8 ms·
Why can't we build distributed networks? I more mean like Google, Apple, WhatsApp, Signal, Telegram, etc building methods to communicate through WiFi/Bluetooth
by godelski 4y ago
Why can't we build distributed networks? I more mean like Google, Apple, WhatsApp, Signal, Telegram, etc building methods to communicate through WiFi/Bluetooth and not be completely reliant upon cellular. I don't mean your random 3rd party app that is useless because no one uses it.
It helps the people that frequently text in the same room. It helps during natural disasters (including power outages). It helps prevent oppressive governments from shutting down communication. I see these companies talk a lot about promoting democracy, so I want to see them make an open protocol that is installed on all phones that allow this. They have the network effect that's required to do this.
Hell, I think even if Apple or Google just did this others would follow. It cleanly fits into the new privacy + safety narratives both are selling.
- azov 4y agoThere is/was FireChat [1], which does exactly that. AFAIK it gained popularity during Hong Kong protests. Looks like it's now discontinued, not sure if there's a successor app. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FireChat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FireChat
- godelski 4y agoI'm completely aware that there are apps that do these. The problem is the network effect. This app is all fine and dandy when you think ahead of time, but humans aren't really good at that (I have a laundry list of examples of us not doing this). So what I'm asking for is companies with a large network effect to leverage that, and their huge capital, to improve their existing products to be resistant to things like power outages and government shutdowns. It should be default, not require people to be proactive.
- Syonyk 4y ago> Why can't we build distributed networks? We can... but I'll argue, very hard, that we shouldn't. Because it's the wrong technology to solve the problem, being based on the very things that are well targeted, understood, and frequently compromised. If the problem is "Cell phones are compromised through and through," which I'll argue they are, and Apple's addition of Lockdown to work through the fact that even their best sandboxing efforts have been bypassed argues for as well, then "doing things with cell phones" is a horrible idea, because once either an endpoint is compromised, or a tap is within range, you're still giving your adversaries everything they could desire. Both of those are basically certain in a protest.
- anta40 4y agoHmm... if "doing things with cell phones" is horrible idea, then what's possibley the good idea?
- Syonyk 4y agoDoing things in person, with offline techniques. If your location (which implies who you're with) and at least the metadata of your communications (who you communicate with, when, how frequently, how long of messages, etc) are sensitive, I don't believe there's any way to use a cell phone safely for those tasks. And having grown up before cell phones, I assure you, there are ways to coordinate things offline. We just need to bring them back.
- plugin-baby 4y ago> having grown up before cell phones, I assure you, there are ways to coordinate things offline Landlines?
- paganel 4y agoGood old secret associations and secret meetings. The Italians did it quite well 200 years ago [1]: > Cardinals Ercole Consalvi and Bartolomeo Pacca issued an edict forbidding all secret societies, to become members of these secret associations, to attend their meetings, or to furnish a meeting-place for such, under severe penalties It also f.cks with the head with those in power, having secret associations and secret meetings, that is. Having it all out in the open gives them (the authorities) the illusion of control, and, I'd argue, actual control over any significant protest movement. Moving it in the "shadows" is a good tactic because it helps make things blurry and it starts "attaching" doubts to said authorities' monopoly of violence. The authorities will ask themselves: "whom should I punish? where are the revolutionaries? is everyone a revolutionary?", and, as such, that will decrease their legitimacy and their hold on actual power. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbonari#Origins https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbonari#Origins
- _Algernon_ 4y agoGoogle, Apple, etc. do not have economic incentives to build it. They benefit from having everything going through their walled gardens.
- godelski 4y agoThey have an economic incentive just the same way they have the economic incentive to build better cellular infrastructure. Something they already invest in.
- _Algernon_ 4y agoInvestment in cellular infrastructure increases reach which increases the number of customers they can reach which increases profit. Investment in distributed networks, reduces their own access to data about their customers because it would no longer go through their servers, which reduces income, at least for all of the companies that have an advertising business.
- godelski 4y ago> Investment in cellular infrastructure increases reach which increases the number of customers they can reach which increases profit. I could make this exact same argument about distributed networks. Along with the added selling point of safety, privacy, and security. Chat and share pictures with your friends while camping. Trying to contact your neighbors during a power outage?! There's a lot of angles to sell this. > Investment in distributed networks, reduces their own access to data about their customers because it would no longer go through their servers I have some serious doubts. If Google can still collect data you've collected while on airplane mode by just sending it once you reconnect to the network then they can do the same with this. If anything, I think it would increase the amount of data they can gather because it extends the capabilities of how one is able to communicate.
- redtexture 4y agoUsing Metadata to find Paul Revere. -- Keiren Healy -- June 9, 2013. https://kieranhealy.org/blog/archives/2013/06/09/using-metadata-to-find-paul-revere/ https://kieranhealy.org/blog/archives/2013/06/09/using-metad...