2 ms·
It's utterly amazing how flagrantly these posh-dole recipients will shamelessly gaslight us. The sine qua non of capitalism is that it's distributed. What has d
by mindslight 4y ago
It's utterly amazing how flagrantly these posh-dole recipients will shamelessly gaslight us. The sine qua non of capitalism is that it's distributed. What has destroyed and continues to destroy capitalism is the Fed keeping interest rates ridiculously low, going on (at least) three decades now. All of those artifically-cheap "loans" are newly created money being given to the financial industry and handwaved away as "value neutral", while it's anything but. The real estate bubble, the stock market bubble, the auto loan bubble, the college bubble. Everywhere individuals are priced out of transacting directly and banks have stepped in to financialize our lives - it's all been fostered by these central-planning puppet masters, giving us a Potemkin village of "growth" while the real distributed economy gets more hollowed out as its wealth is sucked into the cancerous financial industry with much ultimately wasted on make-work jobs.
And then to have the gall to say that rates going up ever so slightly is "destroying capitalism" ? If you want to know where the blind populist rage driving support for burn it all down candidates comes from, it's right here. If you want to know why "young people" are rejecting "late stage capitalism", it's right here. Heads they win, tails you lose.
- koyanisqatsi 4y agoHow is capitalism distributed if the federal government is the only entity with the authority to print money?
- mindslight 4y agoThe same way capitalism can be considered distributed even though the government is the only entity with the authority to tax. The government could ramp tax rates up to 95% and then redistribute the proceeds as it sees fit. But to the extent it does not, then we get a more distributed outcome. Specifically about the structure of capitalism, capital should remain distributed a certain amount, so that many different competing entities have the resources to enact their own decisions. The extreme end of capital being centralized would be called authoritarianism, with ultimate ownership of everything vesting in the state.
- koyanisqatsi 4y agoSo then an even distribution of money is "distributed capitalism" by your definitions, correct?
- mindslight 4y agoDo you have a larger point, or are you just trying to play some game of Internet Gotcha? It matters how the distribution was arrived at. If it happened as the result of decentralized market activity, say market optimization versus marginal utility, great. If it was gathered up by the government and then redistributed, that is obviously the result of centralization.
- koyanisqatsi 4y agoJust trying to figure out how exactly an even distribution of money is not distributed capitalism as you defined it. So sounds like if the market magically made everyone equally rich (or poor) you would consider that distributed capitalism but if it was done through taxation then you wouldn't. Did I get that right?
- mindslight 4y agoAn even distribution of money (and I presume you mean assets, too) would imply a decentralization of purchasing power. But if it were arrived at through taxation and redistribution, then the overall economic power would still be centrally administered. Such a scheme would intrinsically require a bunch of laws to regulate what "even" means, who is in scope, what can be saved, incentivize performing transactions despite "evening out", etc. That's all centralized structure. Conversely, if the financial industry had grown into the centralized behemoth it has become without trillions in government handouts, then it would make sense to say that decentralized capitalism only ever exists as temporary stage and is ultimately doomed as the big players collect all the chips. This is the conclusion a lot of people have come to about "late stage capitalism", but I'd say they're ignoring the trillions in government subsidies that feed the centralized structure. FWIW in the context of your profile, I think slowing financial industry subsidies (first step, raising interest rates) would go a long way towards reducing natural resource usage. Monetary policy certainly isn't going to stop anyone from dumping plastic into the ocean, but it would cause less throwaway plastic crap to be produced in the first place.