3 ms·
This is the explaination given by the originator of the story (from the article). As a parent, it's pretty clear to me that this was a story invented by a mom w
by lolinder 4y ago
This is the explaination given by the originator of the story (from the article). As a parent, it's pretty clear to me that this was a story invented by a mom who didn't feel it was the right time to have a conversation about slave labor.
> In 1970, Toronto’s John McManus was my guest in Seattle. I chatted to him about what happened when I was a refugee in wartime Guangxi. The journey from Liuzhou to Guiping was by river, and there were men on the banks whose job was to drag the boat with ropes. There was also an overseer armed with a whip. According to my mother, the whipper was hired to do just that by the boatmen! My tale went the rounds, and it was seized by a number of neo-institutional economists. . . . However, this could be a story invented by my mother – the smartest person I have ever known – to entertain a boy of seven!
- onos 4y agoYes, Tldr his mom told him the story and he does not know if it’s true.
- lolinder 4y agoHe doesn't come right out and say he thinks it wasn't true, but it's pretty obvious from the quote that he doubts it. When the original teller doesn't believe his own story and the story flies in the face of everything we know about human nature and the story can be fully explained as a mom trying to shelter her son (which is very much human nature), I think we can go with "fake story" as the most likely hypothesis.