8 ms·
Marten: a Crystal web framework
- dom96 4y agoIt's quite amazing how many web frameworks are built for Crystal (in comparison to other languages of the same size, for example Nim)
- dcchambers 4y agoI wonder if it's because Crystal targets so many Ruby developers... Folks are trying to make the next Ruby on Rails and re-create that lightning in a bottle. Hence all the competition in the space.
- sergiotapia 4y agoNim has this problem where devs like to stitch together libs instead of using an all-in-one solution. It's a tough nut to crack, if anyone does build a "Phoenix for Nim" we should see significant uptick in usage.
- wheels 4y agoI'd love to hear stories about actual Crystal use. Of all the languages I've seen emerge in recent years, it was the one I was most conceptually fond of. It's basically (progressively-) statically typed Ruby, but fast (compiled). I enjoy writing Ruby, but I hate maintaining it.
- nerdponx 4y agoI enjoyed poking around at Crystal, but its library ecosystem seems heavily oriented towards web development (understandably, because its creators are a web dev consultancy), and I don't do much web development for my hobby programming. Also, I found that its static analysis tooling (eg LSP server) was really slow. Compiling small programs was also rather slow, and it generated large binaries. I also had some difficulty understanding the documentation related to importing and including modules and classes; it seemed written from a perspective assuming that the reader already knows Ruby, which I do not. At the time, I was also curious about Common Lisp and Nim, so I spent a bunch of time learning the former, and have lately been writing small personal scripts/tools using the latter. My experience using Python for backend web development has been mixed. If I had to do work like that professionally in the future, I would be happy to do it in a language like Crystal. It seems a lot more comfortable to me than Go, less intimidating than a JVM language (Kotlin?), and less "weird" than Common Lisp or a functional language like OCaml. It doesn't seem like a bad choice for a company willing to invest in engineers while they learn the language, and maybe invest in writing some of their own libraries while the ecosystem is still young. I felt like I was able to get productive fairly quickly. I think an interesting project would be to write a fairly simple web server (maybe some basic REST CRUD thing using idiomatic code) in several languages and frameworks, and compare their performance, ease of getting started, and complexity of the code. I had started working on this myself at one point, and it seems like it could be worthwhile to pick up again, especially now that all of the language ecosystems I had in mind have matured a little bit.
- mhenders 4y agoRegarding different languages and frameworks, I found this informative: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FQPlEnKav48 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FQPlEnKav48
- nerdponx 4y agoThis is great. It's a shame that so much good programming content is locked away in videos on proprietary platforms.
- socialdemocrat 4y agoI used to be a huge Ruby fan but I got to say Julia had proven to be a much nicer language than Python or Ruby ever was. It gives stronger typing so it feels a bit more like a statically typed language in terms of safeguarding you, but without getting in the way. Lot of the power of LISP without the odd syntax. Problem is the community is not web focused so you may not find enough choice in web libraries to your taste.
- nerdponx 4y agoI am a data scientist, so I've always been interested in Julia and have had fun messing around with it, even if I can never find an excuse to use it at work. Have you been using Julia for a "general purpose" programming? It seemed very domain specific to me, more like an upgrade from R and Matlab then something you would write a web server with.
- hipster_robot 4y ago> static analysis tooling (eg LSP server) was really slow. Compiling small programs was also rather slow, and it generated large binaries. Compile times have taken a nose dive in the last couple versions, but I’m not sure about the binary size. I’ve never looked honestly.
- hamandcheese 4y ago> I enjoy writing Ruby, but I hate maintaining it. Sorbet helps immensely in this regard (though it does perhaps make writing ruby a bit less joyful). The Sorbet language server works great (at least with VSCode) - I have pretty reliable go-to-definition and intellisense. I would imagine that if crystal had a decent language server the experience would be even better than Ruby+Sorbet.
