7 ms·
Backing intermittent sources with dispatchable generation is a solution, but not the only solution (energy storage and deferring loads are some alternatives for
by bee_rider 4y ago
Backing intermittent sources with dispatchable generation is a solution, but not the only solution (energy storage and deferring loads are some alternatives for example).
The cost of the fuel also doesn't account for costs they can externalize (ecosystem, healthcare) and the political issues it causes (Saudi Arabia gets by with more shit than they would otherwise, Russia is a big problem).
- epistasis 4y agoPeople also severely overestimate the cost of battery storage today, and underestimate the cost curve of how it's decreasing. For example, for batteries charged directly from a paired solar installation, the cost is estimated to be $85-$158/MWh. [0] The rest of the solar instal costs $28-$37/MWh, unsubsidized. If 3/4 of energy consumption is from the primary solar install, and 1/4 from storage, then you have a firm energy source at a cost of $42-$67/MWh. The national average for generation cost of electricity is something like $50-$60/MWh, (with the rest of the average price of $130/MWh going to transmission and distribution). So today, solar plus storage offers cost competitive, zero carbon energy in the average US location. And costs are going to drop by 50% over the next decade or two. We have a really bright energy future, where energy is cheap and plentiful and carbon free. And the faster we build new renewable resources, the faster the technology gets better, and the faster the prices drop. Slowing down the deployment of renewables is a huge risk that makes us all poorer, and also happens to make our climate challenge worse. We should be doing everything we can to massively expand solar wind and battery production capacity and deployment, as fast as possible. The tech is ready, it just needs to be deployed. [0] https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-levelized-cost-of-storage-and-levelized-cost-of-hydrogen/ https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-...
- dahfizz 4y agoWhere are the terawatts of batreries coming from? It will be decades before we have the manufacturing capacity to make that many batteries, assuming we have the natural resources to make that possible. Batteries are reasonably priced per unit, but they do not scale reasonably. Batteries will not provide grid scale storage in our lifetime, IMO. I think the concept of grid scale storage is misguided Fission (and hopefully fusion) can provide base load at all times, with as much wind & solar as needed to provide for variable load.
- throwaway5959 4y agoI’m going to guess lots of factories that we mass produce, aka gigafactories.
- ben_w 4y ago> Where are the terawatts of batreries coming from? The usual place: factories. Which are getting built as fast as people can get the investment money and the planning permits. > It will be decades before we have the manufacturing capacity to make that many batteries, Even if that was correct (from what I've seen, half of what we need is already being planned and is scheduled for completion before 2030), even then it would be fine, as we only have a critical need of them when renewables become a dominant part of the power grid. > assuming we have the natural resources to make that possible. We do, despite the memes. > I think the concept of grid scale storage is misguided Fission (and hopefully fusion) can provide base load at all times If the whole world did that with fission, we'd run out of fissile materials pretty fast.
- jeffbee 4y ago> despite the memes. As far as I can determine the typical commenter believes that a lithium-ion battery is just solid lithium. I believe this is a result of a sustained campaign of disinformation driven by fossil fuel interests. In reality, a standard 18650 cell contains less than a gram of lithium.
- Manuel_D 4y agoWho cares about breakdown by mass. Break a battery cell down by cost: https://www.visualcapitalist.com/breaking-down-the-cost-of-an-ev-battery-cell/ https://www.visualcapitalist.com/breaking-down-the-cost-of-a... The cathode alone contributes to half of the cost of a lithium ion battery. Shortages of lithium are indeed driving up the prices of batteries. If doesn't matter if a small amount of it is necessary, if obtaining even that small amount is expensive.
- jeffbee 4y ago
- lob_it 4y agoDiversification already has lingo for this in the 21st century: 1) Blue sky innovation - most intermittent renewables. They have toxic downsides too. 2) Gray sky innovation - Oil, gas, nuclear, etc fit perfectly here. Much of it is tried and true technology... And yes, it has downsides too 3) No-sky innovation - With space exploration, energy on the moon, mars, spacecraft, etc may be better served with laminar flow rotors using light/lasers... Just another option with diversification. It looks like stats on 50% of the plastic on the planet have been created after 2006 seem legit, with the trash heaps in the oceans (not to mention plastic breaking down into water system contaminates). Battery technology recycling just looks like another source of toxic groundwater for future generations, since recycling has been gibberish with pretty words thus far. The reuseable rocket technologies mean that battery technology, nuclear waste, etc can be jettisoned towards the sun after their useful life and that landfills may be a thing of the past. Know your innovations and how well diversification copes with the farce of "one size fits all". Four seasons still exist in many places.
