3 ms·
Gandhi reminded us that's a recipe for apocalypse. > Vance was being asked to declare "In the interest of peace, all this slavery was nobody's fault," and that
by pessimizer 4y ago
Gandhi reminded us that's a recipe for apocalypse.
> Vance was being asked to declare "In the interest of peace, all this slavery was nobody's fault," and that's a non-starter.
If your choice is to free the slaves, or punish the slaver, which do you pick? If you choose to punish the slaver over freeing the slaves, are you putting your own ego above the suffering of people who you clearly don't particularly value?
edit: did anyone at the Federation know any slaves? Did they ask them if they would rather be free than hold out as slaves for a trial in an indeterminate future? If the Federation managed to capture her and free the slaves, would the trial be nutritious for the slaves? Would it clothe or house them? Would it deter anyone else from becoming a warlord?
- shadowgovt 4y ago> If your choice is to free the slaves, or punish the slaver, which do you pick? False dichotomy. As an American, it sometimes rubs the wrong way when that's presented as either-or because the US chose not to punish many of the slavers and we continue to live with the consequences of that decision: they regained power and built the Jim Crow South. Justice is required for lasting peace. It perhaps need not be fatal, but it must be real.