4 ms·
Starvation is more typically driven by organizational, infrastructure, or other tangential issues than by the lack of land. Africa is the best example. It's an
by somenameforme 4y ago
Starvation is more typically driven by organizational, infrastructure, or other tangential issues than by the lack of land. Africa is the best example. It's an absolute utopia in terms of the resources needed for survival, a simply beautiful land in general, and home to the highest rates of starvation in the world. It's those tangential problems that are causing it.
And these tangential issues would emerge in spades after nuclear war. For instance one of the most basic is logistics. Think about how insanely much is just involved in getting an ear of corn from a farm to you. At the most fundamental you're relying on machinery, drivers, oil, gas, refineries, roads infrastructure, food processing infrastructure and a whole lot more - before that ear of corn is anywhere near you. And then there needs to be a means of distribution, and more.
Our entire economy came on the verge of collapse because of COVID, and nuclear war would have an impact with so many orders of magnitude greater than COVID that I think even dreaming of anything even vaguely resembling normalcy afterwards is unrealistic. Violence happens after disasters when the food runs out. In practical disasters that tends to not happen due to rapid aid, delivery, support, and organization. In nuclear war, the food will run out.
- Retric 4y agoThat gets into a wider issue, people aren’t going to want to starve and will in general try quiet hard to avoid that fait. Saying the current social order breaks down isn’t enough to suggest Anarchy will take it’s place. A farmer who wants to collect a harvest without oil will want manpower, and survivors will want to eat. That’s the basis of civilization. Sure suburbs in their current form don’t work without cars and oil. But, people can migrate quite far on a half a tank of gas and their feet.
- somenameforme 4y agoWhat you're saying is completely true. At the same time it's also true that tens if not hundreds of millions have died of starvation within the life of many still alive today. And the same was no less true of those individuals who undoubtedly did everything they could, and sought food absolutely everywhere they possible could. But they were looking for something which simply was not there. Sometimes human will and human ingenuity, no matter how strong or how brilliant, is insufficient to overcome a situation. And within these stories one can also see what happens to societies once normal social function starts to collapse. While this [1] article reads like a propaganda piece, the tales it recounts are neither unique nor exceptional given the situation. Of course it does feel weird to be here kind of arguing that, "Yes we will starve." I think my main point and motivation is that the consequences of what we're discussing simply cannot be overstated. There is a dangerous amount of misinformation that increasingly seems to be headed towards, 'Maybe nuclear wouldn't be 'that' bad.' Perhaps not misinformation. Because it's true that it wouldn't be 'that' bad, it'd be vastly worse. [1] - https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jan/01/china-great-famine-book-tombstone https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jan/01/china-great-fa...
- Retric 4y agoI agree that famine would be a serious risk, but when I look at major famines they seem to largely be imposed by government action. Irish, China, Russia, North Korea etc. The Irish potato famine occurred in part because of the potato blight, but it was a multi year issue that at it’s core related to growing exports (cotton, grain) in favor of local food. Russia’s industrialization created famine because so many farm workers where sent to factories. China had similar root causes, the 18year old worker in that story went home to see their family and many fields where fallow. Steal all the food or workers from a village and people starve. That’s not to say drought etc didn’t play a role, but the American dust bowl isn’t remembered as a famine because there was feedback between the amount of food crops planted and the need for food.