- wheels 4y agoRefactoring tools are nice (I guess; I've honestly only used them in Java; I'm mostly an Emacs person), but my main gripes with Ruby maintenance are harder to fix with type annotations: - In duck-typed languages you have to write a lot of tests to do verify things that the compiler does for you in statically typed languages. That neuters much of the benefit of the concision of such languages. Crystal shoots for the best of both worlds. (Static type checking, but usually without explicit signatures.) My main refactoring tool in statically typed languages is the compiler: if I break something, it'll tell me. - Monkey-patching, open classes, etc. I do it too. Pretty much every Ruby-ist does. But it makes it damn near impossible to track down bugs sometimes, because even finding out what file the relevant code is in isn't trivial. Again, Crystal seems to mostly side-step that pitfall. - Speed. I don't even attempt to write fast code in Ruby (though I have written a few C++ extensions for Ruby in a pinch). But if I could get near-to systems-language level performance out of something that was almost Ruby, that'd be pretty amazeballs.
- pmontra 4y ago> In duck-typed languages you have to write a lot of tests to do verify things that the compiler does for you in statically typed languages Would you give some examples? I think I'm testing only functionality but maybe I'm not realizing that I'm testing the types of arguments.
- wheels 4y agoSure. Ruby: def foo(a) raise ArgumentError unless [ :bar, :baz, :quux ].include?(a) return 1 end def test_foo assert_raise(ArgumentError) { foo(1) } assert_raise(ArgumentError) { foo(:moo) } assert_instance_of(foo(:bar), Integer) end In C++ I'd write: enum class Value { Bar, Baz, Quux }; int foo(Value a) { return 1; } In a strongly typed language you don't need to do any of the input validation. I'm not sure that I'd do that level of granularity of tests in an application, but I spend a lot of times writing libraries, where it's pretty important. You also have to call all code paths with your tests in Ruby because otherwise you won't hit errors. Just basic, "this thing runs, the methods it calls exist, it returns a value, and it's of this type" is all guaranteed in a strongly typed language and doesn't need to be explicitly tested.
- freediver 4y agoThe backend for Kagi Search is powered by Crystal.
- noaheverett 4y agoWe use it in production for our products at https://ark.fm https://ark.fm and are actively working to move all of our Rails apps over to Crystal which ironically this framework looks great and may be a good choice for us. (Thank you to the author!) Our email service runs an image proxy (to hide your IP from email trackers) with probably about 30-50 lines of code in Crystal that's been in production for multiple years and it just works. Current project (in the cloud hosting space) that will heavily use Crystal for backend management and WASM which was recently introduced into Crystal and is a game changer for our use-case. Also wrote a command-line tool with it and it feels like I'm cheating at how easy it is to do so. Coming from the Ruby/Rails world where you have to cap deploy/bundle etc to push to a production server and hoping nothing breaks on dependancies makes Crystal's single binary deploy a breath of fresh air...not to mention the performance. We run our own hardware so being able to (eventually once we've moved over fully to Crystal) run the same workloads on LESS hardware with electric prices spiking is financially attractive. As you can tell I'm a fan boy. I'm betting heavily on Crystal and going all in with our stack. Did I mention it is fast?
- shafyy 4y agoKagi (the search engine) is built on Crystal.
- fdr 4y agoThe Crunchy Bridge CLI is written in crystal: https://github.com/CrunchyData/bridge-cli/ https://github.com/CrunchyData/bridge-cli/. The program that monitors databases is likewise a crystal program. There are a few other crystal programs rolling around. My biggest grievance with Crystal is the lack of incremental compilation. I understand why it's difficult to achieve given the language model, and some of the conveniences of that model. I've been watching the Crystal Interpreter with interest, it would be pretty cool if it could speed up my `M-x crystal-spec-line` interactions, along with all the other usual benefits of an interpreter. On the other hand, there's a lot to like about Crystal: it has a convenient yet powerful type system, good error messages, good support for invoking C subroutines in libraries, and generates efficient object code in a straightforward manner.
- compumike 4y agoMy side project https://totalrealreturns.com/ https://totalrealreturns.com/ is now about 5k lines of Crystal. There are some rough edges: in particular I think it could use a better templating solution (a port of HAML would be ideal!), and there are some failure modes with the Redis connection pool that have required workarounds. This includes unit tests: the built-in spec framework is great and much like rspec. https://crystal-lang.org/reference/1.6/guides/testing.html https://crystal-lang.org/reference/1.6/guides/testing.html I'm now starting to use Crystal for internal backend infrastructure and microservices. For anyone who wants to kick the tires on Crystal, I built a crystal-docker-quickstart project template: https://github.com/compumike/crystal-docker-quickstart https://github.com/compumike/crystal-docker-quickstart works without having to install anything locally. (Assuming you have docker.) You can have your own, home-built "Hello world" static binary in under a minute: git clone https://github.com/compumike/crystal-docker-quickstart.git my_app && cd my_app && ./d_dev # in the shell that appears: make && out/my_app Then just edit src/main.cr and you're off and running :)
- paulgb 4y agoThat is one fast-loading page, especially for (what looks to be) dynamic data! Are you doing anything special or just using a good CDN?
