17 ms·
Hey, this is fantastic! I've been looking for one-bit-deep screenshots of SunView, OpenWindows, or Open Look for a while — I don't remember if I ever used it o
by kragen 4y ago
Hey, this is fantastic! I've been looking for one-bit-deep screenshots of SunView, OpenWindows, or Open Look for a while — I don't remember if I ever used it on a one-bit display, but a lot of the graphic design in Open Look seems like it's intended to work well on a one-bit display. Unfortunately, all the SunView/OpenWindows/OpenLook screenshots I could find were 256-color screenshots.
This version of SunView looks pretty different from the Open Look I used to use. There are no pushpins on menus, no rounded ends on menu items, no arrow-buttons on the scrollbar slider, and scrollbars on the left (usually) instead of the right. Action buttons are beveled instead of having rounded ends. Default action buttons are indicated with a thick border instead of a double border. Instead of popups being connected to their parent window with a tower converging on a vanishing point, they're connected with a curvy arrow (though with a little vanishing-point action). Instead of picture-frame corners to resize windows with, you have a mega thick double line border around the entire window. Cascading menu items are indicated with a double-line right arrow instead of a right-pointing triangle.
There are clearly some elements in common. The file browser has the same ugly folder tree view with awkwardly wrapped filenames. The cursor in text fields (including "cmdtool", a name shared with Open Look) is a caret shaped like a diamond or triangle, instead of a vertical line, a flashing block, or an underline. The "file properties" dialog in fileview still has checkboxes for permission bits. And the pushpin also shows up in that dialog despite its unfortunate absence from menus.
The OpenWindows section following seems to have one-bit-deep versions of most of the Open Look stuff I'm familiar with, though! You have the picture-frame corners, buttons on the scrollbar slider (which is on the right), downward-pointing triangles for the titlebar button and menu buttons, a non-shitty mouse pointer graphic, circular ends on menu entry highlights and action buttons, right-pointing triangles for submenus, pushpins on menus (now with lines inside the silhouette), underlined text fields, checkboxes with a little more panache, dropshadows on buttons by way of thickening the border on the bottom and right, rectangular radio buttons (which highlight the selected option with a thicker border), the same slider and gauge widget from the OLIT sampler demo, double-lined borders for default buttons and the goofy perspective tower thing for popup dialogues.
All of this looks perfectly comprehensible despite the one-bit-deep display, and not only is it less ugly than SunView and GEOS, it's even less ugly than Motif or Windows 3.1, on par with the one-bit-deep UIs on the Macintosh and the Palm Pilot.
The highlighting of the hyperlinks in the Help Viewer leaves something to be desired.
Does anyone know how these graphical idioms changed so radically from this version of SunView to OpenWindows?
- classichasclass 4y ago(author) Are you sure those weren't converted XView clients you were using? Those used the SunView API but OPEN LOOK widgets.
- kragen 4y agoThey probably were! Not having written any SunView or Open Look code myself, I never realized that was what XView was for.
- mzs 4y agoI know about xbd but not the (earlier) mgr port of boulder dash. Got a link?
- classichasclass 4y ago(author) You can get the source/binaries from the gopher server; they're part of the MGR source tree. gopher://gopher.floodgap.com:70/1/archive/sunos-4-solbourne-os-mp
- Tsiklon 4y agoYou appear to have a lot of experience with this equipment and interfaces like this, I have to say what has been lost, in terms of usability between this and the more usable versions of Mac OS? (The modern versions of Mac OS and the unix desktops of Gnome and KDE leave much to be desired)
- kragen 4y agoI appreciate the flattery, but I'm not really an HCI expert. To my taste, GNOME, KDE, and modern versions of MacOS are all significantly easier to use than X-Windows in the 01990s, most of the time, as well as capable of doing a wider range of things. But, because their implementation is much more complex, they are often more difficult to debug when things go wrong, even though the available debugging tools are also better.
- jfb 4y ago