7 ms·
> all other safety and contention (RF) issues can be dealt with at a another layer of legislation and enforcement. Make sure you write your congressmen about t
by bluGill 4y ago
> all other safety and contention (RF) issues can be dealt with at a another layer of legislation and enforcement.
Make sure you write your congressmen about this. That manufactures feel like they are liable if someone modifies their control software is one of the reasons they oppose right to repair. The EPA is really pushing hard to make it impossible to modify engine ECUs - no diesel as manufactured in the past 15 years has been even capable of "rolling coal", and for around 15 years before then it was difficult to make that happen. However there are still a lot of modified trucks out there spewing visible particulates, all because someone decided to modify the programming.
> Designs should not, by the use of adhesives, welding, non-standard fixings, unnecessary integration, traps, and fuses, prevent the easy disassembly and reuse of modular components.
Define a module in a rigorous way that I can apply. Seriously, parts have been welded together for ages, which turns two pieces of steel into one, were the two separate pieces a module before or not? With the right tools I can pull an IC apart and repair it - the labor is more than just making a new IC (assuming the original drawings still exist), but it is possible. Does that mean an IC is not a module? What about an IC soldered to a board that is then coated in a waterproof coating, screwed into a case - where is the module. This definition of module is critical to any debates on this, and I have no idea how you can objectively create a good definition that covers all cases.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoMy dad has a Chevy Silverado 3500, and he hates it for this reason. Every time the machine has a minor breakdown (which happens once in a while) and the ECU detects that it isn't quite as efficient as it should be, it will immediately and completely mercilessly lock your vehicle to 35 miles per hour. Doesn't matter if you drove from Minnesota to California to pick up a heavy delivery in person - you are coming home at 35 MPH, the entire way, unless you stop at a shop on the way for potentially days to get it fixed. And as for what could trigger that, it could be anything. Once a sensor went bad on the emissions filter. It was just one sensor of many - not the actual emissions system. It tripped the 35 MPH lock, and the only way to fix it was to replace the sensor, which required taking the entire freaking back axle off. It was almost an entire day's job for the diesel mechanic. Imagine if you were a small business owner, multiple states away from home, when this happened. That is crushing and instills complete and utter contempt for emissions standards and those who make them very, very quickly. And then we wonder why some people hate EVs, love "rolling coal", and dispute climate change. If that happened to you, I could see very quickly why you'd join the haters club.
- shagie 4y agoYou generally have the right to repair cars now... though the penalties for violating the clean air act are rather hefty. I'll also point to Illegal Tampering by Diesel Pickup Owners Is Worsening Pollution, E.P.A. Says https://www.nytimes.com/2020/11/25/climate/diesel-trucks-air-pollution.html?unlocked_article_code=yWbwhRrwfMtCaYHJYqJ7vTt7q696tEKv2XQq5XZJAyf03CWFMs-wEdvIU-4YTVg5PgakNf8n086TK_P0uKB9uFNCGBg-NCrKOMpSe6d8AY00tJ4KaGQMNmrzrcX6rpNPXrg7aejU1V8aWRg4J5HGDkIDcjrxx_KWV94UMcXzdRgvpXu9Pc8BBmsKwDBaq8gNX6WNOzFtH4eXrCybGHKQEbgkNJZJTtZUNWDz6K4aprmDuZBf7xrIMVpdR9hN5-kgewR91-RrkUMbhZCsPp7NgpThOes5t-DeyxmchIkGoAHwXQ-3Y6E2r3t8XvwcDPKV3DnUtIxzREopYxW5pMqybYiJeQnk&smid=share-url https://www.nytimes.com/2020/11/25/climate/diesel-trucks-air... This gets to some of the "why" that the right to repair gets into trouble - that people will "repair" it to violate other laws either knowingly or unknowingly. Note that the 1990 clean air act required that car makers provide this information to independent shops. I furthermore, consider the "hate EVs" because of emissions standards for diesel vehicles to be completely irrational.
- gjsman-1000 4y ago> I furthermore, consider the "hate EVs" because of emissions standards for diesel vehicles to be completely irrational. It's easy to waive your hands and call it irrational when it has never happened to you. If you want to experience the potential consequences for yourself, I dare you to drive from NY to LA (~2800 miles), while never exceeding 35 Miles Per Hour. Not once. Never. Enjoy the trip - you'll be almost entirely on backroads the whole way. That is the potential consequence (taken to an extreme) that Diesel truck owners live with, every day, because of emissions. Irrational? I'd say completely rational - it's ridiculous to have that sword hanging over your head, that a sensor will just blow and you're stuck. If it happens to you, you want to rip the arms off any politician in the area. Edit: As for the New York Times article, imagine if you are a business owner, delivering a product a few states away, or even just a few hundred miles. My dad, if it was not illegal, would have immediately went and did exactly as that article described, because that would guarantee that can't happen, which is important because he can't afford for that to happen. This isn't because my dad is heartless towards the environment - he'd pay $25 or $50 for a day-long emissions exemption (donated to, say, CO2 capture) to the 35MPH limit so he could rest assured that he has a quick way out if something goes wrong and he won't be trapped in the middle of nowhere.
- teddyh 4y ago> That manufactures feel like they are liable if someone modifies their control software is one of the reasons they oppose right to repair. That’s what they say is the reason. But I don’t believe that for a second.
- themitigating 4y agoThey do get sued for things like that. It's possible that's one reason and another is to force people to buy new products more often or pay for repair services. When asked however, they claim it's the first reason because it makes them look better than if it was both. This is an extremely common manipulation tactic