3 ms·
I grew up in the tail start the generation who doesn't understand copyright (though I do, having been a rapid FSF supporter). The thing is copyright no longer
by tomjen3 15y ago
I grew up in the tail start the generation who doesn't understand copyright (though I do, having been a rapid FSF supporter).
The thing is copyright no longer makes sense. It used to, but today we have so many movies, tv shows, albums and books that you couldn't possibly read/watch/hear just one tenth of one percent of them in your entire lifetime even if you did nothing else. Copyright was supposed to enable society to be enriched. The constitution doesn't demand that congress make a copyright law, it merely enables it to do so. The moment the public no longer believes that copyright is likely to benefit it, it can simply stop offering it.
So that nobody makes the argument that you take away their property or that the owners somehow has a moral right to it. Nobody is taking their property away from them. What we take away is the (temporary) monopoly they were granted.
And we could properly still put limitations on the commercial use of copyrighted works -- if that had been used as an example, a lot more hands would have gone up among the students.
- muuh-gnu 15y ago> The thing is copyright no longer makes sense. From a democratic point of view, it doesnt even _matter_ whether it makes sense or not. The only thing that matters is whether we, as a society, collectively _want_ private, non-commercial copying (i.e. filesharing) to be illegal or not. Knowing that "we" probably would make non-commercial copying legal, "they" simply do not let us vote on it. Copyright is basically locked out of any democratic decision process, worldwide. Basically all existing political parties shield copyright away from democratic influence like a sanctum. Only in the recent 2-3 years, in a number of european countries, people have realized that voting on this issue in the current system will basically forever be impossible and have formed pirate parties focused solely on getting rid of the filesharing prohibition.
- Jugglernaut 15y agoSeeing as it is legal to share files non-commercially in Switzerland I'd say that worldwide is a stretch. It's also getting there in other countries. The momentum is behind the sharing, not behind the institutions upholding the barricades.
- cabalamat 15y ago> people have realized that voting on this issue in the current system will basically forever be impossible and have formed pirate parties focused solely on getting rid of the filesharing prohibition. "Solely" would be an exaggeration. The filesharing issue is merely one issue -- albeit a very prominent one -- where governments have acted in the interests of big business not the electorate. Pirates also care about: - abuse of idea/infomation monopolies such as patents on drugs and software - other areas where governments are infringing people's digital rights, e.g. spying on people's communications using the excuse of terrorism and pedophilia - Pirates appreciate that a root cause is that governments do what big business wants, therefore want to get money out of politics and strengthen democracy