3 ms·
>it identifies that the 50mm lens is not the same with modern cameras (which have smaller sensors than 35mm film cameras), and recommends a 35mm lens for these
by coldtea 4y ago
>it identifies that the 50mm lens is not the same with modern cameras (which have smaller sensors than 35mm film cameras), and recommends a 35mm lens for these cameras
That's a different thing, which is about the "crop factor".
Modern APS-C digital cameras have smaller sesnors, with a 1.5 crop factor and will need a 35mm lens to get 50mm angle of view. This is not needed for modern full-frame digital cameras, which can use a 50mm to get 50mm angle of view just like old film cameras.
The article in that section just tells people to get a 35mm for modern (APS-C crop factor) cameras, because that's what gives the 50mm effective angle of view on those.
This issue is orthogonal to the parent's suggestion for 40mm.
To put it in different terms, the article in that section is concerned with "what lens you need on a modern crop factor camera to get 50mm effective angle of view - hence the suggestion for a 35mm physical lens).
Whereas the parent is concened with the actual effective angle of view you get, and suggests 40mm effective angle of view is better than 40mm effective angle of view.
To get such 40mm effective a.o.v, you need a 40mm lens on a film camera or a full-frame digital, and a 27mm lens on a APS-C digital (the kind of cameras the article has in mind when it says that "modern cameras have smaller lensors).
- SECProto 4y agoI think the difference between your comment and mine is I assumed the parent commenter is complaining about 50mm FOV being too tight on a APS-C sensor, and you've assumed they're complaining that 50mm is too tight on a full frame sensor. Either could be right. But I think we've all gotten a little lost in the weeds, as the original article was recommending it not specifically because of focal length, but also because of lens speed compared to the 18-80mm zoom lenses now common on DSLRs.
- Bimos 4y agoI think it is usually assumed that people talk about 35mm equivalent focal length[0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/35_mm_equivalent_focal_length https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/35_mm_equivalent_focal_length
- ISL 4y agoMy comment was based on full-frame equivalence :). 50mm on an APS-C is short-telephoto; frequently pleasing for portraits, but less-useful as a single prime. (I still recommend 50mm f/1.8s as a second or third lens for people using APS-C, but not as an only-lens.)
- SECProto 4y agoThank you for the clarification! I've been happy with my 35mm lens (50mm equivalent) largely because it cost about $200.
- girvo 4y agoEverything you've said is spot on (and I prefer 40mm equiv. as my run-around lens), but 35mm gives you a 52.5mm equivalent. The Fuji X-Mount 33mm is exactly 50mm and subjectively feels very similar to my film 50mm glass of various mounts in terms of field of view. But it's also incredibly expensive. Fantastic glass though, I've rented it a couple times for some shoots