4 ms·
I love how you go from "I'm too lazy to look further than a pop sci summarization" to "the entirety of the work the scientist did was the pop sci summarization"
by scarmig 15y ago
I love how you go from "I'm too lazy to look further than a pop sci summarization" to "the entirety of the work the scientist did was the pop sci summarization" to "flim-flam, fraud, scam."
Climate change "skepticism" in this case amounts to someone who is too lazy to look at scientific reports and just prefers ad hominems.
- HilbertSpace 15y agoReading the whole article gives nothing better. What was written in the whole article has nothing significant. If the study had something significant, then the author of the article didn't report it.
- scarmig 15y agoI'm curious as to where you found the actual article referencing this particular data, as it was just presented a few days ago at the AGU conference, and I'm having trouble finding the (yet unpublished?) conference notes. Alternatively, is this all an oblique way of saying both that the media sucks at reporting science and that scientists (and earth scientists in particular) need to be more approachable and accessible to the public? In which case, I agree with you 100%. Lastly, what is your point, here? Nothing controversial has been reported. Temperatures in Greenland are rising. Marginal ice will melt when temperatures rise. Ice has mass and weight. When that ice goes away, the force its weight has exerted goes away. The Earth decompresses to reach a new energetic equilibrium. And now, their study has confirmed via GPS data that, indeed, things decompress when you stop compressing them. Unless you're arguing that they made up the GPS data out of whole cloth, why the total freak out? The hyper defensive "anything that mentions temperatures changing at all is an AL GORE CONSPIRACY!!1!" really doesn't speak well of the scientific mindset of AGW denialism. The pop sci piece here doesn't even mention AGW, but we've already had 2 (current count) people come in and go into shit-flinging mode to discredit it.
- HilbertSpace 15y agoYou can use GPS and bedrock levels on the southern coast of Greenland to measure temperature if you want to, but I prefer to use a thermometer.
- scarmig 15y agoI believe you're not understanding what the author did. He did not attempt a recent history temperature reconstruction of the Greenland ice sheet via GPS measurements of bedrock rise. Going by the news article, the result was simply that the bedrock rose in response to a compressing force being removed, with zones experiencing heavy ice loss experiencing a commensurate rise in bedrock.
- HilbertSpace 15y agoIt's clear enough what the scientists tried to do with GPS, the southern boundary of Greenland, and the level of the bedrock of the boundary of Greenland. There are amazing images of all of Greenland showing that nearly all of the Greenland bedrock is a big, deep bowl with most of the bowl actually significantly below sea level. The usual claim is that the ice on Greenland has been so heavy that it has pushed down the bedrock. 'Ats a 'lotsa icea'. However, of course, given that ice is much less dense than rock, there are some issues, but let's set those aside. Yes there are claims that the last ice age pushed down the bedrock over most of Canada and that the bedrock is still slowly rebounding. The problem is the article (the one of this thread, not the article, I have not seen, given at the conference). The problem with the article of this thread is that it, the article, maybe JUST the ARTICLE, maybe not the scientific work, is just as I wrote succinctly, "BS". The problems with the article are just at the level of middle school data analysis. The simplest criticism of the article is its use of "as high as" to try to characterize something about all of the bedrock of the boundary of southern Greenland. The main cause of the problems with the article and the main source of the use of "as high as" is the author's approach via the usual of the newsies, drama. He's looking for drama. He's following the usual way, concentrate on extremes. I said this: "Newsies go for drama; for that they like to emphasize the extreme cases, and that is what this author is doing." For "as high as", I wrote: "Moreover, the 'as high as' really means that there could have been just one location with 20 mm with all the other locations less." In most objective terms, the article is BS because it never really said anything at all meaningful about the level of the bedrock on Greenland; it said nothing, nichts, nil, nada. Just read the article and read what I wrote; the article said NOTHING. Look, let me put it to you this way: In the eighth grade there are two classes, A and B. Class A is on one side of the building and class B on the other side. Someone does an analysis of the heights of the students and finds that some of the students in class A are as much as 2 inches taller than they were last year and, since last year, grew by more than 1 inch more than some of the students in class B. What can we conclude from this, that students in class A grew more than those in class B? Heck no. Actually, its quite possible that the same statement would also be true with A and B interchanged. What the article reported about the bedrock level is no better than this total BS about classes A and B. In particular, the author never said anything to let us draw his conclusion that the bedrock in southern Greenland rose unusually quickly in year 2010. Again, again, yet again, once again, the article reported the data on the bedrock levels so badly that it said nothing, nothing at all, nichts, nil, nada, about bedrock level changes. NOTHING. To see this, just read the F'g article or my post. Again, over again, to explain clearly, once again, the problem was that the author went for drama instead of meaningful data analysis. DRAMA. He wanted drama. He wanted to grab people by the heart and the gut. It was emotion, all emotion, in this case totally meaningless emotion, and not reason, not even one gram of reason. Again, the problem is at the level of middle school. What might the article have done? How about: "In year 2005, some high quality GPS receivers were placed at 30 locations scattered around the boundary of Greenland. At each location, the altitude of the receiver at that location was noted in September of year 2005. The following table shows the change in altitude (in mm) for each of the locations in September from the previous September for each of years 2006, 2007, ..., 2010. In the next table we show for each year 2006, 2007, ..., 2010 the change averaged across the 20 locations in the southern 2/3rds of Greenland. What we observe from this data is that, for the stations in the southern 2/3rds of Greenland, on average the increase in bedrock altitude was unusually high from September 2009 to September 2010. A conjecture is that the cause of the unusually high increase is greater ice loss from higher temperatures from September, 2009 to September 2010." But what is in the article is NOTHING like that, not similar, not the same, not nearly the same, etc. Again, maybe there was some good data collection, but what the article wrote about the data is BS. Why the drama? First, the media just wants to keep following their old business model of emphasizing drama. Second, in particular, because a big theme in the media is to ride a wave, mostly generated by and heavily reinforced by, the media, to have a 'story', a continuing 'story', a 'story' really easy to write about, a very dramatic story, about 'global warming' and, now, 'climate change'. They just sling the BS out there, whether there is good science or bad science, they just sling the BS the same. Because they want a dramatic 'story'. And it's all emotionalism with "as high as" and never rationalism. It's BS, and in total it's DANGEROUS. I never mentioned AGW. As I said, I call BS. At C|NET there are claims that the global warming articles and readers posts supporting them are both paid for by organizations that want to convince the public that 'climate change' is a big problem and must be stopped. 'Get it' now?