- Manuel_D 4y agoQuite the contrary, people vastly underestimate the cost of battery storage and neglect the fact that it's cost is increasing as input materials become more scarce. Actual real-world cost of deployment is mugh higher than estimates [1] frequently exceeding $500/kWh. Estimates often exclude the cost of installation, maintenance, transformers to handle voltage conversion, etc. This is how $130/KWh battery costs turn into over $500/KWh of real world cost. Furthermore, the existing global production figures are somewhere around 400GWh per year. The world uses 60 TWh of electricity per day. Even just one day's worth of storage would mean dedicating 100% of battery production to grid storage for over a century. Actually attempting to providing a significant amount of battery storage would spike the cost of batteries as demand exceeds supply. The input materials for batteries have seen skyrocketing costs in the last couple years [2], and only 24% of battery cost is manufacturing. The rest is input materials. It is very dubious that batter production can keep up with the massive scale required by grid storage. Batteries can (and are) being deployed. But not at a scale that makes any difference, and it's unlikely they ever will be. 1. https://www.utilitydive.com/news/new-york-battery-storage-costs-rise-interconnection-queue-12-gw/621954/ https://www.utilitydive.com/news/new-york-battery-storage-co... 2. https://tradingeconomics.com/commodity/lithium https://tradingeconomics.com/commodity/lithium 3. https://www.visualcapitalist.com/breaking-down-the-cost-of-an-ev-battery-cell/ https://www.visualcapitalist.com/breaking-down-the-cost-of-a...
- epistasis 4y ago> Actual real-world cost of deployment is mugh higher than estimates [1] frequently exceeding $500/kWh. Can you point why you think this number, for installed battery cost, is somehow a contradiction of the numbers I posted? Additionally, temporary supply shortages due to massive new markers opening up as the cost drops is completely expected. All the temporary higher prices finance massive production capacity expansion that drops prices in the future. This is a well understood dynamic that we see again and again, even in fossil due production! > Even just one day's worth of storage would mean dedicating 100% of battery production to grid storage for over a century. There are two extreme errors with writing something like this: 1) assuming that battery production stays constant, when it has been growing 10x/5 years, and we are seeing unprecedented demand for new applications. 2) Using primary energy production for comparison to electrified electricity use, when electrified versions of the fossil fuel versions require 3x-4x less electricity. This sort of basic error is as bad as comparing 1GW of solar to 1GW of nuclear without correcting for capacity factor. With reasonable battery production scaling, we will be producing 20-30TWh/year of batteries in a decade. For comparison, it takes more than a decade for us to build a nuclear reactor in the West, so if we are in course to have a fully scaled battery production supply chain for global use, whereas we can't even scale nuclear construction in the US to match the rate at which we will be retiring our aging fleet over the next 20 years. It's time to take a serious look at what carbon-free energy tech is on the table right now and start deploying it as fast as possible, right now, today. At the same time, we should continue research into fanciful ideas like small modular nuclear reactors, in case they pan out. But we need to go to war with the army we have right now.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> for batteries charged directly from a paired solar installation, the cost is estimated to be $85-$158/MWh This is theoretical. When I got home solar quotes, the difference before incentives between an install with and without 27 kWh Tesla backup was over $1,300/kWh.
- epistasis 4y ago$85-$158/MWh is not theoretical, this is real life utility scale installations. Tiny tiny residential scale battery installations have that 5x markup that you are observing. If you were to build your own, it's not hard to get to $300/kWh-capacity, all in, these days, even for small installs of a dozen kWh, using Chinese LFP batteries. But you won't get any of the support that your local installer gives you, and you had better know what you are doing really well...
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> $85-$158/MWh is not theoretical, this is real life utility scale installations Do you have an example? The actual cost in 2019 in the U.S. was $300 to $500/kWh [1]. The cost for the batteries alone was $190, but that’s akin to counting the cost of nuclear power by the fuel alone. [1] https://atb.nrel.gov/electricity/2021/utility-scale_battery_storage https://atb.nrel.gov/electricity/2021/utility-scale_battery_...
- epistasis 4y agoI think you are comparing two different things. The CapEx and installation costs are typically measured in $/kWh for capacity of the battery (though some costs scale by the $/kW, for example the inverters...). The cost of storing and delivering the energy from the battery over its lifetime, is refered to the level used cost of storage. This includes operations costs, debt service, etc. is measured by the cost of delivering energy to the grid, and grid-scale costs are typically measured in $/MWh (as opposed to residential costs typically quotes in $/kWh).
- 4y ago