3 ms·
> despite the memes. As far as I can determine the typical commenter believes that a lithium-ion battery is just solid lithium. I believe this is a result of a
by jeffbee 4y ago
> despite the memes.
As far as I can determine the typical commenter believes that a lithium-ion battery is just solid lithium. I believe this is a result of a sustained campaign of disinformation driven by fossil fuel interests.
In reality, a standard 18650 cell contains less than a gram of lithium.
- Manuel_D 4y agoWho cares about breakdown by mass. Break a battery cell down by cost: https://www.visualcapitalist.com/breaking-down-the-cost-of-an-ev-battery-cell/ https://www.visualcapitalist.com/breaking-down-the-cost-of-a... The cathode alone contributes to half of the cost of a lithium ion battery. Shortages of lithium are indeed driving up the prices of batteries. If doesn't matter if a small amount of it is necessary, if obtaining even that small amount is expensive.
- jeffbee 4y agoAnd yet, all battery makers are continuously reducing the need for expensive materials in their cathodes, because humans respond to incentives. Never bet against human ingenuity.
- Manuel_D 4y agoAnd yet, battery costs are still rising: https://asia.nikkei.com/Spotlight/Market-Spotlight/Battery-costs-rise-as-lithium-demand-outstrips-supply https://asia.nikkei.com/Spotlight/Market-Spotlight/Battery-c... Ingenuity can't change thermodynamics. There's a minimum amount of lithium necessary to hold a charge. Realistically the only reliable path of grid scale battery storage is a different batter chemistry, but none has proven as effective as lithium ion so far.
- jeffbee 4y agoThe minimum amount of lithium necessary for utility-scale batteries is zero because many of them are made of lead-acid batteries, because nobody gives a damn how bulky and massive a battery is in fixed service. This has nothing to do with thermodynamics and everything to do with you parroting anti-renewable propaganda.
- Manuel_D 4y agoLead acid batteries have much lower life cycles. Often around 300 cycles at 80% depth of discharge. True, bulk does not matter. But replacing your batteries every year absolutely does. That's why most battery storage projects use lithium batteries.
- bee_rider 4y agoSo then it isn't a law of thermodynamics that a certain amount of lithium is required to hold a charge? The problem with your post that kicked off this tangent is that obviously human ingenuity includes the ability to look at other materials if necessary...
- Manuel_D 4y agoSure, you can look at completely different battery chemistries, like lead acid or iron. But so far they've all got detriments that make them less desirable than lithium based chemistries. Heck, you can zoom out and propose storage mechanisms other than electrochemical. That true, but again most of the talk is focused on lithium ion batteries because that's presently the most effective option.
- ben_w 4y ago> That true, but again most of the talk is focused on lithium ion batteries because that's presently the most effective option. "Most effective" varies between use cases. LiIon is fantastic for drones and personal electronics, but the reason it's used for cars is that Elon Musk is a very capable salesman and he bet on it — ten years ago, when Tesla was a cute startup but not a manufacturing behemoth, most of the talk I remember was still about hydrogen fuel cells. I think used car batteries are likely to be a significant part of the global power grid because there will be enough of them, and it's a good reuse option before they need to be fully recycled into new car batteries. If they're cheap enough to use directly in this way (and they seem to be already in some specific circumstances), great. If not, doesn't matter too much, there are too many alternatives for me to worry about it.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoCATL seem to disagree with that last point https://www.caixinglobal.com/2022-10-25/catl-aims-to-mass-produce-sodium-ion-batteries-in-2023-101955814.html https://www.caixinglobal.com/2022-10-25/catl-aims-to-mass-pr...
- Manuel_D 4y agoThis is an entirely different battery chemistry, it's not even using lithium.
- ben_w 4y agoWhich is enough to invalidate what you wrote: > There's a minimum amount of lithium necessary to hold a charge. Realistically the only reliable path of grid scale battery storage is a different batter chemistry, but none has proven as effective as lithium ion so far.
- Manuel_D 4y agoThe point is that the big order-of-magnitude gains in lithium ion batteries during the 1990s is not possible today, since they're already pushed near their limit. Given that the cement talks about a minimum amounts of lithium to hold a charge, good faith readers are capable of comprehending that this is talking about lithium based battery chemistries.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoSo what scales better? Off river PHES is cheaper, but limited in scope. Electrolysis works but only for long duration. PWRs have no fuel supply if expanded. They also cost more and the historic highest construction is not to the same scale as the current renewable + lithium battery supply chain.
- tuatoru 4y ago> I believe this is a result of a sustained campaign of disinformation Don't waste your energy. The ignorance of the 75th percentile journalist is stunningly broad and deep; it's no wonder that ordinary people haven't a clue.
- ben_w 4y agoWhile you are mostly correct, I think "don't waste your energy" is a memetic hazard. We all do that, we're back to superstition and magical thinking, not civilisation.