2 ms·
There is a pervasive theme in this comment that labelling people is an action that helps them. Maybe. In some cases yes. But it is suspicious generality - ther
by roenxi 4y ago
There is a pervasive theme in this comment that labelling people is an action that helps them. Maybe. In some cases yes.
But it is suspicious generality - there are also a lot of cases where people being labelled is an action that harms them. Especially since all the sciences involving the human mind have long histories of quackery, failure and discrimination to draw on. The results are rarely clear and the goals of the people involved are cloudy.
There is probably some balance between the perspectives here and finding it is the real question here.
- robbiep 4y agoThis isn’t my field so trying to speak with any authority isn’t possible but amongst my close colleagues we feel that pervasive labelling and the need to name every phase ends up creating in some people ‘tethers’ around which a person’s entire psychological makeup revolves. It’s good to forget sometimes. Ie person goes through bad breakup. Would meet clinical (DSM-V) depression definition. After a year goes and sees a therapist and gets on antidepressants. Begins to feel good. Stays with therapy. The rest of their life is now a pivot point around that breakup. They’re labelled as depressed. Other stuff comes up. In some worlds, maybe that’s necessary. In others, maybe they come good, make lifestyle changes, find happiness again, and don’t have the label or the antidepressants for life.