6 ms·
PS4/PS5 exploit that is “essentially unpatchable”
- batch12 4y agoFlashing back to the way Sony handled the PS3 OtherOS exploits, I think its likely if they can't fix an issue with the PS2 emulation, they'll remove/block the feature. I won't be surprised if the ability to emulate PS2 games is removed citing 'security concerns'.
- bigbluedots 4y agoI wouldn't be surprised if there's an update that removes PS2 emulation very soon. Small blast radius anyway as it's unlikely there are many users who use this functionality.
- MereInterest 4y agoIt would also be a pretty open-and-shut case of false advertising.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoI play some PS2 games on PS4. There's one game in particular that I really like: Ace Combat 5. If I get an update and my PS4 becomes unable to play this game, I will never purchase anything from them ever again.
- jonhohle 4y agoIt’s not arbitrary PS2 emulation. They have a PS2 emulator that they customize and bundle with classic PS2 games. Some of those games have been published physically and will have an unpatched emulator on disc. The PS4/5 don’t have PS2 emulators as part of their OS like some versions of the PS3 did. Edit to clarify: you can’t put in a PS2 disc into a PS4/5 and play it. You purchase a PS4/5 release of some previously PS2 era game that comes with an emulator.
- bigbluedots 4y agoThank you for clarifying, I guess that would mean there's nothing to patch.
- VWWHFSfQ 4y agoThe patch is to block playing those physical discs without an emulator update via PSN
- bitwize 4y agoSome versions of the PS3 had PS2 hardware inside, that's how they were able to play PS2 games.
- jonhohle 4y agoAnd some had partial hardware and partial software emulation.
- snvzz 4y agoGood. It'll reduce the e-waste when Sony abandons these consoles.
- highwaylights 4y agoThe title seems like clickbait from the article. It’s a partial exploit of the PS2 emulator inside a PS4 game that may not be patchable without removing those titles, that can lead to partial exploitation of the PS4 emulation to run other PS4 games. It does not exploit the PS5 hypervisor, so at its best allows running homebrew inside the PS4 emulator unless someone has another exploit that would lead to arbitrary execution on the PS5 - but if that was the case then this would likely be moot anyway.
- Kognito 4y agoA bit of a stretch to call it “unpatchable”. The end of the article concedes it’s more that Sony doesn’t seem interested in patching it, presumably they don’t think it’s a sufficient threat (I tend to agree). Yes, the PS2 emulator is bundled with the game but given most are digital downloads, it’s trivial to patch those. If Sony wanted, they could push firmware updates to block the few disc games from running without downloading the latest patched version. So yes, it’s unpatchable if by that you mean there’s no way for Sony to force their way into your home and patch it if you’re willing to live with a console disconnected from PSN. Enjoy running that N64 emulator on your now mostly useless PS5 - I guess.
- willcipriano 4y ago> Enjoy running that N64 emulator on your now mostly useless PS5 - I guess Give it time. This stuff always gets better. The og Xbox hacked was great and I've heard good things about the Wii.
- ghusto 4y ago> if you’re willing to live with a console disconnected from PSN. Enjoy running that N64 emulator on your now mostly useless PS5 I wait for prices to go down to sane levels before buying consoles and games, so I don't have a PS4 yet. However, offline is how I run all my consoles. Just double checked, and physical media is still a thing on the PS4. What do you mean "useless"? As in the games need patching before being playable, or is it just the online features you deem essential?
- vlunkr 4y agoNo patches, no online features, no digital-only games. As a side note, they stopped manufacturing the PS4, the price is unlikely to go down much further at this point.
- dec0dedab0de 4y agoI have notice that the price is usually the lowest when a console is two generations behind. After that there is a bit of resurgence from nostalgia collecting.
- greyface- 4y agoPreviously: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32855476 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32855476
- prvit 4y ago“essentially unfixable”? Ars are essentially liars.
- kevingadd 4y ago"essentially unfixable" or "essentially unpatchable" feel right in the sense that you can't block it for good without removing the PS2 emulator's ability to JIT arbitrary code. But you can just remove the emulator, which is a solution for the fact that you can't really "patch" or "fix" the hole since it's a design hole. For most developers removing it would not be an acceptable fix or patch, but Sony has historically been happy to shoot products in the head even after people paid for them, so it's probably not off-limits here.
- prvit 4y agoThey could also just patch the ps2 game embedded in the emulator. Just like they’d presumably do if they found an exploitable bug in a native PS4/PS5 game.
