2 ms·
> because once either an endpoint is compromised, or a tap is within range, you're still giving your adversaries everything they could desire This is hogwash
by godelski 4y ago
> because once either an endpoint is compromised, or a tap is within range, you're still giving your adversaries everything they could desire
This is hogwash because it is the wrong threat model. The encryption in this kind of communication is nearly pointless. If you're trying to organize a protest where you have to be messaging 100+ people then there's no way you can vet everyone. There's going to be a mole. In fact, we saw this with some of the militias at Jan 6th. Despite using Signal their texts got turned over. You just have to turn one person to compromise the system.
Would I rather have the communications encrypted? Hell yeah. I'm that annoying friend that makes everyone use Signal. But it is absurd to think that wire tapped mass communication is worse than no mass communication. Revolutions and protests are won my shear mass. They often show their faces and are demonstrating in a public space (where there are often plenty of cameras: CCT, Police, and the protestors themselves!), so there's no concern about privacy already. Many get arrested, you can't arrest a large group. Arresting everyone would be nearly impossible.
Furthermore, people still use covert speech. People are doing it in Iran right now. People are doing it on highly censored platforms like WeChat. Hell, there's covert speech on Twitter. There's definitely an advantage to using phones rather than going down to the public square and organizing that way. If you think everything is/was organized in back rooms and in complete secrecy, you're gravely misinformed at how these things work in reality.
You have the wrong threat model.