12 ms·
I love Penelope Trunk and her political incorrectness. Her advice may always be controversial, but she's never afraid to speak her mind. And she's right too abo
by AznHisoka 15y ago
I love Penelope Trunk and her political incorrectness. Her advice may always be controversial, but she's never afraid to speak her mind. And she's right too about women. Their natural imperative is to raise children and nurture them - not to do startups. Most also want the social companionship from friends/family as they raise children (which is missing today as most people don't live near extended family), but they don't need to go the extreme of climbing the corporate ladder, or starting a venture.
If anyone wants career advice that makes sense from a human perspective, her blog is a must-read. You just can't dish out career advice without considering human happiness and human nature as a whole.
- CJefferson 15y agoIf women's natural imperative is to raise children and nurture them, why is Penelope Trunk running a start-up? I really thought that this kind of overly-simplistic "men do X, women do Y" was in the past now, but of course such things never die. There was a time where it was generally believed women should stay at home and worry about the children rather than go to school, or vote. I am sure we will look back on this kind of advice in the same way. I hope you see the irony in thinking that there is nothing stopping women from running startups, but they shouldn't want to, as women want to stay at home and look after the children.
- AznHisoka 15y agoOh for crying out loud... Everyone on the internet now has to include a disclaimer every time they write a general statement that doesn't apply to 100% of people, but is pretty much true . The majority of women don't do startups - that's empirical evidence right there. There's nothing stopping them of course, and I'm not saying they shouldn't do startups. I'm just observing why I think most don't.
- CJefferson 15y agoNo, there is no need for a disclaimer. This article make very clear that the opinion of Penelope is that the only reason women aren't running more startups is their genetics tells them to settle down, have children, and only run little lifestyle business between having children. While there certainly is help for women running startups, there is also still sexism at many levels. There are lots of reasons why women still stay at home and look after the children other than genetics. One of the most obvious ones to me (from personal experience) is that men are looked down on if they are the primary carer for their children.
- rmc 15y agoThere's nothing stopping them of course Institutial misogyny?
- yummyfajitas 15y agoIf women's natural imperative is to raise children and nurture them, why is Penelope Trunk running a start-up? Unless something changed since October, she is living on a farm raising her kids. http://venturebeat.com/2011/10/24/how-to-know-when-to-leave-your-startup/ http://venturebeat.com/2011/10/24/how-to-know-when-to-leave-...
- munaf 15y agoHer point was that women have a choice, and by nature, women have different options than men. She did not say that all women should just sit at home having kids.
- dextorious 15y ago"""If women's natural imperative is to raise children and nurture them, why is Penelope Trunk running a start-up?""" 1) She doesn't, as a comment below states. 2) I fail to see how your question makes any sense. Tendency/Preference etc is not Absolute Law. For example, a human's natural instinct is survival, yet there are still people willing to sacrifice their lives for others in danger, etc. (I always hate it when someone takes some statistical observation and thinks it's very smart to point out that there are exceptions --or even worse, uses them to "prove" the statistical observation doesn't hold. Happens all the time in pedantic-land). """I really thought that this kind of overly-simplistic "men do X, women do Y" was in the past now, but of course such things never die.""" Overly simplistic? Just because there are counter-examples, and complex cases, doesn't mean that the generalization is overly simplistic. To make sense of the world you have to generalize, that is not to give equal importance to a multitude of fringe cases. """I hope you see the irony in thinking that there is nothing stopping women from running startups, but they shouldn't want to, as women want to stay at home and look after the children.""" Nobody said "shouldn't", she said "wouldn't". And, statistically speaking, most don't. Do you see equally as many women founders? Or do you think you can attribute that to some mysterious general sexist attitude that prevents them?
- JoachimSchipper 15y ago> [Women's] natural imperative is to raise children and nurture them This is the 21st century. Are we really still talking about "natural imperatives"? If nothing else, note that women are having fewer and fewer children, later and later - clearly, they are feeling this "natural imperative" less and less. Traditional gender roles are unfair to women wanting to have a career, unfair to men who want to stay home with the kids, and far more rigid than needed. Having some "standard patterns" makes sense, but there should be more than one, and the freedom to deviate from those.
- burgerbrain 15y ago"Are we really still talking about "natural imperatives"?" I am puzzled by this sort of comment. There are certainly things that I do as a male that I consider to be built in behavior. I do not see any reason to think that women would not have similar.
- wpietri 15y agoWhat's natural isn't necessarily right; what's right isn't necessarily natural. Respectively those are the naturalistic fallacy and the moralistic fallacy. The reason people object to the naturalistic fallacy in arguments on this topic is that it is typically used to argue for the status quo by people who benefit from the status quo. If you would like to see an example of it in action, read the Texas Declaration of Causes of Secession and the Cornerstone speech. There you can see rich white people explaining how black people are natural slaves, unfit to any higher role in society. Which was certainly a convenient argument for them to make.
