5 ms·
Julia Roberts reveals Martin Luther King Jr paid the hospital bill for her birth
- downrightmike 4y ago
- popularrecluse 4y agoWhat inspires someone to write a jack-assed comment like this?
- aasasd 4y ago
- HWR_14 4y agoProbably someone who wants to talk about the vast increase in hospital costs, especially to patients, over the past ~50+ years. You know, as opposed to what the article is about.
- eesmith 4y agoExcept childbirth cost more than $1 in the 1960s. https://www.workingmomsagainstguilt.com/the-cost-of-having-a-baby-in-1950/ https://www.workingmomsagainstguilt.com/the-cost-of-having-a... gives an example of $86.33 in 1950. https://www.cryo-cell.com/blog/april-2017/when-childbirth-cost-100-dollars https://www.cryo-cell.com/blog/april-2017/when-childbirth-co... shows $165 for 1950, $155 for 1957, etc.
- HWR_14 4y ago1) Yes, it's a slight case of hyperbole 2) The majority of the $165 in 1950 was the 1 week hospital stay (and 6 days of nursery care) instead of a 1 day hospital stay. 3) After accounting for the 1 week hospital stay, the biggest remaining cost was for anesthesia. Which is always expensive. Epidurals instead should have driven the costs way down. 4) So that would leave $45 if they left after a modern hospital stay with an epidural. 5) This was in NYC, so it should be higher than average. 6) After adjusting for inflation, that $165 is still more than the out of pocket costs for childbirth today
- eesmith 4y agoYou forgot an adjustment. Julia Roberts was born in 1967, not 1950. 1950 was simply the first numbers I could find - and enough to show that $1 is off by at least a couple of orders of magnitude.
- HWR_14 4y agoThe numbers are pretty irrelevant. You are focusing on an example (not even one I proposed) instead of the point being made. Not that it's my point. But I do recognize that medical costs have skyrocketed.
- eesmith 4y agoBecause I don't think the point you suggested is a likely explanation. Why does the author wish to imply Julia Roberts' parents were so poor they couldn't afford $1? Coretta Scott King paid off the bill as thanks for her parents' kindnesses towards black children in Atlanta. Is $1 - about $30 now - really that big of a thank you in 1967?
- boeingUH60 4y agoIt’ll be better if hospital births are funded under universal healthcare paid for by taxes from everyone, including the mother birthing the child.
- jimlongton 4y agoI think most Europeans would be shocked by the cost of having a baby in the US. See 'A typical American birth costs as much as delivering a (UK) royal baby' [1] [1] https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2018/04/23/a-typical-american-birth-costs-as-much-as-delivering-a-royal-baby https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2018/04/23/a-typica...
- daveslash 4y agoIs that right!? Wow, I'm honestly surprised it's that low. As an American, I totally would have expected it to be at least double that, but most likely more. I haven't had a kid yet, but my wife had outpatient surgery a couple of years ago to remove a cyst. I hung out in the waiting room and we were out of there before lunchtime. Our insurance was billed nearly $100,000. We (thankfully) have good insurance (tied to my employer, of course), and we hit our annual out-of-pocket max with that one operation.
- markx2 4y agoThere are two points here. 1. The actual cost 2. What is charged As a father of two here in the UK and one birth requiring serious surgery I have no clue at all what the cost was. Why? Because our National Health Service did not send me a bill because the charge was zero. Cost? All the medical staff were going to be paid anyway, all equipment was there and powered on, all drugs used were already budgeted for. So the 'cost' was all part of the service.
- kodyo 4y agoNo. Some of us aren’t communists and would rather have less government control over our lives.
- 4y ago
- abc_lisper 4y agoBirths should be free. At least the government should pay for it, least for the first few. After all, the kids are would-be tax payers.
- daveslash 4y agoIt should just be scheduled to be deducted from the child's tax return once they turn 18. Once they're an adult, make them pay for their own birth. /s
- abc_lisper 4y agoWell. There is a reason why married and families with kids get tax breaks. It is government gently prodding the common folk towards having progeny.
- CharlesW 4y agoFinally, I don't have to leave HN to get my Julia Roberts news!