3 ms·
Molten salt reactors could save nuclear power
- Kon5ole 4y agoI don't think that the safety problem with nuclear power lies in the reactors themselves. It lies in the fragility of the human civilisations operating them. Even a flawed design is safe in the hands of responsible, sane, civilised people who get to perform their jobs without disruption from war, natural disasters, famine or whatever else. And if those conditions are removed, no known reactor design is safe. The main problem with nuclear is that nobody can guarantee - let alone pay for - civilised, sane conditions for a sufficiently long time period for the operation as a whole to be considered safe (or profitable, all things considered).
- DennisP 4y ago> And if those conditions are removed, no known reactor design is safe. The claim for MSRs is that they actually are inherently safe. - There's nothing the on-site staff can do to cause a serious accident, even if they want to. The reactor is stable because of the physics of fuel and coolant, not because of active control systems. - There's a strong negative feedback the slows the reaction rate as the fuel heats up. - If somehow you get overheating anyway, or if electric power to the pumps cuts off, passive systems automatically shut down the reactor. One common design is a freeze plug that melts when you stop cooling it, causing the fuel to dump into a tank that passively cools it. Another uses a similar approach to dissolve a strong neutron poison in the fuel, shutting down the reaction. - Since the fuel is liquid, you never need a large amount of fissile material in the fuel. You can add a little at a time. It's also possible to remove some of the fission products as you go. - The most troublesome fission products are chemically bound in the salt, so even is someone destroys your reactor with artillery, you don't get a large radioactive cloud, just hot rocks at the reactor site. - For either thorium or fast uranium MSRs, the waste products are just fission products, not the long-lived transuranics. Encase them in glass and bury them, and they'll be back to the radioactivity of the original ore in 300 years. Since the decline is exponential, most of the radioactivity goes away in the first few decades.
- Schroedingersat 4y ago> The claim for MSRs is that they actually are inherently safe. Safer isn't safe. Hopefully safer is safe enough to make them affordable even given the much worse conditions the materiala need to withstand, but there are other risks involved (how to make the USA or Russia let you have one without installing a puppet government given they can make superweapons grade Pu is one). > There's a strong negative feedback the slows the reaction rate as the fuel heats up. This is only true of two fluid MSRs. Many of the other advantages are only true of one fluid MSRs. > Since the fuel is liquid, you never need a large amount of fissile material in the fuel. You can add a little at a time. You still need a critical mass and you don't have water as a moderator. The quantity of fissile material is equal or higher than in a PWR. There may be significantly less fertile material in the core though (but about as much in the blanket). > It's also possible to remove some of the fission products as you go. > The most troublesome fission products are chemically bound in the salt, so even is someone destroys your reactor with artillery, you don't get a large radioactive cloud, just hot rocks at the reactor site. The purification/extraction step has never been demonstrated and many of the best candidates for salts are water soluble. > For either thorium or fast uranium MSRs, the waste products are just fission products, not the long-lived transuranics. Encase them in glass and bury them, and they'll be back to the radioactivity of the original ore in 300 years. Since the decline is exponential, most of the radioactivity goes away in the first few decades. Yes. This is a huge upside. As is the corollary that there is actually enough fuel.
- foxyv 4y agoOne thing that really changed my mind about nuclear power recently has been the war in Ukraine and Zaporizhzhia. The happy path for nuclear looks as good as it gets. Huge amounts of energy for a tiny bit of fuel. Zero carbon emission from operation. No venting of waste into atmosphere. However, the potential for bad actors, corruption, and negligence to result in a country spanning disaster make me think that maybe paying the extra money for battery based solar and wind power isn't such a bad idea. Very few solar options could render a country un-livable.
- DennisP 4y agoThat's one advantage of molten salt reactors. The troublesome parts of a nuclear breach are fission product gases with medium half-lives: isotopes of strontium, cesium, and iodine. With an MSR, all those are chemically bound in the salt. Instead of radioactive clouds you just have molten salt that cools into hot rocks at the reactor site.
- foxyv 4y agoI did not know that! Pretty cool!
- tuatoru 4y agoEven without considering toxicity, national security would prefer a widely dispersed generating capacity. It's relatively easy to have 10,000 PV and wind farms each contributing to their local electricity network. That's a lot more work for an invader to knock out than say 20 or 30 nuclear plants.
- foxyv 4y agoUnfortunately, I'm not entirely sure this is true. Especially since our grid is so out of date. For instance, one attack in San Jose back in 2014 by one person with a rifle almost took down northern California. There isn't a lot that having distributed power generation will do if your distribution system is burning to the ground. I mean, if one dude with a rifle can take down an entire substation, imagine what a couple cruise missiles in a time of war could do. However, I imagine that rooftop solar and municipal batteries would do a lot to encourage a more modern power distribution system with micro-grids and battery based peaking.