- FroshKiller 4y ago"Just" always does a lot of work, but "just" is doing a hell of a lot of work in this case. Who's doing the work to create the patch? Who's paying for the work? Who's doing QA, and who's paying for that? What makes you think the source code and assets even exist for all exploitable games, let alone that all can be rebuilt, let alone that all can be meaningfully retested?
- Bjartr 4y agoFor what it's worth, adding a bounds check could be reasonably added to the compiled binary directly. Even if it can't be rebuilt from source.
- anonymousab 4y agoIt is nonetheless doable. A bit expensive but not much moreso than any other game-specific intervention. To call it unpatchable is quite hyperbolic.
- dontbenebby 4y agoDoes anyone else remember that magical moment when you could physically insert a Gameshark[0] into the back of the Playstation and achieve basically the same thing? It used to be a literal, physical device, similar to the technology used by Sonic & Knuckles[0]. I remember someone explained to me, after the family PC got infected with some malware that folks get MUCH angrier if you're messing around in a networked game like Starcraft than something offline like... Pokemon. This was back when they were transitioning to CD-ROMs to distribute the games, and IMHO understandably afraid they'd spend R&D money on things like which controller designs work best, then go pirate all the games. Anyways, I suspect of years of treating minors abusively is catching up with the world, as you see things like this exploit, Solarwinds[2], the Texas grid failure[2]... these are all separate "cyber" issues connected by a common thread: the United States has some that have a state income tax, and some that don't, and people can move freely between them. Like... seriously... did people not plan for a future when people sigh, pretend not to understand your weird Myspace drama, and pay for a quad espresso in cash so they can go do whatever they want on the wifi? I've seen so many people say that X shouldn't be done because something could be a server for a hospital, or an airport or something. But I don't think any hospitals are running the FTP server to upload crime scene photos on a Playstation. Maybe for Devil's night someone should brick every single one of them to cut down on the amount of bored teenagers running around with... command line skills. (Sorry to ramble, I'm doing what I started sarcastically referring to as my "executive time" during the Trump administration -- if the signal is sometimes useful you can't complain it's also sometimes weird as hell.) - Greg. -- [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GameShark https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GameShark [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonic_%26_Knuckles#Lock-on_technology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonic_%26_Knuckles#Lock-on_tec... [2] https://www.npr.org/2021/02/17/968577281/what-went-wrong-with-the-electric-grid-in-texas https://www.npr.org/2021/02/17/968577281/what-went-wrong-wit...
- kuramitropolis 4y agoYou gotta clarify on some of the connections you're making. They're the kind of connections that people usually soft-lobotomize themselves into not making
- iwillbenice 4y ago
- grecy 4y agoThe JIT emulator for PS2 sounds fascinating - are there many public details about it?
- worewood 4y ago> a specially formatted save file on the memory card, leading to a buffer overflow that gives access to otherwise protected memory > ... Then CTurt used the system's USB save import feature to get that file onto the target system. > ... one of the few PS2 games released as physical, PS4-compatible discs As the number of such games is limited, it would be trivial to implement a save-file validation parser in the USB save import feature for these games and push it as a mandatory update. For digitally delivered titles, then you can patch the emulator. (EDIT: unless, the save file contains executable code. Seen it before, done as an obfuscation technique. Next point still apllies, though) Also, > had to use an already-hacked PS4 to digitally sign a modified Okage Shadow King save file, letting it work with his PSN ID. For that, change the workflow so that at each SW update you generate a new certificate. Upon releasing a new FW version, revoke all previous certificates.
- aliqot 4y agoTo be a fly on the wall at Geohotz's office right now..
- efficax 4y agowhy don’t they just let me install linux on my ps4. what’s the danger here take to their business?
- kazinator 4y agoFor the benefit of those who prudently read HN comments first so as not to fall for clickbait, here is what "unpatchable" means: > that means the exploit should continue to work as long as you refuse any online updates before playing. And for digital releases, even if the exploit is later patched out, there are methods to downgrade to a stored, exploitable version using proxy HTTP traffic from a local server.
- anxiously 4y agoI see this as a good excuse to no longer be backwards compatible by Sony.
- blooalien 4y agoYeah, I was gonna say … Sony was willing to sell PS3 on the promise you could run Linux on it, then take that capability away after the fact, so why would they not be willing to kill backward compatibility just as readily? Not "unpatchable" at all if Sony's willing to take that path.
- Ptchd 4y agoThat's what I like to hear, for you, shit company Sony.
- regular 4y ago"a proof-of-concept method that should allow for the installation of arbitrary homebrew applications on the consoles." Good. That should be allowed anyway.