- compumike 4y agoThanks :) No CDN actually -- it's just a side project served straight from a single VPS at the moment. You're probably just seeing the speed of response caching (which I've written in Crystal too, using Redis and local disk as storage backends). If you request a new ticker symbol that isn't already cached, or specify custom date ranges, it will recompute or even have to fetch data from upstream data provider, and those requests will take a bit longer. Also, the whole site is currently served up as a single HTTP request, except for a few external JS and CSS files (Bootstrap, uPlot) which are served from public CDNs.
- victor106 4y agoNice!!! What are some advantages of Crystal over other languages like Go, Java.C#, Rust?
- rdevsrex 4y agoThe only time I used Crystal for work was for creating zip files from a virtual file system in the database that fetched the real file files from S3. It was pretty easy to write, but I kept on having some issues with the part of the standard library that handled the zipping. As Crystal is kinda a small community, I didn't get a lot of feedback from the forums. So I just took a day to rewrite in Go, and its zip library worked great. I'm sure I could have got it working with Crystal if I had more time. I haven't done anything else, but it was fun writing it.
- phil294 4y agoI have recently learned to use it to create an AutoHotkey for Linux implementation (https://github.com/phil294/AHK_X11 https://github.com/phil294/AHK_X11), and it's been a delightful experience. If you like programming in Go and Ruby syntax, this will be your go to language. Other than that, it bears but few surprises, which I would consider a good thing. Its major downside is its compilation time and poor IDE support. Also, you should not be afraid to search through Crystal's GitHub issues or dig into the well designed stdlib's source for more exotic use cases. However, the latter is as easily accessible as is your own code, and the community around Crystal seems quite friendly and welcoming. Contrary to sibling comments, I find it well suited for programs outside of web development as well. And most of all, it's fast.
- hota_mazi 4y ago> I enjoy writing Ruby, but I hate maintaining it. This is the curse of all dynamically typed languages: they make the developer's life easier at the expense of the future maintainer of the code. Because there are no type annotations, writing code is a lot easier than reading it. Which is the exact opposite of what we want.
- cutler 4y agoRails clone?
- jbverschoor 4y agoYeah, I never like it when they don’t simply state that’s the case.
- jbverschoor 4y agoIt's in the acknowledgements sections. https://martenframework.com/docs/the-marten-project/acknowledgements https://martenframework.com/docs/the-marten-project/acknowle...
- joshmn 4y agoWhat's your definition of Rails clone? MVC? If it is, sure, yeah, this and a whole bunch of other frameworks are Rails clones. Laravel is a Rails clone. Django is a Rails clone. We're all Rails clones! Does the design of some of the logic look heavily-inspired by Rails? Sure, and I think it's a great choice. But in reality, calling it a Rails clone is a disservice to Rails. Rails is much more than MVC and patterns implemented from Patterns of Enterprise Application Architecture. The power of Rails isn't in any single one of the patterns — sure, it may have started that way when it was common to ship PHP copy-pasted from php.net and deployed using Filezilla (or explorer.exe!) — but since, what, 2.3? the power of it has been it's ecosystem: nothing can come close to the vastness and maturity of Rubygems.
- Scarbutt 4y agoI don't know, the vastness of the JS ecosystem seems bigger to me? I have come across many third party service providers that do not offer Ruby SDKs but do for JS,Java,Python etc...
- 0xblinq 4y agoI think the Laravel ecosystem is pretty comparable, if not better, than the rails one.
- 4y ago
- mtrycz2 4y agoAll I want form a framework is for it to be boring. Am I the only one? Am I crazy?
- jstummbillig 4y agoI certainly don't mind if a framework is boring, if it comes with qualities I am interested in. Being boring is not one of them – but neither is being exciting.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- antifa 4y agoWhat specifically did you find too exciting about Marten?
