5 ms·
Really? Russia has assassinated or attempted assassination of British citizens and Russian ex-pats on British soil multiple times. They spread radioactive polon
by cmrdporcupine 4y ago
Really? Russia has assassinated or attempted assassination of British citizens and Russian ex-pats on British soil multiple times. They spread radioactive polonium all over the London transit system and put a British police officer in the hospital in critical care. They've shot down a civilian airliner full of Dutch and other citizens. They've funded far right parties abroad in an attempt to manipulate other country's elections. They've attacked US and other country's electronic infrastructure for years. They've been caught spying and manipulating local country's elections.
The global conflict already existed. It isn't just Ukraine's sovereignty that has been violated.
I fail to see how what NATO is doing now is an escalation. Unless you count "fighting back" as escalatory.
Lavrov and Putin use the language of 1960s anti-imperialism, while acting like a 1800s imperial power.
- mistermann 4y agoHow about we look at the stats on "total body count" (maybe broken down by military and civilian) for the US and Russian militaries over the last, say, 30 years? I like to start with just the raw numbers, and then the narratives used to justify the actions can be layered on top afterwards... I think this can be helpful to better see how the process works.
- mft_ 4y ago…because that’s a major tangent (or straw man; presumably intentional) away from the topic being discussed?
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoHow about don't play stupid whataboutist games in which somehow US crimes justify Russian ones? FWIW I'm not a citizen of either country, and my country didn't kill Iraqis because our citizens forced our government to not get involved. In my ideal world Lavrov would be held in the same prison cell as Kissinger.
- hackinthebochs 4y ago>How about don't play stupid whataboutist games in which somehow US crimes justify Russian ones? It's not whataboutism, its pointing out the absurdity that we're heading towards a nuclear showdown over the very same acts the U.S. regularly engages in, even within recent memory. It's pointing out that the moral arguments only apply when the aggressors are not the U.S. This is not whataboutism, this is pointing out hypocrisy and naked manipulation.
- cmrdporcupine 4y ago> "It's pointing out that the moral arguments only apply when the aggressors are not the U.S. " I don't know where you were the night & weekend that the US started bombing in Iraq, but I was in the streets marching. I spent most of my teens 20s and 30s being active against US imperialism. So, yes, it's infantile whataboutism and strawman making. I and many others who take a stand against Russia's actions in Ukraine and elsewhere don't conform to this strawman image you and others have made. The crimes of the US do not justify the crimes of Russia, and I for one am glad to see consequences enforced against Putin's regime. Similar limits should also exist for US actions.
- hackinthebochs 4y ago>I spent most of my teens 20s and 30s being active against US imperialism. This isn't an issue of your personal credence, it's an issue of the arguments used to justify our current course of action by the decision-makers and their enablers. >and I for one am glad to see consequences enforced against Putin's regime. Similar limits should also exist for US actions. The problem is that no one defines exactly what "consequences" are and where the lines are. These discussions never go well so let's just skip to the end: is it your opinion that the U.S. should ensure Russia fully retreats from Ukraine, up to and including a nuclear exchange? (when the reply button isn't active you can click on the comment's timestamp and reply there)
- mistermann 4y ago
- prvit 4y agoThe total body count for US military in the past 30 years is almost certainly less than the total body count for Russian military in the past 9 months. The vast majority of the deaths in middle eastern conflicts were caused by locals, not US troops. Not to even mention that hardly any US troops died, but Russian troops are dying by the tens of thousands.
- hackinthebochs 4y agoOnly if you don't count the knock-on effects of US policy, which is absurd.
- prvit 4y agoNo, not really. It’s silly to blame the US for actions of other groups working to pursue their own goals.
- hackinthebochs 4y agoThe predictable result of groups that the US unleashed by bad decisions and creating a power vacuum? Yes, they own it.
- prvit 4y agoWhy do you think it’s ok to strip those people of their agency like that? Is it because they’re brown and you consider them to be primitive people?
- hackinthebochs 4y agoArguments like this are so transparent. Do better.
- prvit 4y agoYour argument is akin to blaming NATO for the war in Ukraine.
- jacknews 4y agoObviously these are symptoms of a rotten regime to some extent, but clearly motivated by something. Is it overzealous imperial ambition, or the reverse, fear of being marginalized or even overrun? I remember at one point after the fall of Soviet Russia the new CIS being cheered at the Olympics. It seemed they could be part of a greater Europe, and everything would be great. I wonder why that fell apart. Did USA decide that would detract from US power, and 'encouraged' everyone to shun Russia? If that's the case, who's really the bad guy? The point is, there's much more history and politics and ambition going on than the crass headlines.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoThe process of privatization of Soviet assets was a feeding frenzy of corruption and desperation that we cannot even begin to comprehend in the west. Neo-liberal ideologues in the west were implicated in those policy choices, and rightfully hated for it. Putin and his strong men moved in to "clean up" that mess, and forced a slightly more responsible kleptocratic regime in. And replaced Soviet era Stalinist ideology with intense conservative nationalism that -- alongside super high energy sector profits -- stabilized Russian society. Except it has done so with an explicitly anti-western focus. There's no chance of hugging and getting along here. Too many competing interests. But it need not have been this hostile. NATO's expansion into Poland and the Baltics etc. can be seen in many ways, but if I were living next to Russia I myself would probably welcome it. Official ideology in Russia is explicitly imperial and ethno-supremacist in an open and brutal way that clearly requires containment. NATO has a complicated history and structure that I can't always support, but it is the only tool that is going to work at this time.
- jacknews 4y agoSo basically they are irredeemably the bad guys.
- Guthur 4y agoIs everyone on this thread a bot or paid NSA agent? You all need to check this racist rhetoric. The facts on the ground are that over the last 30 years the only country that has consistently carried out military death dealing operations (we talking in the order of 100 operations) throughout the world and far from their own borders are the US and their NATO military alliance. This whole situation is nonsensical and it's more likely to get us all incinerated in nuclear hellfire than achieve anything the majority of the world population want.
- baud147258 4y ago> They've funded far right parties abroad in an attempt to manipulate other country's elections. They've been caught spying and manipulating local country's elections. It's not as if the US had never interfered or spied on elections abroad...