3 ms·
>This is largely down to GOP-administration tax cuts for the ultra-wealthy and to a lesser extent the Iraq War. Source for this? Based on a cursory search the
by gruez 4y ago
>This is largely down to GOP-administration tax cuts for the ultra-wealthy and to a lesser extent the Iraq War.
Source for this? Based on a cursory search the numbers don't seem to match up.
* The current national debt is $24.19T or $30.85T, depending on how you count[1]
* The CBO estimated the bush tax cuts to have added $1.5T to the debt between 2002-2011[2]
* The CBO estimated that if the bush cuts were fully extended at all income levels, it would add $3.0T to the debt over 2010 to 2019[2]. I skimmed the article and it looks like that obama only partially extended it, so $3.0T is more of an upper bound
* The CBO estimated that the trump tax cuts[3] would add $2.289T (or $1.891 trillion "after taking into account macroeconomic feedback effects") over 10 years. Again, this is also an upper bound because the tax cuts have only been effect for 5 years but the figure is for over 10 years.
If you add all the estimates you get an upper bound of around $6.8T, which is a good chunk of the the current debt but I wouldn't characterize the debt as being "largely" due to the tax cuts. Not to mention, the figures above are overestimates due to the reasons I previously mentioned.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_debt_of_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_debt_of_the_United_St...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bush_tax_cuts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bush_tax_cuts
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_Cuts_and_Jobs_Act_of_2017 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_Cuts_and_Jobs_Act_of_2017
- jacobolus 4y agoNow try looking at tax cuts starting from the Reagan administration.
- gruez 4y agoWhy don't you look at those numbers, and then report back to us? Given that you haven't provided any source for your claim and my previous attempt at validating your claim failed, it only makes sense for you to do the legwork this time around.
- jacobolus 4y agoIt’s a counterfactual question, so of course cannot be answered perfectly (or even well) – supporters of tax cuts claim (without very good evidence) that tax cuts spur growth and thus boost revenue. But for example this analysis suggests ~ $13 trillion of the debt between 2000–2025 can be explained by tax cuts after 2000, mostly during GOP administrations: https://itep.org/federal-tax-cuts-in-the-bush-obama-and-trump-years/ https://itep.org/federal-tax-cuts-in-the-bush-obama-and-trum... It’s hard to find any kind of careful analysis about the counterfactual question of cumulative differences in revenue and taxes if Carter-era tax policy had remained in place for the past 40 years. It requires making strong, almost certainly unjustified, assumptions about the rest of federal policy and the trajectory of the economy. But we’re talking about cumulative numbers on the order of 10 trillion dollars, to within say a factor of two. You also have to decide what to lump in with the same set of policy changes (e.g. successive reductions in IRS enforcement capability, cumulatively leaving $trillions more on the table, changes to labor law and the minimum wage, ...). And there are certainly other large-scale sources of deficits. Some of the Reagan tax cuts were offset by substantial increases in payroll taxes, shifting the tax burden from the wealthiest onto the working class, and depressing after-tax wages.