- jbverschoor 4y agoCongrats with the release and docs. Curious about: Refresh/compile times, esp with more models and controllers Do you get a single binary for deployment which includes all assets, such as a .war? Is there debugger, similar to the one in rails?
- chrisseaton 4y ago> Do you get a single binary for deployment which includes all assets, such as a .war? I think they mean such as an .exe > Is there debugger, similar to the one in rails? What debugger are you using for Rails? In my experience Rails has been significantly lacking in a debugger (it's improved recently with the debug gem.) (Not an expert.)
- hipster_robot 4y agoA .war file is a Web Application Resource file. It’s a modification of a Jar file which is meant for easy deployment to Java servers. Anyways the answer is, Crystal can be statically compiled in most circumstances. Last I checked OpenSSL was one of the exceptions, but it’s been a year or more since. Amber packs all the static assets into the binary, Lucky doesn’t. I would doubt that Marten does. If not, you get your app server in one binary and the front end assets get deployed separately. Regarding ruby debugging, byebug and pry have been the two approaches for a long time. Pry is a fancy line editor and doesn’t come with a true debugger, but it can be augmented with one. Byebug has full debugging but the interface is a bit archaic. Both work fine with Rails. Interactive debugging with Crystal is still a bit of a pain, but LLDB works with a little fiddling.
- wazbug 4y agoNot a Crystal expert, but the Marten tutorial mentions a `crystal play` command that will run a web-interface with an interactive "playground" that you can interact with your program's functionality in: https://martenframework.com/docs/getting-started/tutorial#interacting-with-model-records https://martenframework.com/docs/getting-started/tutorial#in....
- gortok 4y agoNot to be confused with the C# document database built on Postgres. https://martendb.io/ https://martendb.io/
- prh8 4y agoLove Crystal and love seeing it here more. Ruby has been day job for years, but Crystal is so much fun for side projects and random things to build. Easily approachable, especially for Ruby devs.
- mfkp 4y agoMy company has donated thousands of dollars to the crystal development budget. Always excited to see new additions to the ecosystem! This framework is looking very nice if you're looking for a rails-style framework. I'll definitely give it a shot on my next project.
- noaheverett 4y agoCrystal is the future™ At least that’s what my hope/gut tells me.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- viraptor 4y agoI'd love to see two docs there: - What's different from Lucky https://luckyframework.org/ https://luckyframework.org/ - What's different from Amber https://amberframework.org/ https://amberframework.org/ There's probably something exciting there, but finding out the differences in features for yourself... please don't make me do that.
- akudha 4y agoI'm learning Cyrstal. Do you have any advice on which of the two frameworks you listed should a newcomer try?
- jasonl99 4y agoI've been playing around with crystal for years, and absolutely love it (I'm a full-time ruby dev using Sequel as an ORM). I wish I had more time to spend with crystal. Kemal (referenced above) is really good, and excellent with websockets. That said, I started playing around with the Marten framework and while it's really new, it's an amazingly good start. I absolutely love the way that models automatically create migrations. Using Sqlite as a default is good for probably 99% of uses cases, and absolutely good for learning the framework (Sqlite itself is amazingly powerful). I've been wondering what new shiny toys I was going to play around with over vacation during the holidays, and I now have my answer :).
- noaheverett 4y agoThey’re all good to try IMO, another is https://kemalcr.com https://kemalcr.com which is akin to Sinatra if you just want to get an HTTP server with routes setup quickly.
- speg 4y agoI made my own :) Was not efficient at getting a web project up, but a good way to learn the language itself.
- rishav_sharan 4y agoYou don't even need a framework with Crystal. The stdlib gives you all that you need. I personally do not use any frameworks at all. Coming to your question, Amber is pretty much dead. Lucky or Kemal are the big ones to use. There are also Athena and Azu toolkit.
- ipaddr 4y agoLovely docs. What were they written in?
- staller 4y agolooks like https://docusaurus.io/ https://docusaurus.io/
- chucky123 4y agoKinda tangetial but when I saw the title, I immediately though crystal meth framework lol.
- DeathArrow 4y agoIs Crystal still not usable under Windows?
- hipster_robot 4y agoWindows support has made great leaps forward in the last few releases.