4 ms·
There are plenty of liberal reasons to dislike race-based admission processes as well. I agree with the spirit of what these programs are trying to accomplish,
by kube-system 4y ago
There are plenty of liberal reasons to dislike race-based admission processes as well. I agree with the spirit of what these programs are trying to accomplish, but punishing Asian applicants for their race is a perfect example of what is wrong with this solution from a fundamental level.
- robertlagrant 4y agoThis is the distinction between old-school liberal (judge by content of character not colour of skin; what you do behind closed doors is your business as much as possible; free speech) and more recent liberal, which seems far more likely to keep the middle of those three, but jettison the others. Bill Maher's journey over the last 2 years has been interesting to watch as he tries to berate the modern left into returning to liberal roots.
- eli 4y agoAre you conflating liberal and libertarian? MLK, of course, coined the phrase "content of character not color of skin" and he was very much in favor of affirmative action.
- weberer 4y agoNope. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberalism
- robertlagrant 4y ago> Are you conflating liberal and libertarian? I don't think so. Old school liberal and modern libertarian are fairly closely related. The term libertarian has appeared I think due to the changing of the word liberal. > MLK, of course, coined the phrase "content of character not color of skin" and he was very much in favor of affirmative action. Sure, at least sort of. But this conflates a principle (the thing I quoted) with one man's politics.
- hedora 4y agoI don't think that's the point. This court has been shredding the rule of law in this country for the last year, and is systematically replacing our democracy with fascism. Their ruling is definitely going to be more damaging to minorities than anything I can come up with. Hell, they banned abortion by eliminating the right to privacy in the US. They were even complete assholes about it. Despite being minority (and arguably illegally, in some cases) appointed, they blame the (underage) women their rulings victimize for not voting enough. The text of the ruling explicitly states that no ruling the court makes could be sexist or victimize women, since women are allowed to vote. I fully expect this ruling to use similar logic to blow an equally large hole in our constitutional rights.
- kube-system 4y agoI’m certainly not defending this court, their motivations, or any tangential effects their opinions might contain. Purely on the merits of the topic: taking an admissions slot from an Asian student and giving it to someone of a different racial background is, plainly, racial discrimination. If we want to help people of a disadvantaged background, we need to find a better way to measure that directly rather than using race as a proxy. Using race as a proxy in prejudging someone isn’t okay even if you think you’re right. Prejudiced people don’t think that they’re wrong.
- eli 4y ago"Taking an admissions slot from an Asian student" is a very opinionated way to describe the situation and strictly speaking it isn't true.
- kube-system 4y agoI’m not an expert on these admission practices, so I can’t say whether the claim is true, but that is what is being claimed, no?
- eli 4y agoYes, that is what's being claimed by the plaintiff and if you accept their characterization it does seem like an easy case. That's probably true for most cases.