- burgerbrain 15y agoI have no interest in ethics, certainly not universal ethics. All I'm saying is that "everybody is the same" type positions ignore reality.
- wpietri 15y ago
- rmc 15y agoTheir natural imperative is to raise children and nurture them - not to do startups. [citation needed] There is no evidence that women naturally want to only raise children. And the implication that a woman who doesn't want spend all their life at home is a 'unnatural' woman, and there is something wrong with her, is a terribly, false, harmful meme to spread. I find this comment offensive, since it spreads a meme that's completly against the Hacker ethic, which values meritocracy above pety ideas like gender, race etc. I'm flagging this comment.
- hackinthebochs 15y agoThis is why we can't discuss sensitive subjects like this. People always take an innocent comment, which seems to be borne out by observational evidence at the very least, and then twist it to mean something entirely different. >There is no evidence that women naturally want to only raise children. Do you see what you did there? You (perhaps unconsciously) inserted "only" in the parent's statement, completely changing its meaning. Then you attack your modified statement as being sexist. Furthermore, nothing in OPs statement implied there was something wrong with a woman who chose differently. Discussions on subjects like these would be much more productive if we could just take statements at face value without assuming all kinds of implied sexism.
- rmc 15y agoI would not call what you said an "innocent comment". It's spreading a meme and idea that has frequently been used to keep half the population as second class citizens. You have part of a point about my "only" comment. However there is no evidence that women (and not men) want to naturally raise children. There is no evidence that there is anything "unnatural" about a woman (or man) who doesn't want children.
- hackinthebochs 15y agoI don't think her argument is meant to be taken exclusively for women. It's just that women are singled out as needing to be told to do a startup. The assumption is that there's no way a woman would freely choose to downshift her career for children, so it must be because of hidden sexism. Her argument was meant to specifically address this misconception. It doesn't mean the same thing doesn't apply to men, its just that this particular misconception applies to woman so that's where she's focusing her argument. Natural vs unnatural is a complete red-herring. I agree that we all should stop using that word in discussions like this. It carries too many connotations and it implies beliefs that I don't think anyone has (that someone that deviates from "natural" behavior is wrong).
- neilk 15y agoThis might have been just a poor choice of words, but beware the naturalistic fallacy. Trunk believes that more women are choosing not to do startups. That's not exactly the same thing as saying it's their "natural imperative". Because then those who choose otherwise are being "unnatural". Also, the "natural imperative" thing implies that our current state of affairs is somehow the only possibility. Maybe the way investment works is currently broken somehow.
- drumdance 15y agoYes, but she addresses this by pointing out that women now outperform men in many measures, including college, law school, med school and even income in their twenties. Is it possible that many women don't choose startups for the same reason many men don't choose nursing? It's demeaning to suggest that women who choose not to do startups lack free will.
- Gormo 15y agoDo you believe that the conception of "natural imperative" she's using refers to a deterministic binary, and not a normal distribution with a somewhat shifted mean in relation to that of men? Treating individuals as mere instances of categories is a bit absurd, isn't it?
- zzzeek 15y ago"natural imperatives" also say that people are attracted to the opposite sex. So what do we do with all those pesky gays? Probably encourage them to go to church more. Certainly, any kind of "if you think you might be gay , that's OK, be gay !" is just encouragement against "natural imperatives" - we should "Stop" doing that !
- hackinthebochs 15y agoDownvoted for projecting opinions on to parent that are completely unwarranted. Pointing out what seem to be tendencies that a majority hold does not imply there is anything "wrong" with those who deviate from the norm, nor does it imply any attempt at "fixing" the deviation.
- zzzeek 15y agoas it turns out, I disagree. > You just can't dish out career advice without considering human happiness and human nature as a whole. This is an article that doesn't just say, "keep in mind not all women want to do a startup". It says, "stop encouraging women to do startups!" Parent post then links this advice to the fact that "human nature must be considered when we give advice". So it links the inaccurate assumption that "human nature" implies "all women want to have babies", which is about analogous to the assertion that all people are attracted to the opposite sex, to an endorsement of the article's premise - that nobody should ever be encouraged otherwise. The downmod you gave me is actually because of my tone. Feel free in that regard. I've observed the Hacker News community to have an incredibly low tolerance for sarcasm as an argumentative device.
- hackinthebochs 15y ago>It says, "stop encouraging women to do startups!" The title is "stop telling women to do startups". I think the distinction is critical. (Perhaps this is her own strawman, but I think its important to get correct where she's coming from). Telling someone what to do is saying you know better than them, that somehow they're choice is sub-par and they need to be corrected. That's what she is ranting against. The implied assertion that women who choose to downshift their career must be doing so because of hidden sexism, not because they simply choose to.
- wpietri 15y agoTheir natural imperative is to raise children and nurture them - not to do startups. Hello, naturalistic fallacy! How surprising that you came to visit when a bunch of dudes are talking about what they think women should do!