is responsible for a lot of suffering and exploitation in modern society. We've constructed a bit of a euphemism for this. "I just want to make a living to put food on my plate". Except it's not the food that's expensive. It's the rent. Which in many places, for low income earners amounts to greater than 50% of their take home pay. In my city there are dozens of empty stores in the CBD "for lease" as if there is no demand for use of these properties. Absolutely ridiculous. Strangely enough, everyone thinks that renting a home or workplace to occupy is a perfectly normal thing to do. Would be great to have a discussion on this.
- causality0 4y agoAgree. Imagine if someone claimed dominion over a chunk of the sky or an acre of water. You'd call him a fool and ignore him. The only way land is different is that it's easier to demarcate.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoPlease look up "air rights".
- dwaite 4y agoNations generally do claim dominion over their waterways, coastlines, and airspace, and maintain military forces which can enforce such things.
- gremlinsinc 4y agoNations, but people and corporations aren't nations. Can apply institute a no fly-zone over their HQ? Edit: meaning land, air, water should belong to the people of said nation, and should be taxed as such and divided out to the people as guaranteed basic income.
- 4y ago
- throw8383833jj 4y ago>> "More than half say their rent is at least 10% higher than it was six months ago, and in seven say rents have increased at least 20%." And it's not just businesses of course. we all know how high rents have gotten in residential. but, what really gets me is that it does NOT have to be this way. I've been reading Henry david thoreau a writer from 200 years ago and I was stunned about how much higher their standard of living was for shelter. Here are some figures from thoreau's book walden: Unskilled labor was paid 1$ per day Skilled labor 1.50$ to 2$ per day Land was 8$ per acre Average Houses cost 800 days of unskilled labor (800$) Rent for a "Spacious apartment" with lots of bells and whistles was 50$/yr (25-100$/yr) so about 50 days of labor per year. Now, look how far we've fallen in the last 200 years: at 100$ a day for unskilled labor The average house now costs 3000 days of unskilled labor plus another 2000 days for property taxes over 50 years. -> that's 5000 days almost 6 times more than 200 years ago. Apartments: for 50 days of unskilled labor, thats 5000$ a year, you couldn't even rent a room for that much. * The spacious apartment Henry described included the following: "Rumford fireplace, Venetian blinds, Copper pump and many more things" Our standard of living for providing shelter has dropped so significantly, that now it takes 30 years to pay off a house whereas back then it took only 10 years, with higher interest rates too! thoreau felt even this was too long and too much of burden, so we went off into the woods and built himself a nice little cabin for just 28$ (cost of building material) And yes, they didn't have electricity and some of the things we have today. so, there are some differences. Did we simply get worse at building shelter? No, of course not. The problem is all regulation and zoning and land use policy. Are our regulations so precious that we would give up so much? Shelter and housing whether its for business or residential doesn't need to be so scarce or hard to come by: it's a political choice people have made.
- anomaly_ 4y agoYou understand that the relatively low cost of living until the last 50 years or so was built on the systematic oppression of minorities and women, right?
- throw8383833jj 4y agoThat's an interesting theorey. If it's correct that could explain it. But, I just checked the demographics in Massachusets in the 1800s and it shows that there were 0 slaves. And it looks like minorities were in very very small numbers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1800_United_States_census https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1800_United_States_census I don't think the labor supply of oppressed minorities was influential enough to drive down the cost of labor. Yes, for railroads sure but not for construction of buildings.
- jupp0r 4y agoWhat's the base rate for this to compare it to? Ie what percentage of businesses can't pay all their rent normally?
- twobitshifter 4y ago>Almost half of car repair shops and auto dealerships were not able to meet their rent this month, the report said. I’m very surprised that dealerships are having troubles. Haven’t they been charging all time high markups?
- curmudgeon22 4y agoMy (relatively uninformed) understanding is that they are only able to charge these markups because of a similarly "all time" lack of inventory, leading to scarcity of vehicles to sell. The increase in transaction value isn't making up for the decrease in transaction volume.
- SecurityMinded 4y agoAccording to the POTUS, "The US economy is BOOMING"
- Krisjohn 4y agoCouldn’t or didn’t? When I worked IT at a real estate place, tenants routinely didn’t pay rent until chased up by the asset managers.