3 ms·
Ads. It's not about technology. It's about ads.
by Animats 4y ago
Ads. It's not about technology. It's about ads.
- nonrandomstring 4y agoIt's about control. Ads are a weak(ish) form of control (more powerful than we believe) but only one of many. TBH I've hardly heard the word "techlash" since I cited it in Digital Vegan as an Economist headline. It never really got traction. But the article is correct in identifying it as a moment of reflective realisation rather than a substantial movement. And perhaps in locating it in a dislike of Big-Tech personalities as much as any experienced harm. Today I'm more cognisant of "peak tech", a tangible bend on the curve that seems to be about limits of attention, practical connectivity, exhaustion with gadgets and a limit on how many times the same app can be re-branded "Now with AI". On the other hand there remains a more serious branch to contemporary tech critique. For that I prefer the term "Technofascism", because it's got a bit more fuck-you built into it. Despite widespread awareness there's precious little action beyond Software Freedom, or ability to turn to meaningful choice and "take-back tech". I suppose a regular one-minute-hate of screaming insults at Mark Zuckerberg makes a good safety valve to distract from the real FaceBoot.
- upsidesinclude 4y ago>I've hardly heard the word "techlash" I'd hardly call that a wonder considering the avenues. That would be technofascists at work. Don't be surprised to find a vast number of people have either no clue or no concern about what controls are in place for them.
- alexvoda 4y agoI think ads are a major component of this but not the only one. (See a recent top HN post about chumboxes. It is hard to not become cynical.) You also have: - growing complexity beyond the comprehension of a person resulting in fear of unknown - plain old disinformation and conspiracy theorising - an abundance of brain dead behaviour on the part of technology creators (see the recent article about the glovebox you can only open from the touchscreen) - plenty of bad behaviour on the part of corporations I do not think the techlash is unjustified yet I think technology is an inseparable aspect of humanity. I think the main cause is a crisis of misaligned incentives which on the surface are coherent. The corporate social structure is no longer capable of functioning as an engine for betterment of humanity.