3 ms·
Same reason Homa isn't used: software isn't written for it. With SCTP there's also a significant performance impact because many drivers for the protocol are f
by jeroenhd 4y ago
Same reason Homa isn't used: software isn't written for it.
With SCTP there's also a significant performance impact because many drivers for the protocol are far from optimised, because very few applications use it, because of its performance implications, because very few programs use it, etc. etc.
There's also firewall issues: big firewall vendors just don't play nice with anything that's not a variant of HTTP(S). You still need some kind of firewall in a datacenter and it'd be foolish to set up two different ones for internal and external networking. Protocol ossification is real and if you use any external piece of firewall kit, you're sure to run into problems if you try to use "novel" protocols like SCTP. Hell, you'll be lucky to get good IPv6 support.
You can write your own access control if you want but that's often perceived as more expensive than buying a box, especially if the box companies find their way into a meeting with management.
Lastly, there's education. A shocking amount of developers have no idea about how networking works. They probably know there are protocols like UDP and TCP but their role and inner workings are often glazed over in my experience. Practical networking courses seem to treat the network as some kind of black box where bytes and IP addresses go in and response data comes out. If developers do know their basic networking, that information is often out of date; people don't seem to realise how often TCP gets tweaked to behave slightly differently to improve performance. Ask your average dev something about IPv6 and I doubt they'll know much more than "it's IPv4 with more bits" because networking simply doesn't come up that often.
In the end, it comes down to tradeoffs, experience, and decisions. Feel free to write SCTP code for your servers products where you can, the protocol definitely solves many issues people run into in TCP, but you'll probably have to defend your use of something unfamiliar to many developers every step along the way. The same is true for protocols like QUIC (outside the HTTP(S) environment) which tries to solve a whole lot of layer 3 to layer 5 problems in a single protocol that's designed to play nicely with shitty middleware boxes by its basis in UDP.